Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Ci/symphonie extreme similarity explained! 144 replies

Symphonie/Cobra Hybrid System 4 replies

Symphonie trader or Genesis matrix 1 reply

Symphonie Trader System EA 73 replies

Yet another set of Symphonie Indicators 241 replies

Attachments: Symphonie Trader System
Exit Attachments

Symphonie Trader System

i will take a small position if i see a close at either of these points
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Untitled.png Size: 101 KB
nightmare day.
buying at top and selling at bottom.
Buying now again when it due a retrace.

Thats' why nobody posts trading statements. Its not profitable.

I appreciate your efforts here evaluator but I think too many people are being sucked into this system blindly thinking its a holy grail.

I hope someone proves me wrong.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: symphonie.jpg Size: 154 KB
Finally back on track to 1.34000??????

I really hate markts when the do this! (110 pip wide whipsaw!!!!!!!!)
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Symphonie Screenshot 490.jpg Size: 128 KB
Quoting gregh286
nightmare day.
buying at top and selling at bottom.
Buying now again when it due a retrace.

Thats' why nobody posts trading statements. Its not profitable.

I appreciate your efforts here evaluator but I think too many people are being sucked into this system blindly thinking its a holy grail.

I hope someone proves me wrong.

gregh,

If you read post#1 there is a small part about DYNAMIC Stoploss where you would have only profited from the Symphonie Signals....you would be up 6 pips for the day even with the markt panic on rumors.

Also, if you had really read what I posted I have always said that Symphonie will not be right 100% of the time and no system will ever be! I have also posted that Symphonie WILL MAKE wrong calls but that is where the other components of Symphonie kick in and are more valuable. It is called proper Order and Money management. IF you just put in and order and expect a profit each time and do not manage the orders then you are going to lose and it will be your own fault.

So, before you jump on your Symphone is bad wagon and ride it around...I suggest you go back to post#1 and really read what I say.

Evaluator.:nerd:

(p.s. NO SYSTEM or person or technical analysis could have predicted the rumors that drove the markt crazy today NONE not one!!!)
I think the problem Greg has is the same problem most people are having that are coming to this thread. If you compare your matrix on M5 with theirs they are around an hour later than you putting an order in, monumental differences in the matrix like somebody said much earlier just after you released 4.4h. Now you told that person that you were not going to spoon feed them they had to find their own optimum settings when he said that he could not match up to your matrix with ANY of the settings you published. Now if they cannot match your settings how on earth are they supposed to get the same results as you? Compare the matrix Greg put up and yours.
Quoting lastingwell
I think the problem Greg has is the same problem most people are having that are coming to this thread. If you compare your matrix on M5 with theirs they are around an hour later than you putting an order in, monumental differences in the matrix like somebody said much earlier just after you released 4.4h. Now you told that person that you were not going to spoon feed them they had to find their own optimum settings when he said that he could not match up to your matrix with ANY of the settings you published. Now if they cannot match your settings...

lastingwell,

My settings are posted and you can find them in post#1.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Quoting Evaluator
lastingwell,

My settings are posted and you can find them in post#1.

Evaluator.:nerd:
I know they are and they do not match up on M5 with your pics at all.
Quoting lastingwell
I know they are and they do not match up on M5 with your pics at all.

lastingwell,

you have my indikator, you have my plan, you have my settings...the rest is up to you.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Symphonie please give me a good signal, that i could get +100 or more pips for today

Evaluator,

I have one question and it's not concerning to the trading rules..

When i can go to the real account to trade with symphonie?
Evaluator, best time is 5 or 15 minutes in your system?


kind regards, philipe;
Quoting Yegor
Symphonie please give me a good signal, that i could get +100 or more pips for today

Evaluator,

I have one question and it's not concerning to the trading rules..

When i can go to the real account to trade with symphonie?

Yegor,

If you can maintain a solid growth track record for one month of demo trading then you are most likley ready for real trading...but only start with small account and small lotsizes. Trading real money adds a new dynamic to your trading and one needs to be aware of that.

