What is a good EA for you? | Forex Factory

Options

Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

If you haven't made it yet, what makes you think you will? 212 replies

What would you do if you had a very good system? 7 replies

Demo Trading: How good were you before you went live? 6 replies

You think you are good enough to analyze what system is this?? 7 replies

Is this a good or not that good begining? 6 replies

What is a good EA for you?

  • #1
  • First Post: Jul 2, 2026 6:48am Jul 2, 2026 6:48am
For the people reading this thread (if any ).

- What does make a good EA for you?
- What is the thing that you most value on an EA?
- What makes you trust in an EA?
Indiana Gold #1 Return Today: na
  • #2
  • Jul 2, 2026 8:02am Jul 2, 2026 8:02am
Quoting frielspak
For the people reading this thread (if any ). - What does make a good EA for you? - What is the thing that you most value on an EA? - What makes you trust in an EA?
EYES
For Gold, NY session offers superior tradability compared to London.
  • #3
  • Jul 2, 2026 8:06am Jul 2, 2026 8:06am
No EA survives every regime, so you can't trust them.
  • #4
  • Jul 2, 2026 9:20am Jul 2, 2026 9:20am
Quoting Newtrader025
{quote} EYES
Why you say that?
Indiana Gold #1 Return Today: na
  • #5
  • Jul 2, 2026 9:23am Jul 2, 2026 9:23am
Quoting Rfastrat
No EA survives every regime, so you can't trust them.
Interesting, so what makes you believe that a human can do it? When the worst thing in trading is the mental part? and a bot don't need to deal with it.

Also an EA can be configured, no EA (atleast proper one) keeps the same settings for the entire lifetime.
Indiana Gold #1 Return Today: na
  • #6
  • Jul 2, 2026 10:23am Jul 2, 2026 10:23am
Quoting frielspak
{quote} Why you say that?

Because, I trade purely on Price Action, reading the market with my own eyes and understanding.
For Gold, NY session offers superior tradability compared to London.
  • #7
  • Jul 2, 2026 10:57am Jul 2, 2026 10:57am
Quoting frielspak
{quote} Interesting, so what makes you believe that a human can do it? When the worst thing in trading is the mental part? and a bot don't need to deal with it. Also an EA can be configured, no EA (atleast proper one) keeps the same settings for the entire lifetime.
if you have to adjust your parameters you are just curve fitting.
  • #8
  • Jul 2, 2026 11:08am Jul 2, 2026 11:08am
Quoting Newtrader025
{quote} Because, I trade purely on Price Action, reading the market with my own eyes and understanding.
Thats a good way to do it, it's how i also did before, but you don't believe that an EA can do the same?
Indiana Gold #1 Return Today: na
  • #9
  • Jul 2, 2026 11:11am Jul 2, 2026 11:11am
Quoting Rfastrat
{quote} if you have to adjust your parameters you are just curve fitting.
So if you buy a car with summer tiers and you go to snow you can not change to winter tiers?

You telling me that the market can change, but the EA cannot?

So people trading gold in 1970 still trade the same way in 2026?
Indiana Gold #1 Return Today: na
  • #10
  • Jul 2, 2026 1:09pm Jul 2, 2026 1:09pm
no, I am saying that alpha decays over time. The markets are efficient.
If you paint a black horse with white stripes, it doesn't become a Zebra. Too be honest, you asked for an opinion on what makes a good EA, and my answer is the regime. But take that for what it's worth, nothing, because everyone can have an opinion, and they are essentially worthless. If you make money, just keep doing you.
  • #11
  • Jul 2, 2026 3:02pm Jul 2, 2026 3:02pm
Quoting Rfastrat
no, I am saying that alpha decays over time. The markets are efficient. If you paint a black horse with white stripes, it doesn't become a Zebra. Too be honest, you asked for an opinion on what makes a good EA, and my answer is the regime. But take that for what it's worth, nothing, because everyone can have an opinion, and they are essentially worthless. If you make money, just keep doing you.
I am not here trying to fight with you or something similar, i am just trying to understand your point of view, because at the begining you said "No EA survives every regime, so you can't trust them.". I understood it as - trading with EA can't be good because they don't adapt to diferent market regimes.

But now you said, that for you what matters in an EA is it being able to survive on different regimes and for me it makes perfect sense, if you build an EA that cant adapt to market regimes, you will lose money.

Thank for your opinion and participating on the discussion!
Indiana Gold #1 Return Today: na
  • #12
  • Jul 3, 2026 9:24am Jul 3, 2026 9:24am
Quoting frielspak
{quote} Thats a good way to do it, it's how i also did before, but you don't believe that an EA can do the same?
No, I don’t think so. I’ve never seen any EA trader making consistent profits year after year. Sure, with an EA you might catch 6–8 months of gains, but markets move in long‑term cycles- and EAs simply can’t adapt to that.

My belief won’t help you or harm you, so keep doing what you’re doing.
For Gold, NY session offers superior tradability compared to London.
  • #13
  • Jul 3, 2026 9:44am Jul 3, 2026 9:44am
Quoting frielspak
{quote} I am not here trying to fight with you or something similar, i am just trying to understand your point of view, because at the begining you said "No EA survives every regime, so you can't trust them.". I understood it as - trading with EA can't be good because they don't adapt to diferent market regimes. But now you said, that for you what matters in an EA is it being able to survive on different regimes and for me it makes perfect sense, if you build an EA that cant adapt to market regimes, you will lose money. Thank for your opinion and...
It's a bit more subtle than this. Theoretically yes, an EA could be programmed to handle regimes. In practice, never.
The proper pipeline for all-weather algos requires a huge pipeline. Some elements are interchangeable but FX wise you'll likely have positioning, vol, price history, macro, gating which is where the regimes come in, then risk then finally execution with orderflow. To collapse that into one EA is totally unmanageable. I collapsed just vol and regimes together and that was a huge mistake - 60k lines of code. Imagine adding the rest. Send you round the bend.
  • #14
  • Last Post: Jul 5, 4:11pm (1 hr 50 min ago) Jul 5, 4:11pm (1 hr 50 min ago)
Quoting frielspak
{quote} I am not here trying to fight with you or something similar, i am just trying to understand your point of view, because at the begining you said "No EA survives every regime, so you can't trust them.". I understood it as - trading with EA can't be good because they don't adapt to diferent market regimes. But now you said, that for you what matters in an EA is it being able to survive on different regimes and for me it makes perfect sense, if you build an EA that cant adapt to market regimes, you will lose money. Thank for your opinion and...

Maybe these guys aren't making consistent profits trading off EAs even while providing trade copy services. Some as far back as 2021. Its fake or maybe demo I guess! "They have not seen and will never see", its as simple as that.

https://www.mql5.com/en/signals

People just talk, talk and discourage others. Toxicity and negativity. If they tried and failed means no one can do better or they never even get to try and then assume. Smh

All the best with your EA my friend, @frielspak!
Grit; Knowledge; Right Mindset; All you need to overcome. KIS!
0 traders viewing now