Trading Made Simple

EURUSD H4 TDI bounce but market liquidity is very thin and the price action shows sideways ranging.
Not a good time to trade now.
In a normal trading week, this hour is after London session closed, would you trade H4 during this NY session?

hi
which ea do you use and which setting do you use for it ?
thanks

more nice looking H4 setups with TDI,

but today is not the time for H4 trading.



Attachment g

Hi mortezakh,

that is not a trading robot type of EA.
it is a trade manager EA which manages trades by following my trade plan.
it is custom developed by a few active TMS traders working in collaboration for few years going back to 2013.
you wont find it in this thread because it is not allowed here.
some people here don't want to discuss anything which the OP did not talked about.

Hi classy,

that TMS VertLine is based on price action.
we got the inspiration from Big E training chart post#10,736 and developed the smart tool to draw those lines in realtime market following the price action. It does not show in the chart history but only in the realtime mode.
With this tool, we can trade and capture the entire swing of 3 to 8 candles.

Classy,
In the attachment area there is an indicator showing the quality of the TDI cross.
Title is: Trader's Dynamic Index RealTime 2015 clock.
See if this is close to what you have in mind.
Best to you,
Frank
https://www.forexfactory.com/attachm...1&d=1514327099

execellant big emm.hope one day this vertical line will be available here for test .....thanks

Is it just me (and Classy), or can we do without the negative vibes on this thread? Thanks you to all the members who are trying to save us 'newbies', but you really don't need to bother. We are all big girls and boys and can make our own mind up. Many thanks.

Can you stop trolling this thread now? I started reading the TMS thread earlier this year and have been successful at implementing the ideas of BOTH Big E (which Emannuell7788 recommended doing) AND the more current, timely, and contextually relevant posts and information posted by Emmanuel7788 himself.

The attraction was the high standing it has on the 'Trading Systems' Forum on FF. So thank you Emmanuel7788 for the fantastic job you (and others - to a lesser degree) have had in keeping this thread not only active but current and relevant. I have learnt a great deal from Emmanuel7788, but also from the legendary: Copernicus (& Ramadas) over at 'Diversified Trend Trading Approach'; Strat; Hanover; the incomparable mladen and his great work; as well as many many other positive and proactive members of FF that I just can not name. Thank you all for a great 2017. All of whom Emmanuel7788 has mentioned in his posts and holds in high regard as a student himself.

I am disappointed that Emanuel7788 has felt the need to go elsewhere to share some of his knowledge and not feel safe here, to share it with everyone.

The stain on the year, however, has got to be the trolls on this thread who have not contributed, but spilled their vitriol all over the place in the name of their high morals and ethics. From my humble position, I would like to make it clear that I do not NEED to be saved. I have my eyes wide open and my guard up when I read open Forex forums. Your argument would be that I, personally, may be OK but you are 'protecting' other newbies who may be more naive? My reply would be that if the trolls in this thread were honest and had been doing Forex for as long as they say, then they would acknowledge that we all need our fair share of mistakes and failures in the beginning - this is part of the process of learning. Not that any sane person can not see the massive contribution that Emmanuel7788 has made, and the waste of time and aggravation your contributions have had in contrast. You want to save this thread? Where are your charts? Where is your positive and proactive contribution and collaboration?

I take pride in the diversity of TMS (and other) threads I read, from wonderful Likicas 'TMS for 30M charts', to Davit's 'Pivot Trading', to the historical (now mostly dormant) X-man's, etc. Yes, and the relationship between, Emanuel7788 and Davit is just that - their relationship, not mine! See how I did that, exercise MY prerogative and judgement to make a choice that benefits ME. We don't need to be saved. In fact my opinion is that it is disrespectful of you to jump to the assumption that just because we are new to Forex that we are impaired or disabled in any way: we can not read, we can not understand, we can not fail and learn from our own mistakes. In fact why not start a thread, seeing as this is the main theme of your argument against E7788? Help people against the perils of FF and FF thread charlatans on your own thread! I am sure your warnings would be really appreciated buy the newbies you are trying to protect.

If anyone else is dissatisfied then please use the following to make your opinions known to the Administrators of this thread:





Please note that when we press the "Clean Up" button you get a drop down menu that gives us the option to choose what in particular may offend us, from 'Focus on Trading', to 'respect fellow traders', and 'No Bickering', et cetera.

I would humbly request that the Administrator (and interested members) of this thread help to keep this thread clean from the disrespect and side-tracking that has been going on.

Seasons greetings to all, and best wishes for a happy and prosperous 2018!

SanAshi
a Few miss consumption in post 84 708. a Newbie after 18 month? Really?
"negative vibes on this thread" is caused by one member that does not follow the instructions of BigE.
The so called "trolls" want Emmanuel7788 to open his own thread where he can post what every he want's to post.

