Astro based Turning Points known in Advance

One aspect to consider from Gann's Tunnel Thru the Air, page 76 and 77 concerning Time and the Law of Vibration...

Yes I agree with Gann, but this astro events indicator, doesnt work properly.. Sometimes its changing direction of price, sometimes it doesnt and continue.. sometimes before astro event, sometimes after... randomly

When i trade not using that ---> sometimes price changes direction, sometimes it doesnt, sometimes continue, sometimes ranging markets, randomly..

any differences?

Abhay has referred to the turning points lines as being energetic points.. not a prediction of which direction the market will go. Oftentimes it is a reversal, but not always. How many ways can a trend change direction?

Let's see...

up >down
down >up
sideways > up
sideways > down
down > sideways
up > sideways

Now, depending on what the market hours are, news events, etc., price action can be slow or fast. His advice to be patient and wait for price action to reveal itself by crossing a trendline is the best, and probably only way to trade with these turning points.

W.D. Gann is quoted in an interview with The New York Herald Magazine, Jan 5, 1919, p 15

'An astronomer can predict to the minute when a eclipse is going
to occur,' he said, but you would not consider him a prophet, would
you? Of course not. He simply makes use of mathematics based on
known laws of the movements of the planets in their orbits. I have found
in my researches that the Chinese understood all those laws and
computed the coming of eclipses thousands of years before the
Egyptians and Chaldeans. It is marvelous the knowledge that these
ancients had. In making my predictions I used geometry and
mathematics just as an astronomer does, based on immutable laws
which I have discovered. There is nothing supernatural or weird about
it. Some weeks ago I read an interesting article on the failure of
astrologers in their predictions regarding the war.
'Now there is a great deal in the vibrations of the planets, but to
make accurate predictions the great law behind it all, which the
ancients understood, but which they purposely refrained from putting in
their books, as they wanted to keep the secret for themselves, must
enter into the calculation. That is why astrology fails for nothing can be
accurate that is not based on mathematics and so few astrologers are
mathematicians.
Gann told this interviewer that he had discovered the Law of
Vibration through the way in which numbers and letters were written,
not through astrology or the planets. Furthermore, Gann says here
plainly that planetary calculations are not sufficient to predict the
future; the great law behind it all the Law of Vibration must also
enter into the calculation. In other words, something must be used in
addition to astrology that is not astrology and that something is the Law
of Vibration! Gann then adds that astrology fails, and why? Because

nothing can be accurate that is not based on mathematics. Thus,
Gann implies, the Law of Vibration the law that rules all things is a
mathematical law. Here we have only to determine what mathematics
are involved what Gann means by the term mathematics and we will
be in a position to attempt to look at the markets as Gann himself
looked at them.

We will have begun to understand the Law of Vibration.

Romeman has written a well researched and thoughtful look at Gann's Law of Vibration and is freely available as a pdf download here: THE LAW OF VIBRATION - Forex Factory

Why would sideways be a direction?

Could be a quiet time in the market, could be a consolidation period... in any event, it is a change of trend.

Direction also involves time...Time continues to move forward but price is stalled... that is a direction.

I see.I got that wrong with trend changing "direction"

Hello jnevins:

Thank you very much for the Gann pdf file. I enjoy reading every thing on Gann. A famous controversial trader even today.

The ff link does not work though.
http://www.forexfactory.com/attachment.php?...1291703

Have you been able to apply the law of vibration successfully to your trading ?

Borg

Thanks for the heads up regarding the link... apparently the top half "The Law of Vibraton" worked and not the bottom half... so I edited that out... try it now.

I am a student of Gann and there are many more knowledgeable practitioners than myself.... such as Abhay. I am here to learn from him. I have been actively posting in another Forex Factory Forum, Planetary Cycles and use both Timing Solution Software and Astrolog 5.4 to find Moon - planetary aspects that might be trigger points for price change. It is an ongoing "open source" experiment... http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...08#post8654308 These points are not the same as Abhay's.

I find Abhay's approach to be the most valuable and practical I have ever seen in various forums, including Forex Factory.

EURO near turning point, due for reversal trade. Watching momentum to fade or cross the trendline to downside..

Very interesting indeed. Thank you so much. Am I correct that the time frames is always H1?

Yes, as my analysis is on 1HR timeframe, because anything above will be too wide and trades duration will have to be longer with wider stops..

Euro is turning south----simply amazing.

It turned there because of ressistance..

looks like momentum is stalling here and if it does not break 1.0960 then this turnis going to hold, even though movement is slow so it mmay not be very deep turn yet.

Abhay,

Is the trendline tool available anywhere or is it part of your programming work? It is brilliant the way it draws a short trendline out ahead of the price and provides a future target for price to breakthrough or reject.

That is my programming. I am making a change in new version, where you will see progression of trendlines at different hour if you want, rather than moving of that line if trend is changing..

Why price didn't turn around the points?

When lines are close, this is how the movement usually occurs if it the market is not in the very slow time of the day...

really it is good system sir but my mt4 is crashing many times.. so i am not using nowdays

If it good system whats your money management? How many pips tp and sl ?