Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Fibs trading and PASR 0 replies

Fibs And Forks Journal 62 replies

Fibs and Forks 177 replies

Fibs, fibs, fibs 3 replies

Trading with Fibs...and Targets...! 28 replies

Attachments: Supply and Demand trading with Fibs
Exit Attachments

Supply and Demand trading with Fibs

What happened to this thread?
You gotta boop the snoot
Super Scalper Test pt3 (D.T.) Return This Week: na
Quoting HimmerJimmer
What happened to this thread?
What happens everytime. Someone shares the holy grail, gets massive attention then dissapears cause turns out its not that profitable.

I wonder why people keeps seeking for a profitable trading method on internet forums. Its just blind leading the blind.
Quoting Byrig
{quote} What happens everytime. Someone shares the holy grail, gets massive attention then dissapears cause turns out its not that profitable. I wonder why people keeps seeking for a profitable trading method on internet forums. Its just blind leading the blind.
Could also be due to changing market conditions as this was started in 2011. A lot of these threads are pretty old and they start off really decent but over time just die off as the strategy loses its edge over time I guess
You gotta boop the snoot
Super Scalper Test pt3 (D.T.) Return This Week: na
Quoting Byrig
{quote} What happens everytime. Someone shares the holy grail, gets massive attention then dissapears cause turns out its not that profitable. I wonder why people keeps seeking for a profitable trading method on internet forums. Its just blind leading the blind.
Seems like you just couldn't read couple of pages. The guys is still here and trading lol =)

Why even come here and type something if you don't believe in forums and strategies here. Always wonder, did you just lose money to the market and trying to take it out on the people here?
Quoting taksistalo
{quote} Seems like you just couldn't read couple of pages. The guys is still here and trading lol =) Why even come here and type something if you don't believe in forums and strategies here. Always wonder, did you just lose money to the market and trying to take it out on the people here?
Is he still on this forum or is he elsewhere? Last post here was in April. I've been following S/D trading for a while but haven't given much time to it. I'd like to start learning from him if he's still active
You gotta boop the snoot
Super Scalper Test pt3 (D.T.) Return This Week: na
Quoting taksistalo
{quote} Seems like you just couldn't read couple of pages. The guys is still here and trading lol =) Why even come here and type something if you don't believe in forums and strategies here. Always wonder, did you just lose money to the market and trying to take it out on the people here?
I saw him post one trade, could have been cherry picked. Then checked his twitch and all I saw was a F1 game.

I come here and other forums from time to time to remind what people is using and what is not working. Kinda like a counter indicator In fact I wrote I want him to stream some trades, real time. I have followed his channel for a long time now. Hid and bunch of others around here.

And no, I didnt just lose money. In fact today was a day off because of CPI being released. Apart from that, a pretty good week to be honest.

Sorry to burst your bubble. Keep looking for the winning strategy here, maybe you'll be lucky

Till next time.
Yeah same. All I saw was him playing some F1 games... Maybe his trades shared here worked and add value but his stream, not so much

If you want to follow a real trader/real threads here on FF:

https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...r-flow?page=16

https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...trader?page=18
Hi all, long term member here but never posted. I have been trading forex for almost 10 years with inconsistent success across many strategies including supply and demand. I would get frustrated with zones constantly not being respected until recently.

I have tried the usual advise of long candles, leaving the zone fast equals strongest zone etc etc etc. I have found a very simple technique which takes away all of the over analysis, rules and discretion.

Using a 50 and 20 MA to identify previous supply and demand zones has increased my success rate like no tomorrow! Below are some LIVE trades I am in, I'm not posting previous setups as anyone can do that and doesn't help anyone really. I find a supply or demand zone sitting above or below another supply and demand and the highest probability I have personally seen. When it does not respect the initial zone the one above or below where it started is the area I enter>

Again this does not seem to follow any traditional supply and demand trading rules at all, but its definitely working for me and that's all that matters at the end of the day.

Red line is my SL, green line my TP and yellow mark is where I entered so you can see its actually a REAL LIVE trade.

