I am always amazed how so many people can write books about Gann, Elliott etc which "look" technical about trading but are not.
I have invested some time in the "jewel" book , mainly on the "musical" chapter (the Gann Octave) and I know nothing more about the relationship between music theory and trading
. I should not have been surprised because I own constance Brown's book about Fibonacci and I can not say it was helpful too.
I see 2 others factors which play a role a) we are not newbies , hence we have more exigences . Most of us here are all good and experimented in Gann (and relative subject Fibo, Cycles, Astro , TA, etc) . Hence basic Gann , Fibo, Cycles , Astro etc do not surprise us. Hence parts of the books have no real values for us. b) it is obvious that these guys mainly write books, from time to time generate a Market analysis (as examples) but very rarely, sometimes never trade. Hence they have nothing to offer us relatively to trading. Hence our disappointment.
moreover all these books HAVE to be somewhat nebulous; to look like unfinished work. They are "openers" their real aim is to motivate some people to buy more expensive seminars or courses or an other book. .
I have invested some time in the "jewel" book , mainly on the "musical" chapter (the Gann Octave) and I know nothing more about the relationship between music theory and trading
. I should not have been surprised because I own constance Brown's book about Fibonacci and I can not say it was helpful too.
I see 2 others factors which play a role a) we are not newbies , hence we have more exigences . Most of us here are all good and experimented in Gann (and relative subject Fibo, Cycles, Astro , TA, etc) . Hence basic Gann , Fibo, Cycles , Astro etc do not surprise us. Hence parts of the books have no real values for us. b) it is obvious that these guys mainly write books, from time to time generate a Market analysis (as examples) but very rarely, sometimes never trade. Hence they have nothing to offer us relatively to trading. Hence our disappointment.
moreover all these books HAVE to be somewhat nebulous; to look like unfinished work. They are "openers" their real aim is to motivate some people to buy more expensive seminars or courses or an other book. .
3
