Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Trading Made Simple the right way, and other trading lessons 334 replies

Monitor for 'Trading Made Simple' system 563 replies

Indicators for the 'Trading Made Simple' system 343 replies

MTF Indicators for the 'Trading Made Simple' system 241 replies

Trading Made Simple system follower - Thanks to eelfranz 9 replies

Attachments: Trading Made Simple
Exit Attachments

Trading Made Simple

EUR/USD H1 Chart.

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: eurusd-h1-fxopen-investments-inc-2.png Size: 41 KB


Which one of the two candles here considered as the setup candle? I guess the first one is the setup candle the second the entry candle right? However the TDI Cross here first happened on the second candle, so this might be to later already now.

Or do you always look at the lower timeframes (M30/M15 here) here to place your entry on the TDI Cross happened earlier?

In my understanding it would be valid to only look at H1 if i want to trade H1 because you also aim for a bigger profit as on M30/15. So i would enter short with the opening or close (more conservative) of the next candle after the setup candle.
Quoting realjumper
{quote} That's the point, as I have said quite a few times now. There is no need to show any sensitive data on the TE, it has options of what to show. There is no need to show anything more that what they claim on their charts, but what the TE offers is a complete picture of wins, losses and much more, but no sensitive data if the TE owner wishes that to be so. Still waiting for a simple answer to my question, but Emmanuel (for one) has kept me waiting for about 3 years now, so I don't expect a simple answer to a simple question from these 'teachers'.....and...
The same can be asked of you, or Iddd or Jester
Where is your Trade Explorer?
------
The very same member's that are nagging to see TE's don't even have their own TE's.
(Double standards are the norm in FF.)
Quoting onejester
{quote} Would you like a shovel to dig?
Yes please.
Prefer a gold plated shovel.
How big and deep must the hole be.
Quoting Tekkies
{quote} The same can be asked of you, or Iddd or Jester Where is your Trade Explorer? ------ The very same member's that are nagging to see TE's don't even have their own TE's. (Double standards are the norm in FF.)

I am not 'teaching' nor am I making any claims of trades.

Why do you refuse to employ a TE to support your claims?
Doing what you like is Freedom. Liking what you do is Happiness.
Quoting Tekkies
Yesterday's trades {image}
I see you only posting DE30 charts the last weeks, what happened to currencies like GU? Doesn´t it work any longer?
Quoting Tekkies
{quote} The same can be asked of you, or Iddd or Jester Where is your Trade Explorer? ------ The very same member's that are nagging to see TE's don't even have their own TE's. (Double standards are the norm in FF.)
Like said i would love to provide you with it, either link it to a TE here or MyFxBook or even give investors pw. But the problem here is that i started trading with these accounts long before experimenting with the TMS strategy and even now still some of my trades are not made by the TMS strategy.

So this would probably just confuse people instead of help. Also i am not the one teaching people here or claiming everything to be King or profitable for 85% and so on...
Quoting realjumper
{quote} That's the point, as I have said quite a few times now. There is no need to show any sensitive data on the TE, it has options of what to show. There is no need to show anything more that what they claim on their charts, but what the TE offers is a complete picture of wins, losses and much more, but no sensitive data if the TE owner wishes that to be so. Still waiting for a simple answer to my question, but Emmanuel (for one) has kept me waiting for about 3 years now, so I don't expect a simple answer to a simple question from these 'teachers'.....and...
Just as you have the prerogative to show what you want they also have the same prerogative ... so I guess like everything else in business you do your own due diligence with the facts that are available ... but I must say I do find your tenacity interesting considering that you have not even tried the rules first hand especially as you say you have been challenging this for 3 years.
Time for me to move on from this conversation as it has little value of my time and we must agree to disagree.
In conclusion I must say my adaption of the Big E's rules have proven to be financially beneficial ... my TE say 9.4% this week ... I'm happy ... I am sure you could do much better or maybe you already do ... that is for you to know.
All the best
When you are successful perhaps give a thought to others ... Kiva dot org
Quoting PayItForward
{quote} Just as you have the prerogative to show what you want they also have the same prerogative ... so I guess like everything else in business you do your own due diligence with the facts that are available ... but I must say I do find your tenacity interesting considering that you have not even tried the rules first hand especially as you say you have been challenging this for 3 years. Time for me to move on from this conversation as it has little value of my time and we must agree to disagree. In conclusion I must say my adaption of the Big...