I have attached screenshots of my LIVE trades currently in as examples.
Attached Images (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: a9e69aa0c2db4910579cce846764cd08.png Size: 46 KB Click to Enlarge Name: 011d3fd60dc28635fa0bd82023172c00.png Size: 49 KB Click to Enlarge Name: 3547e291fb3135cc3bbbe6b7f0b6d9bf.png Size: 55 KB Click to Enlarge Name: c078697f4c3a3bbb2d999c512cd103b0.png Size: 53 KB
Quoting 1Hour
Hi all, long term member here but never posted. I have been trading forex for almost 10 years with inconsistent success across many strategies including supply and demand. I would get frustrated with zones constantly not being respected until recently. I have tried the usual advise of long candles, . {image} {image} {image} {image}
How do you fit your MAs into the picture? Do you draw your supply when they cross or close to each other (meaning MAs)? Or you draw your supply/demand when the price gets close to them to expect brake or bounce of them? May you please explain more?
I use the cross or strong continuation (widening MA) to assist in determine where the zone is. I draw the zones after identifying with the MA first.
just saw this thread n subscribed, seems I will love it as I use snd with fibs, hope get many experience from this thread
Hope everyone gets green pips
Quoting 1Hour
I use the cross or strong continuation (widening MA) to assist in determine where the zone is. I draw the zones after identifying with the MA first.
Ok I see. How did your trades end up? =)
Wow some really ignorant comments lately, just goes to show and maybe somewhat explain why I don't share so much, although most of it previously was binded to contracts when I got signed up to trade for the record company.

I started a stream on twitch, really excited to get that going, nothing is cherry picked as any one of my early followers will know, when I was a mere taxi driver, cherry picking was my pet hate, and something I despise, and prided myself for only ever showing my live trading, even my dollar amount that I had with my first little account was not even hidden, I planned to do the same again on twitch.

Anyway so I started my twitch stream and nobody turned up, not even 1 person, only person that turned up asked when I was going to be playing Assetto Corsa next.
So you only have yourselves to blame., it was a Sunday evening when I assumed most people would be at home and I even remember entilting it about the week ahead and looking for possible opportunities, but I waited for a good while and no one showed up. HELL, even I edited my last post about no one turning up and asked everyone a good time, and STILL no one replied but 1 person as to a suitable time for them, the following posts are people moaning about me streaming racing games (go back have a look for yourself, I literally post asking people for times, then next page, AHHH HES PLAYING VIDEO GAME) , cmon guys, you got to give to receive in this world. https://i.imgur.com/8pIATSz.png

Everything I've ever shared or taught I've done for free, and never EVER asked for a dime as I was about to do so again via free streams on twitch, so please less of the rudeness and ignorance, and if anyone ever finds value in my thread still then it's all still worth it to me.

For everybodies information, yes I still trade, I've had Audi R8's, Nissan Gt'Rs, Mercedes c63 blah blah blah been through that materialistic phase in my earlier days as i've grown maturer and realised more important things in life, I have various accounts now all dotted about doing their own thing, I have alot of time, and I mean ALOT, hence all the game playing and streaming, yes I still trade supply and demand, it's not really something that can expire, as supply and demand still drives the market as it did back then, today and into the future.
The problem I have found with the Supply and Demand strategy is it rarely works out as expected. Most of the time zones are not respected. I don't see how anyone can make a living from such a strategy. It makes more sense to see how price responds to recent highs or lows, and then trade in favor of strength using candlestick patterns.
You don't know because you don't ask.
Quoting here2there
The problem I have found with the Supply and Demand strategy is it rarely works out as expected. Most of the time zones are not respected. I don't see how anyone can make a living from such a strategy. It makes more sense to see how price responds to recent highs or lows, and then trade in favor favor of strength using candlestick patterns.
Works with confluence, fibs RN's etc IMO
Quoting here2there
The problem I have found with the Supply and Demand strategy is it rarely works out as expected. Most of the time zones are not respected. I don't see how anyone can make a living from such a strategy. It makes more sense to see how price responds to recent highs or lows, and then trade in favor of strength using candlestick patterns.

