Trapping System: Grid | Page 46 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

Trapping System: Tunnel Martingale 476 replies

Grid - New indicator that replaces chart grid 60 replies

Grid (not grid system) or horizontal lines indicator 6 replies

Trapping System: Way to Fully-Automated Trading System 47 replies

Grid, Burst Grid, Grid Risk and Grid Profit 1 reply

Attachments: Trapping System: Grid
Exit Attachments

Trapping System: Grid

  • #901
  • Jul 26, 2015 11:17pm Jul 26, 2015 11:17pm
Tickmill demo is back up and running
  • #902
  • Jul 27, 2015 2:39am Jul 27, 2015 2:39am
Thanks for the backtest Igotaplan, but have you tried it only to open during London sessions etc? or does a backtest not work well for this? It would be interesting to see if we can create this test under the ideal conditions the system might enjoy....be great to be able to test the new version soon for backtesting using my tickstory account for 99% backtest data.
  • #903
  • Jul 27, 2015 3:49am Jul 27, 2015 3:49am
Quoting chucrut
{quote} Hi, I'm live since a week with this EA and it look promising, the account is up 8%. My plan is to withdraw weekly 1/2 or 1/3 of the profits made during the week. This make slower the process of compound gains but at the same time can start to amortize the investment.
hi could you tell us your setting?, thank so much
  • #904
  • Edited 5:26am Jul 27, 2015 4:46am | Edited 5:26am
Hi. My settings are these

OrderOperation: STOP orders
OrderCountPerSide: 5
RecreationCountPerSide: 2
LimitOrdersCount: 4
RecreationThreshold: 100
GridStepPoints: 25
CurrentPriceInterval: 30
MagicNumber: 8888
InitialLotsType: Fixed
InitialLots: 0.12
InitialLotsMult: 0,0003
CommentInfo
ProfitTakingMode: Without Comission and Swap
TargetProfit DynamicBase: Balance
TargetType: Fixed
TargetProfit: 15
TargetProfitMult:0,004
Stop Loss Dynamic Base: Balance
Loss TypeNo Stop Loss
Stop Loss -350
Stop Loss Multiplier-00001
CloseTypeTarget Based (Standard)
CloseModeInternal
CountRunningCloseEA0
CheckIsCorruptedFALSO

Fortunately, waiting a few minutes, the price went down, and i won my target profit.

Can somebody help me to protect my account from this situation?

Or your opinion of these settings? Maybe better settings?

It's posible to fix stop loss by trade? For example, if i have 3 buy opened and 4 sell, and the price goes down. I want to close the first "buy" with 200 eur lossing, for example. Not all trades.

I don't know if I'm explaining myself well.

Thank you.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Test.jpg Size: 552 KB
  • #905
  • Jul 27, 2015 5:44am Jul 27, 2015 5:44am
Quoting bolsistico
{quote} hi could you tell us your setting?, thank so much
Hi, already posted here some time ago but ok:

eurusd
Stop orders
Grid step: 55 points
Current price interval: 60 points
Time: from London Open -1h to New York Open
Lots and target fixed: 0.01 for 0.33$ for every 300$ of balance then do the calculation according to your balance (or increase the risk like 0.02 for 0.66$ target for every 300$ of balance, my demos are with 0.03 for 0.99$ target for every 300$ of balance, look my trade explorers. Choose your own risk, high normal or low)
  • #906
  • Jul 27, 2015 5:59am Jul 27, 2015 5:59am
Quoting boxcar
Hi. My settings are these OrderOperation: STOP orders OrderCountPerSide: 5 RecreationCountPerSide: 2 LimitOrdersCount: 4 RecreationThreshold: 100 GridStepPoints: 25 CurrentPriceInterval: 30 MagicNumber: 8888 InitialLotsType: Fixed InitialLots: 0.12 InitialLotsMult: 0,0003 CommentInfo ProfitTakingMode: Without Comission and Swap TargetProfit DynamicBase: Balance TargetType: Fixed TargetProfit: 15 TargetProfitMult:0,004 Stop Loss Dynamic Base: Balance Loss TypeNo Stop Loss Stop Loss -350 Stop Loss Multiplier-00001 CloseTypeTarget Based (Standard)...
Then on that case we need to define Target Buy, and Target Sell.
Then let us say:

  1. the price moves up until 4 buys opened, 1 pending buy and 5 pending sells still not opened, total orders are 10.
  2. Let us assume, since the price moving up and Target Buy is reached then EA will close all opened buys, so 1 pending buy and 5 pending sells still not opened and also 4 opened buys is closed now. Total orders are now 6.
  3. Then the price moves down until 3 sells opened, 1 pending buy and 2 pending sells still not opened. Total orders still 6.
  4. Let us assume at this position, Target Sell is not reached.
  5. Then the price moving up again drastically, 1 pending buy is now opened. Then you'll end up in floating open orders.
  6. If the price is not correcting, your total loss will get bigger and bigger since the total BUY and SELL is imbalance (1 buy and 3 opened sells out of 5 sells).