Sigh.....Again......all I'm asking is for them to show a TE to back up their claims. If they choose not to, then I would like an answer FROM THEM, as to why not.

It's really simple......Why do they refuse to answer a simple question?????
Doing what you like is Freedom. Liking what you do is Happiness.
Quoting Tekkies
{quote} The same can be asked of you, or Iddd or Jester Where is your Trade Explorer? ------ The very same member's that are nagging to see TE's don't even have their own TE's. (Double standards are the norm in FF.)
I don't believe in this method, nor do I believe it is correct for Emmanuel7788 to produce that much information it becomes confusing to new traders.

The thread should be closed, but since it isn't I'm not adding any less value than those who choose to not show any consistency.

When the quality goes up, I'll happily have nothing to say.
'in less than half an hour he made over 100 ticks'
Quoting realjumper
{quote} I am not 'teaching' nor am I making any claims of trades. Why do you refuse to employ a TE to support your claims?
1. BigE is the teacher, I am a student.
2. Don't claim either. How could I? Not my method. I only follow the rules that the teacher has made.
3. Chart posted is enough proof that rules (applied correctly) does work and can be verified easily.
4. Don't need too, nor required.
5. What for?
6. Not my method so I don't have to proof anything.
7. Not here to win a popularity show or a beauty contest.
8. ..............

a Few post's back Jumper you posted that you and BigE vouched for each other and that is way you are on his buddy list. The way your post's read lately indicate that after all these years you never really believed in what BigE has posted nor that this method is anything but unprofitable.

Now you want to use a TE to "proof" the validity of this method. Sorry, that is not going to happen with my TE. TMS is not a easy method to trade with despite the title. An TE will lead to false expectation and who will be called out. Even the chart's posted are being question by member's (floating man, con-artist). Not going to walk that road again.

Chart's are posted without any information. Why? There are a few checklist for this method (paperclip). Member's can use a checklist or BigE's training chart's and post's to find the reasons for that entry on that chart posted. That is how I learned

This will be my last response in regards to anything related to Trade Explorer's.
------------
Point in case. a Member has asked which bar is the setup candle. A question asked and answered many times. Emm posted last week again one of BigE's training charts that show clearly which bar is what.
Quoting onejester
{quote} I don't believe in this method, nor do I believe it is correct for Emmanuel7788 to produce that much information it becomes confusing to new traders. The thread should be closed, but since it isn't I'm not adding any less value than those who choose to not show any consistency. When the quality goes up, I'll happily have nothing to say.
While everyone is fighting... Not proving anything...still.

I destroyed the market this week. Before and after NFP..Still have trades in positive but will post just this. The extra doesn't even matter at this point.

Photo shop? Maybe? You never know...

Don't worry I wont be bothering the rest of you TMS clowns... Ready to withdraw and enjoy the weekend!
Attached Image(s) (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: tms11.png Size: 235 KB
Click to Enlarge Name: tms12.png Size: 266 KB
Click to Enlarge Name: tms13.png Size: 109 KB
You will learn the most from your losing Trades
And still going down...

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: haha.png Size: 238 KB
You will learn the most from your losing Trades
Quoting lddd
{quote} I see you only posting DE30 charts the last weeks, what happened to currencies like GU? Doesn´t it work any longer?
Why do you ask a "fake trader" a question Iddd?
GU does work. Due to USA trade war and GBP Brexit GBPUSD is not for me at this stage.
Also DE30 spread is constant at 10 pips.
Quoting Tekkies
{quote} 1. BigE is the teacher, I am a student. 2. Don't claim either. How could I? Not my method. I only follow the rules that the teacher has made. 3. Chart posted is enough proof that rules (applied correctly) does work and can be verified easily. 4. Don't need too, nor required. 5. What for? 6. Not my method so I don't have to proof anything. 7. Not here to win a popularity show or a beauty contest. 8. .............. a Few post's back Jumper you posted that you and BigE vouched for each other and that is way you are on his buddy list. The way...
a Few post's back Jumper you posted that you and BigE vouched for each other and that is way you are on his buddy list. The way your post's read lately indicate that after all these years you never really believed in what BigE has posted nor that this method is anything but unprofitable.