As to "their high morals and ethics" you are wrong, it is one of two follow BigE's instruction's or get out. To become a successful trader you need for one discipline. Discipline to follow a trading method, rules. Negative vibes are caused by lack of discipline by one member. The "fantastic job" can also happen in a thread where the "job" can swap, change, add, remove to the currant prevailing method.

Was also a newbie, got lead astray by Emmanuel7788 and his so called "current, timely, and contextually relevant posts and information posts" which in many cases contain no relevancy to any of BigE's post's or 5-method. It took more then 4 month's to unlearn the wrong that has been posted.

By all means "fail and learn from our own mistakes" enjoy the trip.

Edit: Read chapter XII in Reminiscence of a Stock Operator you might understand what is currently happening in Trading Made Simple.

Sad news.

Many of you may know member dcginc (realname Rick Galloway). He was one of the pioneer members during the time when Big E started this thread.
Rick started his own website forum , you will find the link in his profile page. He is one of the more successful TMS traders among us.

I have been following his website since the time it was started. He shared many very articles about trading and trading psychology. Some of the TMS traders here also took his courses and became better traders. I did not take any of his courses but I read every of his weekly posts. What I benefited most was his WMA Weekly Market Analysis - his weekly top down analysis which many of us would follow and comparing with our own Big Picture Plan.
I stopped reading his website for more than one year and only during this holiday period that I went back to catch up with his posts.

Today, I am shock to read the sad news at his forum that his family suffered a tragedy. His family loss their young son Max.

For those who knew Rick, our thoughts are with him and his family.
https://protradernetwork.com/category/market-analysis/
Do drop by his forum and get the most recent updates. There are still plenty of old articles to read and learn.

Very sad news indeed. I never subscribed to Ricks paid course, but am on his free newsletter and he shared this news and his planned absence a few emails ago. While Rick went "commercial", my impression was always he wanted to help fellow traders. Good guy, and good trader too.

Note sure who, but someone compiled his posts into a pdf and it has been posted in the thread few times. Its a relatively short PDF, but with lots of TMS and general trading wisdom. PDF is posted below, a good read for all TMS traders of any level.

All the best to Rick.

Nik

P.S. Rick also made some very interesting videos on TMS themed topics and general market analysis. Good free content on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC5c...9JyryeQ/videos

Hi SanAshi.

Thats you point of view and thats your right.

But i have a other view.

To make it short:

emanuell7788 has no need to go elsewhere to share his non TMS stuff. He just have to follow the rules like everbody has to. In simple open a thread where he can kick renegades like me. Period. I dont know how to say it in english but you are mixing up things. First he promised to open a own thread here on FF years back hoping his critics will silent after a time. Than he showed some median crashed TE and THAN decided to hide with a private club. Why should this sissy be treated special? Look what he have done to this thread, the dead OP the real friends of the OP which just asked him for showing respecht to the wishes of the OP. The dissed profitraders. This guys gives a f'.....++ about others feelings. There is so many bullshit hes responsable for... But it all can be cleared with just follow the rules. Must be hard for sure..

That the former nice TMS thread is now a trashbin is his fault.


Happy trading

Two of the last H4 trade setup with TMS VLine work out with some profits.

Well, Rick did chose to go commercial but he did so with good intentions and provided very good trading education which has helped many traders.

It is unlike other members who came to this thread and took the hard work of others and sell them online claiming its their own work and selling trade signal service through subscriptions, etc.

GBPUSD Dec 27 H4

In a sideways ranging market type and low liquidity, you will experience many TDI for entry and exit trades will go no where.

So not trading H4 during this year end holidays is a good idea to preserve trading capital.

thanks frank but i can't understand ,what you are trying to share? is Trader's Dynamic Index RealTime 2015 clock same as emma's vertical line or ....? please tell me details and share indicator links.

I have 4 trade today.
Is it true TMS system?

Tekkies, no misconceptions at all. Retail Forex is not a sprint, it's marathon. There is a lot to learn and understand, and even then it is an uphill battle for most. What I have learned while reading a variety of threads on FF is that most fresh newbies can be lazy and not actually read the thread, or summaries suggested, but some have the audacity not to even read the first post! Even though I have been learning on micro demos and real accounts over 5-6 years I feel I am just at the tipping point of holding my head above water. Yes newbie, because my knowledge, skill and lack of success (so far) does not qualify me to describe myself otherwise. Especially with such legends that have been around longer, know more and are more successful than I am. All of whom I hold in very high regard, and two on this very thread - one deceased, one not.

I acknowledge your perspective and that of others who may have a different opinion. Everyone has a right to disagree. The issue that I am addressing is that I feel that these disagreements are crossing the line. You can say what you want, I do not mind. But when intellectual arguments and disagreements degenerate into all-out slagging matches I think it is inappropriate and it distracts from the quality and attractiveness of the thread. It interferes with our job of learning in order to trade successfully.