In that case how will correct the situation?
The idea seems good but I feel this situation is making the opened orders more insecure when it is not trending.

If you ask me to code/fix your EA... it's probably not for free...
  • #907
  • Jul 27, 2015 6:08am Jul 27, 2015 6:08am
Quoting radityo.ardi
{quote} Cool result! So, can you share the settings to us here? And probably let me test it under VPS and see for the next 1 month. Would like to know how's the composition on limit and stop orders (how many limit, and how many stop orders). Actually you're trying to pair this strategy with "few limit orders", am I right? {quote}
Sure i will, in fact in the setup are in the strategy tester. But i am still doing a lot of backtests. Im not 100% happy with the settings.
I will try to come up with a setup this week, i will share and than we can start a demo testing.

  • #908
  • Edited 7:06am Jul 27, 2015 6:28am | Edited 7:06am
It's difficult in a market without trend.

Now, similar situation at this time.

3 buy and 5 sell opened.

Maybe increasing CurrentPriceInterval...

Thank you so much for answer, Radityo.ardi

I will continue with the test
Attached Image(s) (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Test STOPORDERS 2.jpg Size: 610 KB
Click to Enlarge Name: Test STOPORDERS 4.jpg Size: 597 KB
  • #909
  • Jul 27, 2015 6:49am Jul 27, 2015 6:49am
Quoting IgotAplan
{quote} Sure i will, in fact in the setup are in the strategy tester. But i am still doing a lot of backtests. Im not 100% happy with the settings. I will try to come up with a setup this week, i will share and than we can start a demo testing.
Hi IGotAPlan
I tried to backtesting many times but never succeed. In the journals tab always show this error: "TestGenerator: unmatched data error (volume limit 129334 at 2015.07.02 00:00 exceeded)"
I already download from MT4 data center, tried test with lower timeframe etc. but always end up with that error. Never open any orders, and not showing reports nor graph.
Do you know to solve this issue?

Thanx in advance
  • #910
  • Jul 27, 2015 7:12am Jul 27, 2015 7:12am
Quoting dearest
{quote} Hi IGotAPlan I tried to backtesting many times but never succeed. In the journals tab always show this error: "TestGenerator: unmatched data error (volume limit 129334 at 2015.07.02 00:00 exceeded)" I already download from MT4 data center, tried test with lower timeframe etc. but always end up with that error. Never open any orders, and not showing reports nor graph. Do you know to solve this issue? Thanx in advance
I think there are 2 options to solve your problem:

1) Increase the timeframe you are using to do the backtest, anything above M15 should be fine?

2) Tools - Options - Charts - Increase "Max bars in history"

Regards

Vlad
  • #911
  • Jul 27, 2015 8:41am Jul 27, 2015 8:41am
Hi, so it is my first day of forward testing this EA,

I have the standard GTSTOP set on EURUSD - starting balance $100. I have the same setup running on 2 difference clients (2 different brokers) on my VPS

My one setup is with Tickmill and the other with IC Markets.

I started both EA's at the same time this morning, as soon as the Tickmill demo server came back online.

Even though the setups are identical - the results are drastically different:

On tickmill, I have closed trades resulting in 1.75% profits, and current open trades representing 42.12% floating loss!

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Tickmill.PNG Size: 60 KB


On IC Markets I have closed trades representing 21.01% profits, and current open trades representing 10.47% floating loss!

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: IC Markets.PNG Size: 63 KB


Is it normal to have such a drastic difference with the same setup on different brokers? Both accounts are ECN accounts with 1:500 leverage.

