{quote} привет @shumThank you for your interesting comments in the last week. Is the question here answered now? please refer #558
MT4 Trading without GAP and without Excel
- #602
- Edited 12:04pm May 6, 2017 11:09am | Edited 12:04pm
- Joined Jan 2012 | Status: Trader | 1,862 Posts
{quote} KIM still loves you !! keep posting !!
From time to time I've been looking for you, if you have the right toy. 
You can quickly confuse something in NK.In the next week I will try the following:
SmHullMavg and DB. tf 1' and 5'
The settings are slightly different from the recommendations of @SwingMan # 552, but what does it - as long as the cat is not in the house, the mice dance on the table.
Chart SmHullMavg Min5
looks like this (darkgreen+red Lines; not pink)
Any recommendations in advance concerning settings before trading?
Its your turn then to make the Excel-conclusions.
Thx
@dreambig and @Rce
- #603
- May 6, 2017 11:18am May 6, 2017 11:18am
[quote=JamesCaror;9836886]{quote} So what is your target manuually? Why we cant use atr based tp sl built in ea itself? James[/quote
If i were to exit manually trades entered with these particular settings they would be at the opposite cross of the Hull on M1 chart with settings I've posted earlier in this thread. However the settings I posted yesterday for the DB were really so I would get faster entries at the end of the trade week to test the Hull close. You can use whatever settings you chose. There have been many combinations tested and posted in this thread. Each person has to find what works best for them in trading.
Usually the reason most EAs are built with multiple indicators, parameters, etc. is so the user can adapt the EA to their own style and methods of trading. When you have several people running different settings and relaying this information to others, then a person can learn much faster the results of various combinations of settings than having to run these tests themselves. Plus if you are a part of a thread to contribute in a positive way instead of a negative way then this interaction with others can be a fun experience. Too often what can be an enjoyable experience is tainted by individuals with nothing positive to contribute.
db
If i were to exit manually trades entered with these particular settings they would be at the opposite cross of the Hull on M1 chart with settings I've posted earlier in this thread. However the settings I posted yesterday for the DB were really so I would get faster entries at the end of the trade week to test the Hull close. You can use whatever settings you chose. There have been many combinations tested and posted in this thread. Each person has to find what works best for them in trading.
Usually the reason most EAs are built with multiple indicators, parameters, etc. is so the user can adapt the EA to their own style and methods of trading. When you have several people running different settings and relaying this information to others, then a person can learn much faster the results of various combinations of settings than having to run these tests themselves. Plus if you are a part of a thread to contribute in a positive way instead of a negative way then this interaction with others can be a fun experience. Too often what can be an enjoyable experience is tainted by individuals with nothing positive to contribute.
db
- #604
- May 6, 2017 11:20am May 6, 2017 11:20am
{quote} Right, Kim, make love not war.
Wie ich bemerkt habe,die ältere version läuft besser
- #606
- May 6, 2017 3:13pm May 6, 2017 3:13pm
- Joined Jan 2012 | Status: Trader | 1,862 Posts
{quote} Wie ich bemerkt habe,die ltere version luft besser
To what extent is this version better?
Hey fellows,
Too bad the acitivity started fading so fast in this thread since it is a briliantly coded EA both technically and the logic behind it, many thanks to Swingman
Anyway I have never been a fan of trading with negative RR and I also noticed a tendency for the signals to often come after the most recent run only to retrace shortly after entry. However then plenty of the signals would keep on going racking up a big bunch of pips so I tried another approach.
I set the EA to swing 45 with manual trading, changed ATR to H1 and ATR multiplier to 10, this might be slightly high though. I started this yesterday and even with volatility being low I got a decent amount of signals which I screened manually and declined some for those which seemed to approach strong S/R but I took at least two thirds of the trades and in barely two trading days I racked up over 350 pips
Two days of testing doesn't really say anything about an EA but its parameters for a trade is solid and is likely to give signals for high probabilty set ups. In additiona it's very user friendly in manual mode asking for confirmation with SL and TP ready it makes decision making quick and easy.
I hope my result and set file will encourage fellow traders to keep testing this EA and focus on the swing settings.
Swingman, a humble request, will you please consider to implement a breakeven or lock profit function based on ATR multiplier?
Too bad the acitivity started fading so fast in this thread since it is a briliantly coded EA both technically and the logic behind it, many thanks to Swingman
Anyway I have never been a fan of trading with negative RR and I also noticed a tendency for the signals to often come after the most recent run only to retrace shortly after entry. However then plenty of the signals would keep on going racking up a big bunch of pips so I tried another approach.