Well there's your first faliure already, supply and demand is NOT a strategy, it is a law, it is a driver, it is not something you can copy and paste and colour by numbers.

You can create a strategy using supply and demand as the main driver maybe, but as a singular.

Like myself, once you can spot supply and demand with just looking at your chart with your naked eyes, everything changed for me, my eyes were opened.
Upon which of course I built a system to work with using supply and demand as my respected driver, bring in fibs, and a few other bits just as above user mentioned, then you are closer to something which can be called a strategy. Supply and demand is a law, in pretty much everything, business, sales, food chain, stock market etc etc etc, not a strategy lol. With whatever you choose to trade with, no matter what you choose, if you disrespect the law of supply and demand then you will lose either way.

If you perceive supply and demand as a strategy you are at a place where you still have alot to learn, and much to respect within the markets.
Quoting deankenny21
{quote} Well there's your first faliure already, supply and demand is NOT a strategy, it is a law, it is a driver, it is not something you can copy and paste and colour by numbers. You can create a strategy using supply and demand as the main driver maybe, but as a singular. Like myself, once you can spot supply and demand with just looking at your chart with your naked eyes, everything changed for me, my eyes were opened. Upon which of course I built a system to work with using supply and demand as my respected driver, bring in fibs, and a few...
Well, yes, I understand it is a law. But when I say, 'strategy,' I am not in error. I am referring to the method commonly taught on trading so-called Supply and Demand zones in the Forex market.

I have a very good supply and demand indicator. When I say it is 'very good,' I mean to say it is quite accurate in drawing so-called supply and demand zones. It was when I tested this indicator in MT4's Strategy Tester that my eyes were opened to how unreliable the strategy is.

But perhaps you have found a better way to trade these zones. If so, then that is good for you.
You don't know because you don't ask.
Quoting deankenny21
{quote} Well there's your first faliure already, supply and demand is NOT a strategy, it is a law, it is a driver, it is not something you can copy and paste and colour by numbers. You can create a strategy using supply and demand as the main driver maybe, but as a singular. Like myself, once you can spot supply and demand with just looking at your chart with your naked eyes, everything changed for me, my eyes were opened. Upon which of course I built a system to work with using supply and demand as my respected driver, bring in fibs, and a few...
Your posting have been fantastic I think and the fact they are not cherry picked makes you genuine and not like many other posts!

Im really bad at putting questions into words so I’ll give it a crack, please let me know if it dosnt make sence!

might just be me, but I have noticed that often when price races fast towards a zone during the uk and us session (high liquidity) and then slows down and stops at the end of the session, it it’s close to the zone then there it seems to drastically increase the likelihood of the zone being respected during the Asian session. Just wondered if you had any observations or thoughts on this?
Here are some examples of current open trades I was explaining regarding when a zone is entered at the end of the US session. Price often becomes exhausted and then the 'bargain hunters' enter at the commencement of the Asian session which seems to increase the likelihood of the zone being respected. Just my personal observation would love to hear your feedback!

I apologise the first trade is completed for profit but the second two are live and still open.
Attached Images (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Closed Trade.JPG Size: 54 KB Click to Enlarge Name: Open Trade 1.JPG Size: 63 KB Click to Enlarge Name: Open Trade.JPG Size: 57 KB
Quoting Byrig
{quote} What happens everytime. Someone shares the holy grail, gets massive attention then dissapears cause turns out its not that profitable. I wonder why people keeps seeking for a profitable trading method on internet forums. Its just blind leading the blind.
Its actually that most people can’t follow it, that’s the issue. I can say hand on heart this thread owner has improved my trading tenfolds. I always knew I was close but couldn’t quite get it. The information posted here was just that little extra I needed. When you see zones you see them and they become EASY to see! The R:R is so large even if you was only 50% successful you would be way in front.

@deankenny21 I can not thank you enough!
0 traders viewing now