Trade Guider System VSA, fact or fiction?

Good to see there is still some interest even if it appears as disjointed ramblings.

However, you are quite wrong and I am ever an optimist and my glass is always half full.

But I am aging and not so easily fooled these days with a quick tongue and fanciful explanations.

There is more snake oil in this industry than any other I have encountered, so when I turn to statistical analysis and something is proven wrong, I actually believe the science over other claims that lack supporting logic.

If anyone of the so sayers can provide some logical reason for your belief that volume is relevant in the context provided.. other than you believe the salesman, then i will be happy to have another look. In the meantime I have provided many logical arguments why it is not applicable. The logic for my arguments is what you need to address if a fair debate is to ensue.

So far at each opportunity, I encounter disparaging personal comments as a substitute of the necessary logic or evidence. This behavior does nothing for your credibility and simply makes me more sure that I was right all along and you guys are more interested in your sales reputation than any real word results.

For you, if it works, it is easy proven.. it is always easier to prove a positive than a negative. I am not sure why no one has taken that opportunity.

Mate.. go ahead and believe what you may! Honestly, I wish you all the best. Hope you make millions!

Tell you what, how about I tell you guys how to do your own stats testing? Then you can see for yourself!

Thank you for good wishes!
I'm not selling anything to anybody so I don't want to argue about or make anybody believe in something.
If you so concerned about logic, I found logic error in your statements. You are talking about statistical analysis that show failure of volume....on other side you telling that you read MTM book but did not memorize to much from it and it's clearly that you don't understand the VSA method on good-enough-to trade level. How come? How you doing statistical analysis? What rules you apply if you dont know the method???
I can say that I statistically prove that airplanes CAN NOT fly....because all planes that I build not flying well.....may be because I'm not a plane maker?
If HG or Malcolm are making planes that fly high it's because they understand how this thing works. You can either join the FREE learning thread or open yours and teach people to trade your way.....believe me Maclolm will never go to your thread and say "Hey people you are blind fools, give me logical proofs that you are not trading bulshit!"
People asking Who are you to judge?
Volume AND range(spread) of the bar are making sense when you read the chart they have some predictive power, yes you need to work with charts thousands of hours to gather experience and make more good predictions than bad....but show me working method which is not need work at all? It was said million times in forex discussions that if such easy method exist why everybody is not millionaires??
Lastly, you are a smart opponent but I'm pretty sure that you are a not profitable trader. Because I never saw the profitable trader on any forum criticizing anything in such manner(eg. proove to me! don't believe it! you are not logical! my method is a secret etc.)
Successful people attitude is just different....

There is zero point in debating with this guy.

I have tried . I have asked us to show us his fantastic calls and system.

All he came back with was ' I am not here to teach you how to trade' and something about an EA. This means he has NOTHING and is still finding his way in the world of fx.

VSA made me 15% on account last week... so it works for me.

Do not believe me? go look at some of my posts ... ie where i got in 2 pip off the low of Guy for a 200 pip run. Think this is by magic ? That trade set up for 12 hours.

The guy that you are arguing with would be the same guy that would argue , back in the days , that a round wheel would never work cause he thinks a triangular one is better , yet he talks about logic and statistics.

Till the owner of this thread shows us his magnificent trades I say he has nothing...and does not trade only debates.

Well Guys,

Congratulations on your move to modify the trade guider system as it applies to forex. Just been reading your thread and I see how many other ideas have been adopted in an effort to improve the system.

I understand it must have been difficult so;

Once again, Congrats

In Russsian language i would say = Pjannij bazar ( written not in rusian letters )

In english this could be - Drunked Talks..

This is how i describe such talks like in this thread asgard is talking..

No need to talk more...


B,
T

Guys i would like to sell TG

If i can tell it here

If it is forbiden please erase my post


Regards

Why are you selling? could you share your experiencs of TG with us.

isn't it obvious this TG system works well. let's be happy with that! (see youtube videos there are plenty of them out there!) When someone has an other vision how to use VSA -and use TG with that system, you are more than welcome to share with me and others! let's show some charts, and give a glimp of your 80% ++system.