Disliked{quote} The Traders_Dynamic_Index has several different versions since 2005 ands by 2011, there was the Synergy_Pro_TDI released. Why so many diferent versions over the years between 2005 and 2011? Why did the OP Big E used only the first version which he subscribed to CompassFX in 2006? He got the new version Advanced TDI version in 2010, did he use that newer version? A lot of back-testing and forward testing of the TDIs done between 2012 and 2017. The results is not better that what you posted using the Stochastics and the MACD. But the testing...Ignored
If you look at the picture, you will see MACD is not performed well I mean MACD doesn't have enough edge according to the backtest result. On the other hand, Stochastics have a little bit of edge over the years in the market. I just wanted to know TDI have a little bit of edge or not, Probably it has. Let me ask the questions in a different way, If you have asked to choose one from these 3 indicators (Stochastics, MACD, TDI) which one you will choose and why?
MA provides the market's current direction and strength.