Disliked... I'm always interested in the w/e exchange of ideas and views after market close on Friday. For myself, my Trading Edge does not tell me based on the current state of the Weekly, Daily, and 4hr charts and the last candle closes on those, what has the greater probability of happening next, ie more upside or more downside. So, if I were to say that I 'thought' it looked like more downside, or more upside - it would be just a guess. Others' may express it as what they 'think' or what they 'feel' or indeed 'expect' - but it amounts to the same thing....Ignored
When I did CFA they would talk about the 'mosaic theory' of investment in the ethics section. The idea was you were allowed to use a variety of public, non-public and non-material information to make an investment decision. Basically the idea is that it is acceptable to use a variety of varied sources to come to a decision even if one of those was a group of analysts discussing a buy/sell recommendation in the pub-as long as that wasn't your only source (although if it was a group of directors discussing strategy, this would fall into insider trading and hence unacceptable). Kinda similar here, we're all building our own mosaic and using our own internal bullshit detectors built through our years of living and dealing with people to figure out what's useful and what's not.
I think I can say with confidence that you could never build a successful trading strategy off of copying someone else's calls. You have to have confidence in yourself to hold trades into drawdown knowing that you're going to be right more often than not. but I personally find it pretty useful to put a chart out and write down my thoughts just to clarify it in my own head. If people want to tear it apart and say it's nonsense then so be it, in fact I'd prefer that.
With all that said I do think some degree of directional bias is important to be consistently profitable. Otherwise you're just putting a trade out into the wild with no idea where it will land. So you'll never have your strike rate & RR where you need it to be, to be consistent (does that make any sense??). So yea, we can take it as read that none of us truly know, but it's also fair to say we can have a pretty good idea based on the clues the market, COT, fundamentals are telling us.
For me, I think it's more likely than not we'll make a push up to one of the horizontal levels I highlighted where I'll be looking for a good price for a longer ride down.. just imo, and just on the info I have
Reading threads like this is a real double edged sword though. I've definitely found myself shaken from my own view and wish I'd just held firm, but on the other hand I've for sure people consistently point out things that I never would have seen and turned out to be correct. So yeah.. just have to tread carefully, I guess.
5