Start small and you should do fine.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Quoting felipeds
Evaluator, best time is 5 or 15 minutes in your system?


kind regards, philipe;

5 min. 15 min and 1H seem to be the most popular timeframes to trade using Symphonie.



Evaluator.:nerd:
Quoting Evaluator
lastingwell,

you have my indikator, you have my plan, you have my settings...the rest is up to you.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Yes the rest was up to me so I decided I would not dream of trading it after giving it just the merest glance on the 5min timeframe thats all I needed to do to know unless a major trend is on the way the amount of pips picked up really is not worth it. I was merely pointing out why some people are having more problems than you are.
Quoting Evaluator
Yegor,

If you can maintain a solid growth track record for one month of demo trading then you are most likley ready for real trading...but only start with small account and small lotsizes. Trading real money adds a new dynamic to your trading and one needs to be aware of that.

Start small and you should do fine.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Eval,

Thanks for advices!
So i will trade on demo account till the end of this month.

And about your results in 2012, how could you manage to get 380% a week, is it possible to do so following ARS rules?
This results are crazy

Your results motivate me to work harder!
Quoting lastingwell
Yes the rest was up to me so I decided I would not dream of trading it after giving it just the merest glance on the 5min timeframe thats all I needed to do to know unless a major trend is on the way the amount of pips picked up really is not worth it. I was merely pointing out why some people are having more problems than you are.

lastingwell,

Then best of luck to you in your search for the perfekt system......Because obvioulsy Symphonie is not for you.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Eval,

I'm a little confused

for placement of the pending order are you taking the closing or lowest price of the signal candle?

Thank you,
nadar
Quoting Evaluator
lastingwell,

Then best of luck to you in your search for the perfekt system......Because obvioulsy Symphonie is not for you.

Evaluator.:nerd:
Thank you for the good wishes Evaluator. I dont need to search Ive found the perfect system for me and surely that is the whole point. My interest in this thread arose because I was intrigued by the spreadsheet you posted on last years growth and very impressive it was but I do feel you should have marked on it when you started using the other indicators compared to the image in post 1. Simply calling everything you trade "symphonie" will confuse people into thinking the growth was all down to the latest when in fact only 1 of the original indicators remain as far as I can tell.
Quoting lastingwell
Thank you for the good wishes Evaluator. I dont need to search Ive found the perfect system for me and surely that is the whole point. My interest in this thread arose because I was intrigued by the spreadsheet you posted on last years growth and very impressive it was but I do feel you should have marked on it when you started using the other indicators compared to the image in post 1. Simply calling everything you trade "symphonie" will confuse people into thinking the growth was all down to the latest when in fact only 1 of...
Lastingwell, my settings and matrix match Evaluator's just fine. It has made me a lot of pips. People are on here from all over the world with tons of different hardware. Evaluator cannot be expect to be everyone's technical support. I have done extensive back testing with ONLY the new indicator (a couple weeks worth) on 5M charts and they more than back up Evaluator's data on his spreadsheet. Good luck with your other system. There are many good ones out there!
Quoting Stickbow21
Lastingwell, my settings and matrix match Evaluator's just fine. It has made me a lot of pips. People are on here from all over the world with tons of different hardware. Evaluator cannot be expect to be everyone's technical support. I have done extensive back testing with ONLY the new indicator (a couple weeks worth) on 5M charts and they more than back up Evaluator's data on his spreadsheet. Good luck with your other system. There are many good ones out there!
I wasnt talking about hardware I was talking about the matrix gregh had compared to evaluators matrix and also quite a few other people. When you have an indicator you will get very slight variations with broker feed. You do not get a signal one clear hour after the other one on the 5min chart.

If you care to look at the spreadsheet evaluator posted it shows results for a full year the vast majority of the gains being made up to August last year. If you care to look at evaluators posts he wasnt trading these particular indicators at that time, that is indisputable its fact. Good luck for your trading.
Hi Eva,
Which settings do you have?
because my settings are diferent in 5M
thanks


Quoting Evaluator
Finally back on track to 1.34000??????

I really hate markts when the do this! (110 pip wide whipsaw!!!!!!!!)
{Promotion Removed}
3 traders viewing now