Disliked{quote} hey @tommydog.... People here already know that. You and @realjumper are two members here suffering from schizophrenia and OCD in FF. Your symptoms are more serious because you post fake trades using photoshop edited old charts and make losing trades look like winning trades. We know because when we zoom in onto you posts and charts, we see many MT4 objects being edited and you still have not posted any MT4 account summary of those trades to show you have taken real trades with correct entries and exits. I already posted a few examples today....Ignored
- #142,723
- Sep 16, 2023 2:18am Sep 16, 2023 2:18am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
Entered this E/U trade last night on the weekly time frame... put the SL at the top of the previous candle... about 150 pips away... won't see the next candle until next week... already in profit... see the nice 5 o'clock green TDI line with Stoch's confirmation... {image}
Pay attention to details and you will learn fast ....
> you see the OHLC data
> you see the price when that chart was saved
> you see the dat and time ... May 08, 00:00 is a Sunday and FXDD broker open NY 5pm is 00:00 candle
> which day of that week did he open his sell order when the OHLC of that week is printed on his chart
> his SL is very small from his entry, that is a hint ...
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,724
- Sep 16, 2023 6:58am Sep 16, 2023 6:58am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} hi emmanuel thanks a lot i always use your advice . i analyze higher time frames from monthly and my trades win every week i pick only the best setups in H4 but i am confuse how to manage my trades and always exit too soon i need clear signal to know when to exit . i trade in h4 and sl is big here maybe i need to pick only first reverse and not pull backs to achieve the 2r at least and trail each R . i really pick the good trades and if i could earn only half of the profit i will be the always winner . i try to use cavemanager like you but...
How you manage your trades depends on your Exit Strategy.
You must first decide your trade Exit Strategy before you place you trade.
There are 5 Exit Strategy I talked about in this thread.
post #55,038
Types of exits:
1) Static Exit when SL and/or TP(s) hit.
2) Adaptive Exit when Percentage of ATR reached, R-Multiple reached, etc.
3) Trade Invalidation Exit.
4) Timed Exit, when the trade has exceeded its predetermine duration, no matter the trade result.
5) Psychological Exit.... mental exhaustion of the trader.
'set and forget' works best for 1) Static Exits and also 2) if we know how to.
My preference is the ATR-based R-Multiple exit .
In your EN sell trade, you have you SL above the swing high and that is the risk 'R' for Position Sizing.
That is the risk 'R'
And the Exit Strategy using R and R-Multiple Exit Management, you would easily got a +2R trade if you simply use the 'set-and-forget' and let the market hit your TP @+2R. You move your SL to Breakeven when the price moved to +1R level...
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,725
- Sep 16, 2023 7:04am Sep 16, 2023 7:04am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} hi emmanuel thanks a lot i always use your advice . i analyze higher time frames from monthly and my trades win every week i pick only the best setups in H4 but i am confuse how to manage my trades and always exit too soon i need clear signal to know when to exit . i trade in h4 and sl is big here maybe i need to pick only first reverse and not pull backs to achieve the 2r at least and trail each R . i really pick the good trades and if i could earn only half of the profit i will be the always winner . i try to use cavemanager like you but...
another simple exit is use the HA candles Price Action
#2617 follow simple rules for entries and exit
This is Synergy exit using HA candles.
The TDI' Volatility Band is useful for this exit.
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,726
- Sep 16, 2023 7:14am Sep 16, 2023 7:14am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} hi emmanuel thanks a lot i always use your advice . i analyze higher time frames from monthly and my trades win every week i pick only the best setups in H4 but i am confuse how to manage my trades and always exit too soon i need clear signal to know when to exit . i trade in h4 and sl is big here maybe i need to pick only first reverse and not pull backs to achieve the 2r at least and trail each R . i really pick the good trades and if i could earn only half of the profit i will be the always winner . i try to use cavemanager like you but...
You have the Stoch and TDI on your chart,
use them to help you see the market type conditions and the Exit Strategy for 4H swing trading.
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,728
- Sep 16, 2023 8:34am Sep 16, 2023 8:34am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} time is valuable ! why why some people dont try, i see a lot people never admit they are wrong, never wanna said sorry to people or themselves. just Admit, and sorry. it doesnot hurt at all. you ,Emmanuel, should create a new topic and block him
I agree with you. Please advise the trolls here to a new thread and keep the discussion here healthy.
I think the problem here is some traders, likely losing ones, keep harassing others. You can definitely see they are full of hatred and jealousy. I don’t see why they cannot admit they’re losing trades.
1. I am trading well and making profit with BigE’s TMS. Following TDI and post #647 mostly
2. I have posted my trade entries, management and exits with screenshots
3. There is no obligation to share live trading signal to other here. I am not a signal provider or sort, just a retail trader.
4. The trades and charts I post here are to show how BigE and TMS traders analyse and trade. You are more than welcome to engage in a trading discussion with us
Meanwhile, trade well with your demo account. Hope you can get out of drawdown soon. Treat it like a live account and trade wisely. Time is valuable.
