Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

4 Hour Strategy Macd+other Indicator 21 replies

average true range for 1 hour and 4 hour charts 2 replies

X-1102 1 hour , 4 hour and daily Tf trades 7 replies

Create a verticle line at certain hour for every certain hour 16 replies

Is the "4 Hour Strategy (MACD)" the best system here at FF? 20 replies

Attachments: 4 Hour Strategy (MACD)
Exit Attachments

4 Hour Strategy (MACD)

Quoting mkain
Great stuff master Phillip, I wonder if this strategy concepts are similar to your classic 5 min Intraday (which I trade), I guess I'll take a look to find out.
Hi
Great to see you are still around. No it is something more easy and concervative. A lot more easy on the emotions.
Phillip
Hi. I'm somewhat new to forex and I started paper trading this system on eur/usd and cable around october 2011, trading only trend continue signals. I had quite a few good trades, but then around november all my trades started to lose and I was getting whipsawed out of every trade, so I stopped for a while but kept an eye on the charts, and almost every single tc that I see seems to completely reverse. Has this method stopped working or is it just that I'm not applying it properly?? Has anyone else had this problem?
Evening Men,

Have been reading Mr Nel's 4hr system for just about a week,can anyone tell me if their was a sell off zero on the 13th at 20.00 at a level of about 1.3203 and 2 tc trades ,one at 16.00 on the 14th and another at 16.00 on the 15th.
These times are for Ireland/u.k,are these actuall trades within the parameters of Philip's system ,or am i just looking at stale data with rose tinted specticles ???

Thanks....

Arrow.
Quoting arrowloopboy
Evening Men,

Have been reading Mr Nel's 4hr system for just about a week,can anyone tell me if their was a sell off zero on the 13th at 20.00 at a level of about 1.3203 and 2 tc trades ,one at 16.00 on the 14th and another at 16.00 on the 15th.
These times are for Ireland/u.k,are these actuall trades within the parameters of Philip's system ,or am i just looking at stale data with rose tinted specticles ???

Thanks....

Arrow.
Hi,

Please see attached image, it's my opinion about those trades :

13.02.2012 16:00 - it's a valid signal on MACD (bounce from zero line ) , but where is the price ? It's above 89 SMA right ? so we still have uptrend IMO. You could trade this one as a CT trade, with very small risk ( 0.5 % ), SL above previous candle ( 30 pips ), first TP at 89sma ( +45 pips ), so Your RR=1.5

14.02.2012 16:00 - price moves away from 8 and 21 ema, but it's still CT trade ( you should wait until 8,21 ema moves under 89sma ), RR looks good.

15.02.2012 16:00 - it's more valid signal than the last one, but RR is very bad ( SL = over 100 pips, first Tp = 200 sma = 70 pips ) 0.7 :/

TC trades should be taken only in the direction of a trend !
8,21 and 89 moving averages show us main trend on 4H.

Hope this helps You :-)
It's only my opinion

B.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: eu-4h-macd.gif Size: 23 KB
Quoting Phillip Nel
Hi
Great to see you are still around. No it is something more easy and concervative. A lot more easy on the emotions.
Phillip
Phillip,
An unrelated question: after I acquired the Combo Package - a while ago - I subscribed and was receiving your weekly forecast for the next week on Sundays. These mailings stopped. Did you stop making them or for some reason my email address was kicked out from your mailing list?
Thank you.
MidnightRun
I have tried this strategy and most trades seem to go wrong. I don't know where I have gone wrong. Can someone help me please, please.....
Quoting Datura
Hi. I'm somewhat new to forex and I started paper trading this system on eur/usd and cable around october 2011, trading only trend continue signals. I had quite a few good trades, but then around november all my trades started to lose and I was getting whipsawed out of every trade, so I stopped for a while but kept an eye on the charts, and almost every single tc that I see seems to completely reverse. Has this method stopped working or is it just that I'm not applying it properly?? Has anyone else had this problem?
I know how you feel. I am in almost the same position. And I have no answer as to what I have done that is not correct. I wish someone here could help me answer my questions too.
Quoting Fuiyong
I have tried this strategy and most trades seem to go wrong. I don't know where I have gone wrong. Can someone help me please, please.....
Please show us Your entries, so we can discuss about them.
Quoting Borek
Please show us Your entries, so we can discuss about them.
here is an exemple of a trade just taken this morning. I know that Macd is quite high so I reduce the risk lower then usual.

have a nice day,
Attached File(s)
File Type: doc 120220EURUSD.doc   130 KB | 367 downloads
Yvon
Quoting trademin
here is an exemple of a trade just taken this morning. I know that Macd is quite high so I reduce the risk lower then usual.

have a nice day,
Q1: is this using 4hr MACD or 1 hr?
Q2: only trade with 21 and 89 ma? What about 21 and 8 ma? I see that many a times price move on 21 and 8 ma.
Q3: what r the other ma for i.e. 200 and 365ma?
Quoting Borek
Please show us Your entries, so we can discuss about them.
Here is my trade entries. Thanks for helping me.
Attached File(s)
File Type: rar Forex Entry.rar   8 KB | 350 downloads
Quoting trademin
here is an exemple of a trade just taken this morning. I know that Macd is quite high so I reduce the risk lower then usual.

have a nice day,
How do u decide where to put the stop loss in this case?
Quoting trademin
here is an exemple of a trade just taken this morning. I know that Macd is quite high so I reduce the risk lower then usual.

have a nice day,

A lot of resistance up there...be careful
Quoting Fuiyong
How do u decide where to put the stop loss in this case?
here is some explaination for my late trade:



It is all based on 4Hr.
The 1 hre chart is for a fine tune.-I know that some people based their trading on the 1hr chart. But I don’t. As per M. Nel the strategy is called 4H MacD Strategy, meaning that the set up should be looked on the 4 hr chart.

For the SL: in this case, already my entry is quite stretch, meaning look at the 8ema(red), look like if I wanted to pick up the highest apple on a tree.
The best would have been with a lower Macd, giving then some room to the pair to move up.
I knew that this trade is more risky, just because of the entry: quite above the 8ema, and the Macd quite high.so my SL is about under that strong green bar.

Look at the daily chart: looks like still bullish to me, just at a break out level and the MacD is still low, so some room available to the up side.- I know that there is still 9 hrs to go to that bar and it could go back down, but it should keep its bullish momentum, that is why I did put my SL right there.
It is not a perfect trade . considering the same opportunity the It could have been at a lower entry around 1.3230 using the 1h chart as a fine tuning.
Yvon
Quoting Morelands
A lot of resistance up there...be careful
thanks for the advice . indeed a quite streched trade,
Yvon
Quoting trademin
thanks for the advice . indeed a quite streched trade,
maybe a bit crazy explanation but...

have a nice reading,
Attached File(s)
File Type: doc The way I see it.doc   2.3 MB | 561 downloads
Yvon
Quoting Fuiyong
Q1: is this using 4hr MACD or 1 hr?
Q2: only trade with 21 and 89 ma? What about 21 and 8 ma? I see that many a times price move on 21 and 8 ma.
Q3: what r the other ma for i.e. 200 and 365ma?
my answer is explained in the work done under "the way I see it"
Yvon
yep

same question about weekly wrap, did you decided to finish the subscribtion ? supporting your buyers
where is Ira and Palmer ?
Quoting trademin
here is an exemple of a trade just taken this morning. I know that Macd is quite high so I reduce the risk lower then usual.

have a nice day,
hi

I didn't took this one because price moved away too much from 89 and 21 ema ( over 100 pips ) Philip told many times that TC trades works best when taken from 21ema. Second reason is that US market is closed today, so don't expect big moves in US session.

B.
1 trader viewing now