I set the EA to swing 45 with manual trading, changed ATR to H1 and ATR multiplier to 10, this might be slightly high though. I started this yesterday and even with volatility being low I got a decent amount of signals which I screened manually and declined some for those which seemed to approach strong S/R but I took at least two thirds of the trades and in barely two trading days I racked up over 350 pips
Two days of testing doesn't really say anything about an EA but its parameters for a trade is solid and is likely to give signals for high probabilty set ups. In additiona it's very user friendly in manual mode asking for confirmation with SL and TP ready it makes decision making quick and easy.
I hope my result and set file will encourage fellow traders to keep testing this EA and focus on the swing settings.
Swingman, a humble request, will you please consider to implement a breakeven or lock profit function based on ATR multiplier?
Hi, SwingMan and everyone in this thread!
Last weeks I made a lot of experiments with the settings.
Here are my conclusions:
Manual trading, the last 3 days (it is not enough, but the ratio of RR makes me happy) - Report and settings are in the screenshots.
The main thing here is trading time: breaks in Lo and NY sessions.
- We trade only the coincidence of the first three TFs.
- Avoid trades in the first and last 5 minutes of every hour.
- Avoid trades before the news.
Well and... we trade in the opposite side of signals!!!
SwingMan , thank you again for this development. To facilitate the trading process and for transition the system to automatic mode the next improvements would be very useful:
- to introduce the concept of "REVERSE": for AUTO - to see this setting on the DB, for MANUAL mode maybe, change the signals to the opposite ones in this mode?
- to introduce the option "do not show signals in the first and last X minutes of every hour" (in the screenshot);
- to introduce the option "do not show signals during X minutes before and after the news - select the importance of the news (1,2,3)";
- to introduce the option which could show on the ADR panel how many pips stay up to ADR to avoid trading and, accordingly, the signals are not shown from the X points to ADR (the custom option). The ADR option is true / false.
- it would be nice to add the ability to edit symbols list (not critical)
Fix:
- I noticed in 5.0 version that the sound of the BUY / SELL signal does not match to the preset one in the settings (the default terminal sound is used), but the opening of the order gives the correct sound - Mysound.wav
- to remove the sound signals and trade signals during the time of preset non-trade sessions.
Last weeks I made a lot of experiments with the settings.
Here are my conclusions:
Manual trading, the last 3 days (it is not enough, but the ratio of RR makes me happy) - Report and settings are in the screenshots.
The main thing here is trading time: breaks in Lo and NY sessions.
- We trade only the coincidence of the first three TFs.
- Avoid trades in the first and last 5 minutes of every hour.
- Avoid trades before the news.
Well and... we trade in the opposite side of signals!!!
SwingMan , thank you again for this development. To facilitate the trading process and for transition the system to automatic mode the next improvements would be very useful:
- to introduce the concept of "REVERSE": for AUTO - to see this setting on the DB, for MANUAL mode maybe, change the signals to the opposite ones in this mode?
- to introduce the option "do not show signals in the first and last X minutes of every hour" (in the screenshot);
- to introduce the option "do not show signals during X minutes before and after the news - select the importance of the news (1,2,3)";
- to introduce the option which could show on the ADR panel how many pips stay up to ADR to avoid trading and, accordingly, the signals are not shown from the X points to ADR (the custom option). The ADR option is true / false.
- it would be nice to add the ability to edit symbols list (not critical)
Fix:
- I noticed in 5.0 version that the sound of the BUY / SELL signal does not match to the preset one in the settings (the default terminal sound is used), but the opening of the order gives the correct sound - Mysound.wav
- to remove the sound signals and trade signals during the time of preset non-trade sessions.
- #611
- Edited 5:40pm May 14, 2017 3:20pm | Edited 5:40pm
[Well and... we trade in the opposite side of signals!!! ]
Hi vinvlad.....good results.....do you mean that you trade the opposite direction of the given signal, treating that signal direction as a pullback of a higher TF trend?
db
]Hi vinvlad.....good results.....do you mean that you trade the opposite direction of the given signal, treating that signal direction as a pullback of a higher TF trend?
db
- #612
- May 14, 2017 8:05pm May 14, 2017 8:05pm
- Joined Mar 2010 | Status: Trader | 2,261 Posts
cfta thanks for the settings share. do you think this can be traded automatically?
blam
blam
Hey fellows, Too bad the acitivity started fading so fast in this thread since it is a briliantly coded EA both technically and the logic behind it, many thanks to Swingman
- #618
- May 15, 2017 7:01am May 15, 2017 7:01am
- Joined Aug 2007 | Status: Trader | 2,725 Posts
Your work in this example of settings, just confirms the impulse is exsosted before pullback.
If you need this, I complete the functionality of the "R" button.