I do not know if you have noticed, but the Original Poster (OP) of this thread has passed away. His work remains! Anyone and everyone can go right back to post #1 and start reading the posts one-by-one. Not only this, but Emmanuel7788 and others are constantly pointing new people to pdf summaries of Big E's work. You may see this as anathema, but I see it as a great tribute and honour to Big E to keep the thread active and vibrant to everyone that swings past. It is what attracted me and a lot of other people from what I can see.

"Always sell what shows you a loss and keep what shows you a profit."(p.197)
Emanuel7788 reminds us of this all the time. I am very keen to learn more about money management from Emmannuel7788 and replicate some of the amazing trade reports he has posted. You, and others, denounce him for his losses. I really do not understand - if we are all honest here EVERYONE has blown an account, or two, or more. Whether demo or real. So what? This is just part of the learning process.

Starting another thread
Why because a few want him to? What about the rest of us who value his contribution and want him to stay on this thread? Do we get a voice? You've mentioned it once, twice, ....how long do we have to endure the distracting tantrums? I have an idea, why don't you guys get together and write an article of the evils of the current TMS thread and save it as a pdf, then when newcomers ask about material we can add this to the list of required reading? Another idea would be for you guys to get together and start a new thread - and complain incessantly there, how does that sound?

Lack of relevance to Big-E's posts and/or 5-method
Honestly, Emmanuel7788 has smoked everyone in this area, there is no one who I have come across who knows the intricacies of the method, different time-frames, TDI indicators, Heiken Ashi, risk - from high, to moderate, to conservative, EAs, the history, the many variants that have existed and exist today, etc., etc. etc.. I stand to be corrected on the previous statement, but the man posts prolifically. He posts his plain charts, his analysis, educational material from Big-E AND his own. No one comes close. Most of the time he is first to answer questions on a whole host of TMS related stuff. It is unfair that detractors want to totally ignore the mans work and gloss over it as if he is a defiler of something religious. He is not doing any such thing. All one has to do is go back and read. Some of us can read, and choose to read. The answers are there in 84,700 odd-posts. Sure there are arguments and disagreements but life moves on.

If anyone has trouble reading and understanding Big-E's posts then the problem does not lie with Emmanuel7788, the problem lies with the individuals who have reading difficulties. The logical fix would be to get the material translated or to make an effort to improve their reading and comprehension of the English.

Chapter 12
Thank you for the reading, I enjoyed it - if anyone wants the pdf PM me (i'm not sure about the copyright rules with respect to this). You are trying to infer that Emmanuel7788 has nefarious motivations and agendas, or that he is simply a great salesman that will ruin our trading if we listen, or learn from him. I have read the chapter and do not see the comparison with Percy Thomas, the Cotton trader in the chapter nor the salesman in the chapter. No one on this thread is going to loose 2 million dollars because they will be manipulated by Emmanuel7788. We are all micro or mini traders (demo, and real at best), and if anyone is stupid enough to learn Forex with that amount of money, I think they deserve to loose it. Look, Tekkies, we are all human beings, no one is perfect, and I am not trying to paint Emmanuel7788 out as a saint. The reality for ME (and others) is that he has done nothing but help and support on this and other threads he posts on. All we see is your hate and anger. Is it time to let it go, or find an equitable solution? Can you please acknowledge there are two side to this argument with complaints from both sides.

Well, Malony, one persons trash is another person's treasure. What you and Tekkies find offensive and disrespectful to Big-E, others find useful and important 5 years down the track of the OP's passing. It is all perspective.

I understand your message Malony but you don't have to resort to name-calling, swearing, and personal attacks just to make your point. If anything it makes you guys look like the villains in this if nothing else.

Lefevre, E., & Markman, J. D. (2010). Reminiscences of a stock operator: with new commentary and insights on the life and times of Jesse Livermore. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons.

This can be funny go down much, well maybe.
And more funny is, I like the fight here in Battlefield TMS. I want to make it clear that you have to finish this conversation style. I know already that adding new strategies, many indicators over the main strategy is sometime unnecessary, but hey , some of them are useful. Even BigE did not want it. But he will not like more this conversation style over his thread even he pass away 5 years ago. Think about. Trading Made Simple and Thinking Simple. It actually does not bother me adding new strategies over the main, I can clearly see if I need them. I appreciate the work of Emm and others, but it disturbs me to open the thread and see a new daily candle of fights. Isnt it better to show ideas more like I did, I keep that chart in basic formation , but actually I am using a different chart

No. It`s not perspective. It`s a matter of rules posted by the OP. In every other thread Emm would have been kicked. This is what happens when one egoistic person shit on the rules and nobody come to judge him. It`s not like hes a nice guy, he shoots against every better trader who critises him. He`s like a parasite. When he`s afraid of opening a own thread he souldnt make promises about. There he could share his treasures. Every normal person would have opened it`s own thread after been asked nicely too in this special case. So this guy gets what he deserves.


Stay tuned.