I'm not quite sure how you deduced all that from a simple question I have asked, which is simply to ask you (and other teachers, chart posters) to employ a TE to support your claims. If you refuse to do so, then the question is 'why not?'

Both you and PayItForward are making a lot of assumptions about my motives and/or trading abilities to try and deflect from the simple question. I know that Emmanuel is a wriggly character when it comes to answering this question which I have asked for 3 years, but I thought better of you. My mistake.

Now you want to use a TE to "proof" the validity of this method.

No. I want to see the TE as proof of your claims and to ensure that you're not cherry picking certain trades. I have never ever mentioned the validity of this system.

Sorry, that is not going to happen with my TE. TMS is not a easy method to trade with despite the title. An TE will lead to false expectation and who will be called out. Even the chart's posted are being question by member's (floating man, con-artist). Not going to walk that road again.

A TE would end all those false expectations and would stop all the 'floating man, con artist accusations in a heart beat.

Chart's are posted without any information. Why? There are a few checklist for this method (paperclip). Member's can use a checklist or BigE's training chart's and post's to find the reasons for that entry on that chart posted. That is how I learned

Indeed, but that has nothing to do with my simple question.

This will be my last response in regards to anything related to Trade Explorer's.

I'm sure it is. Some people are willing to post charts and 'guide' (aka 'teach') newbies, but they can not offer any evidence that they can walk the walk. Too easy to just talk the talk, until someone like me comes along and calls them out. Then the squirming and excuses begin.
Doing what you like is Freedom. Liking what you do is Happiness.
Quoting catalin_eros
{quote} MN BEEB and space to fall, W1 BEOB. Your emas look as they should, too. That pin from the week 13-17.08 would have kept me out, but that is not part of my question. I was not referring to Big E's rule of entering on the first or second candle, I was just asking if there is any reason you did not enter one candle earlier, as there was a signal there given by the TDI and 5 ema. The week started on the 3rd, and your entry was on the 4th.

You do not always have to enter a trade using APB/HA candle 1 and 2,

Big E our teacher did say when we can enter a trade with APB#3

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Post 351 candle no3.png Size: 275 KB
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
Learn from Buddha's wisdom

Attached Image
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
My favourite post is Big E' Post#647

I think Big E still is the best TMS teacher.

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Big E Post 647.png Size: 122 KB


Attached Image
Honesty is a very expensive gift. You wont find it in cheap people.WBuffett
A good trader once wrote this, somewhere on Forexfactory. - Truth be told; i've learned alot from his trading, and i really do believe that P&L is a personal thing, ind the end, we are all here to make money, and make a living of our passion.

Stay healthy everyone.


Quote
So anyway, I thought to myself, 'why do I bother?'........I have a win/loss rate of about 80%. Yes, yes, I know.....some muppet is going to call me a liar unless I show my account etc etc etc.....but guess what?.....I don't have to do that.....I don't have to prove anything to anyone. I don't care who believes or doesn't believe. Those that put in the long term effort will find out the truth for themselves.

I thought about not making any further effort here and just trading for myself, and to hell with the thread.

I thought about opening an MT4...
MY SITTING, NEVER MY THINKING!
Quoting merrygold
A good trader once wrote this, somewhere on Forexfactory. - Truth be told; i've learned alot from his trading, and i really do believe that P&L is a personal thing, ind the end, we are all here to make money, and make a living of our passion. Stay healthy everyone. {quote}

I wrote that in 2012, now it's 2018.

I have already stated, several times, that in hindsight I should have employed a TE, but I cannot go back and do that now as I no longer trade that method. Similarly Big E is not with us, so neither can he.

Is the a point you would like to make???
Doing what you like is Freedom. Liking what you do is Happiness.
EUR/USD H1 Short, TP where?

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: eurusd-h1-fxopen-investments-inc-5.png Size: 48 KB
7 traders viewing now