- #142,729
- Sep 16, 2023 8:46am Sep 16, 2023 8:46am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} hi emmanuel thanks a lot i always use your advice . i analyze higher time frames from monthly and my trades win every week i pick only the best setups in H4 but i am confuse how to manage my trades and always exit too soon i need clear signal to know when to exit . i trade in h4 and sl is big here maybe i need to pick only first reverse and not pull backs to achieve the 2r at least and trail each R . i really pick the good trades and if i could earn only half of the profit i will be the always winner . i try to use cavemanager like you but...
as I have posted previously, a simple diagram outlining TMS trade plan. Follow the Price Action in post #647
Back to your EURNZD H4. First it was a valid TMS sell setup. Good on you entering sell at the TDI cross down
Sticking to H4, the Prev L is at about 1.2R from entry. If you have missed the candle open and entered sometime during the H4 candle down, your R:R might be lower.
If you expect the price to keep the downtrend, then making a Lower Low would be what you should anticipate. Then you can consider the next Previous Low. The R:R is about 2.4.
The 2nd lower low is also a strong Last Reversal during the last uptrend.
If you did not plan out the trade, just don’t trade that setup, there is always setup for TMS trades
trade well
- #142,730
- Sep 16, 2023 8:46am Sep 16, 2023 8:46am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} Hi Havenoidea, I agree with you. Please advise the trolls here to a new thread and keep the discussion here healthy. I think the problem here is some traders, likely losing ones, keep harassing others. You can definitely see they are full of hatred and jealousy. I don’t see why they cannot admit they’re losing trades.
@tommydog....
You must have forgotten to take your evening dose of your schizophrenia medication.
Do you have another photo of your left hand holding a handphone and your right hand with another handphone taking your left hand...
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,731
- Sep 16, 2023 8:48am Sep 16, 2023 8:48am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} hi emmanuel thanks a lot i always use your advice . i analyze higher time frames from monthly and my trades win every week i pick only the best setups in H4 but i am confuse how to manage my trades and always exit too soon i need clear signal to know when to exit . i trade in h4 and sl is big here maybe i need to pick only first reverse and not pull backs to achieve the 2r at least and trail each R . i really pick the good trades and if i could earn only half of the profit i will be the always winner . i try to use cavemanager like you but...
@korosh1350
You can also consider Exit 4) Timed Exit like Big E would close his trades at 6am his local time.
or Close all 4H trades by the time the London session close.
I would close all my 4H swing trades on Friday when London session closing time.
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,732
- Sep 16, 2023 9:02am Sep 16, 2023 9:02am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} Hi Korosh1350, as I have posted previously, a simple diagram outlining TMS trade plan. Follow the Price Action in post #647 {image} Back to your EURNZD H4. First it was a valid TMS sell setup. Good on you entering sell at the TDI cross down
@tommydog....
You do not know how to use the TDI MBL and VB with the Stochastics to see the market type conditions.
Knowing the market type conditions is an important element to determine the potential profit run of trade setups.
Spend more time and study the OP posts where he mentioned how the use the TDI MBL and VB for volatile market swings. He also provided links to TDI secrets in his old thread.
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,733
- Sep 16, 2023 9:05am Sep 16, 2023 9:05am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} hey @havenoidea I will start a few new topics in this thread next month. One of the new topic will be for TMS_EVO_2024/2025/2026 system live testing from Oct to Dec . This will help those who are still struggling with system development using Big E' 5-Method . Don't worry about that @tommydog.... he is the loser here posting fake trades using photoshop editing on his old charts. He has blown several accounts since 2021 and he will still be blowing more accounts with his prop firm demo. I will continue to check his old posts and flag all...
First, you have mental problem. We can see you are full of hatred and jealousy.
Please control your mental problem as you confessed yourself.
Please stop making up stories of mine. It doesn’t hurt anyone but yourself. Don’t listen to the voice in your head
You sound like some poor guy unable to afford a trip, or a phone, and just spiting your negativity on others.
Have a nice weekend and a life
- #142,734
- Sep 16, 2023 9:10am Sep 16, 2023 9:10am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} @tommydog.... You do not know how to use the TDI MBL and VB with the Stochastics to see the market type conditions. Knowing the market type conditions is an important element to determine the potential profit run of trade setups. Spend more time and study the OP posts where he mentioned how the use the TDI MBL and VB for volatile market swings. He also provided links to TDI secrets in his old thread. {image} ...
Yes that is one way to exit a TMS trade.
However, compare with planning exit with Previous Low (#647 price action)
Exit would be 30pip higher than the Previous Low, which leads to less profit and poorer R:R.
- #142,735
- Sep 16, 2023 9:25am Sep 16, 2023 9:25am
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
{quote} Time is valuable, but I will spend some time replying you this. First, you have mental problem. We can see you are full of hatred and jealousy. Please control your mental problem as you confessed yourself. Please stop making up stories of mine. It doesn’t hurt anyone but yourself. Don’t listen to the voice in your head You sound like some poor guy unable to afford a trip, or a phone, and just spiting your negativity on others. Have a nice weekend and a life
@tommydog....
