DislikedYou were correct that was a no supply bar.
I only glanced at the chart for the second, but I'd believe you marked a valid NS bar as it was a down bar with low volume that followed climactic volume.
Per Clif's methodology this would be considered an aggressive entry.
In my mind a NS bar doesn't necessarily have to be a down bar, it can be down for most of the bar's formation and then close slightly up, and as long as it broke the prior two bars' lows it means the same thing; lack of selling interest.
Don't beat yourself up about not...Ignored
Hi Clifton, I hope you're still around and kicking
I pretty much gave up on looking at volume, there were just too many terms to learn VSA
Then one day I go to your thread straight from the horse's mouth ....
"Stopping volume, no demand/supply volume into SD, opposite bar entry"
HOW EASY WAS THAT!
Honestly, you deserve a medal of honor for this thread
Just very logical
Keep up the good work
I pretty much gave up on looking at volume, there were just too many terms to learn VSA
Then one day I go to your thread straight from the horse's mouth ....
"Stopping volume, no demand/supply volume into SD, opposite bar entry"
HOW EASY WAS THAT!
Honestly, you deserve a medal of honor for this thread
Just very logical
Keep up the good work
- #391
- Edited 3:34am Aug 15, 2012 3:13am | Edited 3:34am
- | Joined Feb 2011 | Status: Trader | 86 Posts
eurusd something boiling.
this setup also appearing on audusd too.
the strongest has been gbpusd(i think i attached the wrong picture! so embarassing! and i admit that i didn't know the UK data was coming out)
this setup also appearing on audusd too.
the strongest has been gbpusd(i think i attached the wrong picture! so embarassing! and i admit that i didn't know the UK data was coming out)
so i learn something new as i work through with this in the thick of things. on review i realised i should have looked whether 1H was really forming. it didn.t in fact real demand for 1H was down at 1.2254 area. (counting volume sticks and comparing). yes 5m had nice SV but in the bigger timeframe it was flat.
1H showed that the US session lead the way with a big SV.
it hurt but its good - Clifton and Frankkn has made the particles of the market understandable that even when i analyse wronlgy - using the same parameters i can see where i was wrong. (something The Disciplined Trader teaches you to forget and accept it as a coin toss)
as a soccer and athletics person. when you collide into an opponent it is not a coin toss, it is footwork/positioning/tactics/rate of change of positions etc.
Thanks to Clifton and Frankkn's explanations and leading, I see the market in the particles it is meant to be discerned in.(there's alot of smokescreen out there...including Tradeguider,XLT,etc)
Meanwhile any tough love is welcome. I am a hasty and aggressive person. Because in my mistakes I know where I went wrong. And when I'm wrong I learn what can be done better.
That's how you improve as an athlete and in any endeavor.
1H showed that the US session lead the way with a big SV.
it hurt but its good - Clifton and Frankkn has made the particles of the market understandable that even when i analyse wronlgy - using the same parameters i can see where i was wrong. (something The Disciplined Trader teaches you to forget and accept it as a coin toss)
as a soccer and athletics person. when you collide into an opponent it is not a coin toss, it is footwork/positioning/tactics/rate of change of positions etc.
Thanks to Clifton and Frankkn's explanations and leading, I see the market in the particles it is meant to be discerned in.(there's alot of smokescreen out there...including Tradeguider,XLT,etc)
Meanwhile any tough love is welcome. I am a hasty and aggressive person. Because in my mistakes I know where I went wrong. And when I'm wrong I learn what can be done better.
That's how you improve as an athlete and in any endeavor.
