DislikedHi ido
Thank you for sharing the indicator. I tried to download the indicator but failed to get it.Ignored
Simplified original turtle trading system 42 replies
Support and Resistance Trading Simplified 249 replies
Simplified Trailing Stop 0 replies
Simplified Version Of (Fast) Stochastic 2 replies
a software that can offer a simplified rate of any currency in your screen 0 replies
DislikedHow tight are you about the rule that when going to buy then the high of last candle should not be the highest among last 5?
I ask this because USDCHF is forming a nice box on my chart but the last candle is the highest... Would you trade sth like this anyway or better to stay away?Ignored
DislikedPlease read Post #169 as Colostarr already replied this when I asked him the same question.Ignored
DislikedHi Kopaszn,
Thanks for the useful indicator. Your indicator shows the history that met the set up criterion. It does not show the recently 5 bars set up as shown in the chart below. It would be nice to see if the indicator be able to draw the rectangular box of 5 recently bars which met the 3 rules and draw the lines representing the TP and SL based on ATR calculations.
ThanksIgnored
DislikedHow tight are you about the rule that when going to buy then the high of last candle should not be the highest among last 5?
I ask this because USDCHF is forming a nice box on my chart but the last candle is the highest... Would you trade sth like this anyway or better to stay away?
EDIT: in this example all 5 candles have practically equal highs. 1-2 pip difference.Ignored
DislikedHi,
if I correctly understand the rules, there is a valid setup to go Long in GBPJPY.
It's Right?Ignored
DislikedPlease read Post #169 as Colostarr already replied this when I asked him the same question.Ignored
DislikedI would validate this as a good northerly break out for 2 reasons:
1. It coorelates to the EURUSD which is currently heading south
2. This pair is currently in a very strong uptrend (SMA's are very seperated and pointing north! on 4H)!
Not trying to create a double standard here
this plays into what I was saying earlier about looking at your charts, taking other factors into account: coorelating pairs, trends pivots
Indicators and EA's create a way for you to NOT have to look at your charts, not have to read anything into a trade....Ignored
DislikedSorry but I couldn't understand how this post is related to my post to Indrek. He just asked the very same question I asked and I just pointed him to your post answering both questions (just saved your time). That's all. Other than that I haven't mentioned or commented about any other factors you explained above.
And I totally agree with you that there is no need to any indicators and EAs (I don't even know how to use or attach EAs) for your strategy. A simple Excel spreadsheet to do the required calculations for six major currencies (just updating...Ignored
DislikedKopaszn,
I have loaded your indi up on a chart and I have a few observations:
I believe the setup bar, when closed counts as 1 of the 5 bar sequence.
- Sorry to Easyryder, (see post #120) you were correct!
I have therefore changed the variable to barnumber = 4.
Would it be possible to have your indi take account of the rule:
For valid down trend signal ~ 2. The low of the most recently closed candle is greater (higher) than the LL5
For valid up trend signal ~ [b][i]2. The high of the most recently...Ignored
DislikedI see the very same behavior in this thread - EA's and indicators to make life easy! It won't happen - I promise! You have control to make your life easy, not an indicator!Ignored
DislikedColostarr,
I ask about this USDCHF setup you traded last week. For me the setup became valid on earlier bar (red dotted line). If the next bar still ranges, like here to the south and you get again a new setup, you just change the position of your buy stop order according to last hh5?
http://img707.imageshack.us/img707/9...0214154542.pngIgnored
DislikedHere's the latest version of the indicator.
Screenshot with all options ON:
Attachment
This way, you can have the rules always onscreen (might be me, but i forget rules sometimes and have to go back to first post to read again )
AttachmentIgnored