Is that the real market structure that offer the edge over the market? Does it really give alpha? Ofc you know the answer. No one has to tell it to you, we are all smart enough.
Trade the value
Price Action and Trading Discussion 5,928 replies
Price action at the core / tma intra day 5,016 replies
Price Action discussion 26 replies
Disliked{quote} That manual is the typical market structure. This market structure philosophy has PRICE ACTION build central to it. Most people learn and do understand this market structure that's espoused in countless books, YouTube videos and forums. Yet high percentage of traders lose money. Many members of this forum are still searching for a solution after many years of experience in the market. Is that the real market structure that offer the edge over the market? Does it really give alpha? Ofc you know the answer. No one has to tell it to you, we...Ignored
DislikedI have spent time reading Shahabas thread, also many others, and through about 30 books, market structure etc is repeated over and over again, it seems as though all the information is the same, it's just dressed up differently, labelled differently, sold differently, but the common theme is most people are buying and selling in the same spot. You can see this in the GU and EU threads quite clearly s&d S&R exhaustion and order blocks, they are all in the same area give or take a few feet, inchs whatever.Ignored
Disliked{quote} The complete and detail market structure analysis of the daily gold market trade. {image} {image} {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} thank you BWilliam for sharing the charts, i am also learning things and treat my this question as my learning, a.Why price has not reach the marked arrows yet b. Which side arrows it will target first. Regards {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} The following 2 pics should answer your questions. {image} {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} please find below further queries and consider this as my learning dont get annoyed we are not fighting just brain storming. if any annotations possible or text to support the chart will be much appreciated Thank you BWilliam in anticipation {image} {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} please find below further queries and consider this as my learning dont get annoyed we are not fighting just brain storming. if any annotations possible or text to support the chart will be much appreciated Thank you BWilliam in anticipation {image} {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} There are 4 standout points on the chart marked by zigzag. The trader can enter his buy trade at ANY candle to make profit. There are 50candle(99%) close that would end up in profit hitting target. Doesn't matter which candle the trader open his buy trade it makes profit. The ONLY difference is how much profit he makes. Pinpoint accuracy talk is nonsense and not necessary. No special trading skill required. The key question is "do the trader truly understand market structure" to know the future business direction of the market ? Do the standard...Ignored
Disliked{image}Target, target, target Many George's followers claimed they solved it. Good for them. Only 1 had show the before and after chart, 3 or 4 times. None have show the solution to that puzzle. Most likely they will never show it if ever they cracked the puzzle. As for me the puzzle is way above my head. Oh yes these arrows fall under the puzzle - {image} BUT what happened after all those arrows had been taken I can explained to you without any problem.Ignored
Disliked{quote} Without being sound rude, george have never told anything to be honest. you have to pick and guess on your own Why is that? I mean why to hide it one may fear that the algorithm may be changed and we also lose to earn as more people know how the market moves but i respect him being an elder and that he spent several hours on charts and its good for him but not for us, either he don't like to share or he don't know but i am no one to comment on either side. but now this forum should be to learn and share more rather hide things and...Ignored
DislikedThanks, I understand to a certain extent of how you approached this, but my question would be, the targets: are they the tops you have circled below? so they are all for consideration as things unfold? and do you reference anything from the 15 min chart to target on the one minute? {image}Ignored
Disliked{quote} Without being sound rude, george have never told anything to be honest. you have to pick and guess on your own Why is that? I mean why to hide it one may fear that the algorithm may be changed and we also lose to earn as more people know how the market moves but i respect him being an elder and that he spent several hours on charts and its good for him but not for us, either he don't like to share or he don't know but i am no one to comment on either side. but now this forum should be to learn and share more rather hide things and...Ignored
Disliked{quote} George said we should be boundless in our thinking. I personally have taken his work and expanded further in an effort to understand the targets. Though we don't have all the information visible for us in the standard charts (we can only see filled orders) one will have go to further and look at the possibility of unfilled orders and where possibly you can find them. What he emphasized is work, work and work. He correctly and repeatedly said this is not for the lazy (and don't look at it in a negative way). The knowledge that he shared has...Ignored