hmm still not right. i changed the settings on my chart and in yours the smoothing part is missing. So you are only running a simple average instead of a smoothed simple average. look if you can apply "Wilder's smoothing" or "smoothing" on the indicator settings. problem with the incorrect display is that fractal signals might occur different around the alligator and more importantly your exit will be incorrect.
The Essentials of Trading: Emotions, Risk Mgt, Price.