You have been called out and exposed by me for posting fake trades using photoshop-edited charts.
You need to do the right thing and admit to this very grave mistake made in this dead man' thread.
Its okay people here will forgive you for that big mistake made because we all know of your mental illness for a long time.
You wont be the last one posting fake trades in this thread.
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
- #142,736
- Sep 16, 2023 10:27am Sep 16, 2023 10:27am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} Folks, Do Not trade with prop firm account. You read this: CFTC Charges “My Forex Funds” with Fraudulently Taking Over $300 Million From Customers Hoping to Become Professional Traders | CFTC https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8771-23 ...
Is it because you blew your Prop Firm account, or just suffering from mental problems?
From what you posted, You and I are both trading accounts under the same prop firm company. Mine is still going. How is yours?
It is weird that you as a prop firm trader, is against prop firm trading. Seems weird that you HATE many things that you doing.
Trade well.
- #142,738
- Sep 16, 2023 11:40am Sep 16, 2023 11:40am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} Are you planning to share this indicator?
Thank you for asking. However I am not planning to share my own indicator.
What I can do is to provide you ways to construct the TMS chart like BigE’s on MT4, mobile MT4, and Trading View.
#130851
I have TradingView and MT4 installed on my phone.
TradingView is more versatile and can put up custom indicators and set up alerts to trade on the fly.
MT4 is my broker, IG, trading platform for trade execution. I also put up the TDI on the chart.
====
First. Inspect the code of TDI green and red line. #25 has the .mt4 and source code can be viewed .
The RSI is 13, close. Green line is SMA(2) of the RSI and Red is SMA(7) of it.
Note the TDI is calculated from the OHLC of original chart, not the HA candles.
====
Setting up the TDI green and red line on MT4
#122445, I have explained how to do it step-by-step. Basically put up the RSI(13) and then apply MAs to the indicator.
https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...2#post13623472
======
Setting up the TDI and HA chart on TradingView
#120591. The HA chart is added as indicator because as mentioned, TDI is calculated from original OHLC
https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...7#post13580607
- #142,739
- Sep 16, 2023 11:47am Sep 16, 2023 11:47am
- Joined Oct 2020 | Status: Trader | 3,886 Posts
{quote} Hi Oradba, Thank you for asking. However I am not planning to share my own indicator. What I can do is to provide you ways to construct the TMS chart like BigE’s on MT4, mobile MT4, and Trading View. #130851 I have TradingView and MT4 installed on my phone. TradingView is more versatile and can put up custom indicators and set up alerts to trade on the fly. MT4 is my broker, IG, trading platform for trade execution. I also put up the TDI on the chart. ==== First. Inspect the code of TDI green and red line. #25 has the .mt4 and source code...
My TMS indicator is the same basis: TDI green and red line.
The background color is trade direction (trend) determined using #647 Price Action elements. The benefit is further filter out noise and only trigger alerts with valid TMS opportunities.
Having said that, the TMS setups can be identified by manual analysis.
For example, when I entered the GU sell, that was when the indicator determined a downtrend period (red background). It then gave me alert as the TDI cross down within the downtrend window.
v-line marks the entry
Moment of entry
trade outcome
- #142,740
- Sep 16, 2023 8:28pm Sep 16, 2023 8:28pm
- Joined Nov 2008 | Status: Trader | 50,211 Posts
#11,148
Quoting eelfranz
Hi Everyone .... Hope the week is going well for you all. Any questions? PM me. My favorite plays are 32% up and 68% down on the TDI. You have to check your TDI every time a new candle appears. OFTEN TIMES I'll check the current candle several times during the trade. Just my routine. Do what works for you .................. {image}
and this post #1967 is the OP trade example:
#1967
Quoting eelfranz
Entered this E/U trade last night on the weekly time frame... put the SL at the top of the previous candle... about 150 pips away... won't see the next candle until next week... already in profit... see the nice 5 o'clock green TDI line with Stoch's confirmation... {image}
> and his Weekly charts sell trade
> a lot to learn when you pay attention to details and study his charts, you will see many failed trade setups.
...
Quoting eelfranz
Hi Everyone .... Hope the week is going well for you all. Any questions? PM me. My favorite plays are 32% up and 68% down on the TDI. You have to check your TDI every time a new candle appears. OFTEN TIMES I'll check the current candle several times during the trade. Just my routine. Do what works for you .................. {image}
and this post #1967 is the OP trade example:
#1967
Quoting eelfranz
Entered this E/U trade last night on the weekly time frame... put the SL at the top of the previous candle... about 150 pips away... won't see the next candle until next week... already in profit... see the nice 5 o'clock green TDI line with Stoch's confirmation... {image}
> and his Weekly charts sell trade
> a lot to learn when you pay attention to details and study his charts, you will see many failed trade setups.
...
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett