That statement makes it say that only stoc is an indicator but so is tdi. Both indicators mimic price they Don't confirm anything
1
1
Trading Made Simple the right way, and other trading lessons 332 replies
Monitor for 'Trading Made Simple' system 563 replies
Indicators for the 'Trading Made Simple' system 343 replies
MTF Indicators for the 'Trading Made Simple' system 241 replies
Trading Made Simple system follower - Thanks to eelfranz 9 replies
DislikedBig Jim, #1 in importance is PA, #2 is the TDI for confirmation & Stochs is just an indicator I note. If TDI & Stochs are oppositre... I may pass on the trade...Ignored
DislikedA/U - Also note TDI & Stochs hooking over... Last nights trade ... {image}Ignored
DislikedThis is the first time I write something on forex factory even if I'm involved in trading since more 10 year. I have great respect for emmanuel work just like the common efforts of everyone here. Really a great community! I'm a trader with mixed results, always traded conservatively and in the last periods I'm having a more deep understanding of markets reality. Unfortunately I did not have the chance to read everything since I had hard journey with personal diffiulties. I would be grateful if Emmanuel can recap briefly the way he does his top down...Ignored
DislikedHere we go again. Price vs Indicator https://www.tradeciety.com/is-price-...an-indicators/Ignored
Disliked{quote} What a fool you are you post this and what I said is exactly what they said indicators mimic priceIgnored
Disliked{quote} The heading of that web page Divergence is: "Busting 5 Price Action Trading Myths" Did I post any context that contradict your post's.? Since you made it personal by calling me a fool. Here is something to think about. (it takes a big fool to see a small fool) Now Divergence how do you read price?. Let me see. Oh yes, you use Pattern 123. One of your chart you posted Drawing lines on the chart, number the HH, LL with 1,2,3, or A,B,C. Trying to predict where the...Ignored
Disliked{quote} Well that is what I thought Tekkies. " Well there is no difference between your metode, TDI or Price Action ". How wrong I was with that idea, I even argued with Divergence last year when he attacked the TDI indicator. I decided to test his ideas out and try and prove him wrong. I first tested the market profile and then started to included a few of his setups to my trading strategy which were his 123's, HH & HL and 2b's etc. I just proved I was wrong, price action leads in both time and profits. Indicators lag and here's an example. On...Ignored
DislikedGood post Rick and CG here's the thing we all started out with indicators we all wanted trading to be simple BUT unless you do the work of learning how to read a chart you will spin you wheels forever. I came to that realization about 8 year's ago I am just trying to save you time and money. By the way Rick not using MP just pullback into s and d along with 123 2b break pullback for reversalsIgnored
Disliked{quote} Well that is what I thought Tekkies. " Well there is no difference between your metode, TDI or Price Action ". How wrong I was with that idea, I even argued with Divergence last year when he attacked the TDI indicator. I decided to test his ideas out and try and prove him wrong. I first tested the market profile and then started to included a few of his setups to my trading strategy which were his 123's, HH & HL and 2b's etc. I just proved I was wrong, price action leads in both time and profits. Indicators lag and here's an example. On...Ignored
DislikedIn one breathe you say s and r is no good in the next breathe you use them. Personality I don't use them. Supply and demand now that's a different story. I have done videos of live trading my p and l is there for all to see I don't see the point with your request especially when your trading dimes and not dollars enough saidIgnored
Disliked{quote}
There is many ways to trade Forex.
Yours is not the only way or the only correct way eitherIgnored