Hi Dan. I’m with you on this one. I also don’t post much either but have read all of bobokus and skunny thread from beginning. I believe you have asked some great questions and I see nothing wrong with any of them. Where is the evidence that skunny students can now trade with profit I ask? From the 100 members he had in his trade group I see here many that say his teaching was either not very good or they come here asking questions still seeking more knowledge. Pipskateer is one example. He was a big part of the skunny group and is now following James 16 thread adding that he should of gone there a long time ago. Sounds like tradefibs did not work for him. The only evidence I see where joining may help traders are the posts and trade calls performed by brunite and gridtrader. Going back there are 2 posts in this thread showing some evidence of sucessful trading, one by piprpro and another one by gridtrader called candle whisper, but do we even know if these graphs are real or came from result of skunny's teaching? Of entire 100 why only these 2 or 3 traders?
Teachers like James 16 have many testimonials on his web page including hudnreds more right here on forexfactory. Perhaps skunny could share some testimonies of success with us by his group of students? I have not seen any to date other than those mentioned already. I believe asking for testimonials is a simple request and others if they are smart should be asking for the same. Brunite and gridtrader are the only traders of the entire group of 100 and to me that is not a very good percentage rate of success. People want proof and there is little of it here. Earlier in this thread sizzler seemed to suggest that one of the cycle guys was skunny. In the same reply sizzler also said skunny posted a failed trade call. Dan you said earlier cycle maniac posted a bad trade call too! I understand that trading without fail is impossible. I also think that out of 100 members there should be many more here to give skunny a good testimony. The small few by brunite and gridtrader are the only good I can see in this thread to give skunny merit. Skunny himself never posted a trade call here since this thread began and it has now been several years. So I ask an easy question once more for testimonials. Please, can you provide those for us?
Teachers like James 16 have many testimonials on his web page including hudnreds more right here on forexfactory. Perhaps skunny could share some testimonies of success with us by his group of students? I have not seen any to date other than those mentioned already. I believe asking for testimonials is a simple request and others if they are smart should be asking for the same. Brunite and gridtrader are the only traders of the entire group of 100 and to me that is not a very good percentage rate of success. People want proof and there is little of it here. Earlier in this thread sizzler seemed to suggest that one of the cycle guys was skunny. In the same reply sizzler also said skunny posted a failed trade call. Dan you said earlier cycle maniac posted a bad trade call too! I understand that trading without fail is impossible. I also think that out of 100 members there should be many more here to give skunny a good testimony. The small few by brunite and gridtrader are the only good I can see in this thread to give skunny merit. Skunny himself never posted a trade call here since this thread began and it has now been several years. So I ask an easy question once more for testimonials. Please, can you provide those for us?