Regards

Vlad
  • #912
  • Jul 27, 2015 9:03am Jul 27, 2015 9:03am
Quoting chucrut
{quote} Hi, already posted here some time ago but ok: eurusd Stop orders Grid step: 55 points Current price interval: 60 points Time: from London Open -1h to New York Open Lots and target fixed: 0.01 for 0.33$ for every 300$ of balance then do the calculation according to your balance (or increase the risk like 0.02 for 0.66$ target for every 300$ of balance, my demos are with 0.03 for 0.99$ target for every 300$ of balance, look my trade explorers. Choose your own risk, high normal or low)
thank so much, i thought that it was another new setting
  • #913
  • Jul 27, 2015 9:03am Jul 27, 2015 9:03am
Vlad13685, maybe the difference is the Spread between the Brokers.
  • #914
  • Jul 27, 2015 9:21am Jul 27, 2015 9:21am
Quoting boxcar
Vlad13685, maybe the difference is the Spread between the Brokers.
Hi, there is almost no difference between the spread - 3 points vs 2 points etc.
  • #915
  • Jul 27, 2015 9:39am Jul 27, 2015 9:39am
Hi Vlad
Are those accounts demo?
My Tickmill demo accounts didnt start trading/updating before this morning....i think they had some errors at market openings.
Hope that helps
SunGaard
  • #916
  • Jul 27, 2015 9:46am Jul 27, 2015 9:46am
Quoting SunGaard
Hi Vlad Are those accounts demo? My Tickmill demo accounts didnt start trading/updating before this morning....i think they had some errors at market openings. Hope that helps SunGaard
Hey SunGaard,

Yes both accounts are demo. Yup saw the downtime on Tickmill demo, but I started both EA's at the same time when Tickmill came online again (about 6am GMT).

Regards

Vlad
  • #917
  • Jul 27, 2015 10:22am Jul 27, 2015 10:22am
Quoting Vlad13685
Hi, so it is my first day of forward testing this EA, I have the standard GTSTOP set on EURUSD - starting balance $100. I have the same setup running on 2 difference clients (2 different brokers) on my VPS My one setup is with Tickmill and the other with IC Markets. I started both EA's at the same time this morning, as soon as the Tickmill demo server came back online. Even though the setups are identical - the results are drastically different: On tickmill, I have closed trades resulting in 1.75% profits, and current open trades representing 42.12%...
Hi Vlad,
These differences apparently is quite normal I would say. As I have pointed out in previous post, even the same broker will also have different result as it maybe because of the starting time factor. That's why I have emphasized over this thread, to test and test and test if you want to start trading with this EA. Moreover, it will be good if you have multiple different profitable set file with different style, like one with limit, the others with stop for example.
You need to look not just simply spreads and leverage, but other factors like stop out level and margin call level, execution time, execution type, even spreads when it is on high impact news, then even the same pair like EURUSD will have a bit (verry small) different character from one broker to another. This is the factors that sometimes people never seen this, although actually broker will make the price exactly the same with market conditions but it can't be exactly 100%.
My suggestion is to keep observing what would be the best setting for broker A and then check again for broker B...so on and so forth... Tweaking the settings a little bit would help.
If you ask me to code/fix your EA... it's probably not for free...
  • #918
  • Jul 27, 2015 11:01am Jul 27, 2015 11:01am
Quoting radityo.ardi
{quote} Hi Vlad, These differences apparently is quite normal I would say. As I have pointed out in previous post, even the same broker will also have different result as it maybe because of the starting time factor. That's why I have emphasized over this thread, to test and test and test if you want to start trading with this EA. Moreover, it will be good if you have multiple different profitable set file with different style, like one with limit, the others with stop for example. You need to look not just simply spreads and leverage, but other...
Great thanks for the feedback!

Just shows you how important it is to choose the correct broker for the strategy you are using!

I will continue to test the 2 brokers together and see what the performance is like over a few weeks.

Regards

Vlad
  • #919
  • Jul 27, 2015 12:36pm Jul 27, 2015 12:36pm
Quoting Vlad13685
{quote} Great thanks for the feedback! Just shows you how important it is to choose the correct broker for the strategy you are using! I will continue to test the 2 brokers together and see what the performance is like over a few weeks. Regards Vlad
Vlad,
I have observed noticeable difference between account types even on the same broker (ecn vs regular - tickmill). The ecn hits the target faster and closes, while the regular doesn't close and might get"stuck" in some situations...while the other continues and makes more trades. It is dependent on spread and possible slippage. This is one scenario when you have a change in direction. Keep in mind, the ecn you will have to pay commission afterwards, so profitability may not be that different. Just my 2 cents :-)
Best, Josh
  • #920
  • Jul 27, 2015 5:12pm Jul 27, 2015 5:12pm
Hi, Radit.
can we use pair Gold? and how to seting if i want to use Churcut seting.
i was foward test in 4 account demo(2 acc Tickmill and 2 acc Roboforex procent) with churcut seting in pair EurUsd abaout 3 week and have good result. i get result in 4 acc for 20% - 50% till today. Now i want to use pair gold. can you help me to have good seting for Gold? thanks

btw, someday i will use tickmill, because now they give rebate $4,5/lot (classic acc). but for now, i must be patience, because dont have $1000 - $5000 to deposit. :'(
early, i will use real acc in roboforex pro cent first. because my foward test is promising.
1 trader viewing now