James16 is not credible | Page 56 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

Credible brokers? 31 replies

What makes a track record credible for Trading Firms? 0 replies

any credible broker with credit/card deposit in euro? 4 replies

Attachments: James16 is not credible
Exit Attachments

James16 is not credible

  • #1,101
  • Jan 27, 2012 3:58am Jan 27, 2012 3:58am
Hi OD,

Did you pick the initials for your username on purpose or is it just a coincidence?

If you are trolling, then you have done pretty well. Up to 70 odd pages!

However, if you are a legitimate trader, perhaps you could enlighten us with your expertise and post a live trade of your own.
  • #1,102
  • Jan 28, 2012 3:42pm Jan 28, 2012 3:42pm
Quoting diallist


Hahahaha! Thanks dragon! That's the best laugh I've had in a very long time! Why? Because I've sat with James16 in his trading room and watched him trade live, and was blown away by the intricate depth of knowledge he has about trading. What he teaches in his forum is only a fraction of what he knows, but at the same time, what he teaches is MORE than enough for anyone willing to put in the necessary time to study Jim's information to make as much money as they want trading.

It was Jim & Merlin who put me on the right track. Jim...
I just read this..and it really is the best advice one could give..very true..read that thread and it will change everything..u only have to read!
  • #1,103
  • Jan 28, 2012 9:34pm Jan 28, 2012 9:34pm
How about this idea dragon... now this is just a thought:

Step 1: If you want to prove your accusations of James16 being a scammer, stop your ignorant rants and go over to the FREE that's right FREE J16 chart thread and read through the important posts that have been graciously organized in that thread. We both know you know where this thread is so go find it. Read it. Study it.

Step 2: Open a demo account and try out his methods. If you know anything about the learning process of trading you should know how to do this. Test this method out for a couple of months. This thread has been going for 1.5 years and that would have been plenty of time to try and prove your point. But instead you're still around ranting about someone you know NOTHING about and methods you obviously haven't put into practice.

Step 3: Open up a myfxbook log through the link you graciously provided in this thread so we can track your progress.

I remember in gradeschool math when my teachers told me in order for my answer to be counted I needed to show my work. In order for your accusations to be actually taken with any weight, SHOW SOME PROOF. All I see is you going on about how he charges for the private room and doesn't post statements and doesn't do live calls blah blah blah.


If you haven't tried to implement his methods on a demo account and test out his strategies, your argument has no merit. So if you're going to keep on ranting about that thread and his methods, just leave and take your ignorance somewhere else. You don't have to pay to come to this thread and you chose to come here to speak garbage. So if you're going to keep this immature rant up, please find the "X" on the upper right of your screen and never come back.
You should thank me, I take the other side of your winning trades.
  • #1,104
  • Jan 29, 2012 6:57am Jan 29, 2012 6:57am
James vs Jacko there are many same things between them

Both have +30 years trading experience

Their threads are free

No bank's statement, no evidence..nothing but words

They opened subscribe service cuz they are genuine , they are good men , they do it not for money but for their hobby ...their main income is from trading (as they claimed)

Both has many workshippers who have favor with them or simple who are brainwashed do everything to protect them and ignore the fact james16 is no difference than jacko ( i mean 99% the same)

For everyone still believe in James16, read this thread , when someone stand up and say the truth about jacko , look how his fans react , it is the same as james16's workshippers saying.

Like the post number 3 from the guy teddybear in that thread : I am a member of jackos group and I can see EVERY one of his trades since he started the group in Oct 2007.I can vouch that he is definitely extremely profitable.

look it up , there are tons of beautiful words for jacko

http://www.forexfactory.com/showthread.php?t=172030
  • #1,105
  • Jan 31, 2012 1:24am Jan 31, 2012 1:24am
Quoting onlydragon
[b]James vs Jacko there are many same things between them

Both have +30 years trading experience

Their threads are free

No bank's statement, no evidence..nothing but words

They opened subscribe service cuz they are genuine , they are good men , they do it not for money but for their hobby ...their main income is from trading (as they claimed)

Both has many workshippers who have favor with them or simple who are brainwashed do everything to protect them and ignore the fact james16 is no difference than jacko ( i mean 99% the same)

For...
That's funny you say "no evidence" because you have none either. Have you ever considered that these "worshippers" as you called them are actually people who have made profits from the methods he has shown? That would give them a reason to be on his side.

And I will tell you right now I'm not a J16 "worshipper" I have looked through his thread and found information I found very helpful, but have a different system I use. I find your accusations very ignorant and that is the sole reason why I am even writing on this thread. Because you bash people who try to help others learn how to trade making accusations that you can't backup. Look at the amount of views and replies to his thread and how long it has been around and TELL me how you think he isn't credible. The thread has been around for seven years and you don't think the someone else would have proven he wasn't credible by now? C'mon man think for a minute. Just stop this useless rant, and go on with your life somewhere else.
You should thank me, I take the other side of your winning trades.
  • #1,106
  • Feb 10, 2012 10:06am Feb 10, 2012 10:06am
Quoting onlydragon
[b]James vs Jacko there are many same things between them

Both have +30 years trading experience

Their threads are free

No bank's statement, no evidence..nothing but words

They opened subscribe service cuz they are genuine , they are good men , they do it not for money but for their hobby ...their main income is from trading (as they claimed)

Both has many workshippers who have favor with them or simple who are brainwashed do everything to protect them and ignore the fact james16 is no difference than jacko ( i mean 99% the same)

For everyone...

I just have one question for you.

Did you ever try james16 method for at least 1-2 months?

Also , please provide me the proof of how james is a scammer?

i do not see you posting any evidence of it.
  • #1,107
  • Feb 27, 2012 10:16am Feb 27, 2012 10:16am
Quoting onlydragon
[b]James vs Jacko there are many same things between them

Both have +30 years trading experience

Their threads are free

No bank's statement, no evidence..nothing but words

They opened subscribe service cuz they are genuine , they are good men , they do it not for money but for their hobby ...their main income is from trading (as they claimed)

Both has many workshippers who have favor with them or simple who are brainwashed do everything to protect them and ignore the fact james16 is no difference than jacko ( i mean 99% the same)

For everyone...
How old are you? 15? I read some of your posts and it looks like posts of a histeric child: "The next door kid has more friends then I have".

Why do you still babble about bank statements, live call etc.? Are people here obliged to make live calls to show their skills? Only indiot will post his account statement on an anonymous public forum, only even bigger idiot ask for it.

I really think you should go to see a doctor. This is an anonymous internet forum. If it makes you crazy (your posts look like) how do you solve real problems in real world? By the same way?

And, you should stop posting. It's not healthy for you evidently. Just switch the comp. off, go out and watch the trees, people, river, ducks...and you will realized that there is no james16 demon hidden behind, waiting for the right moment to skin you.

Anyway, I doubt anyone takes your posts seriously.
Follow my trading on Twitter and FB: @pumlitch
  • #1,108
  • Feb 27, 2012 10:49am Feb 27, 2012 10:49am
Quoting onlydragon
[b]James vs Jacko there are many same things between them

Both have +30 years trading experience

Their threads are free

No bank's statement, no evidence..nothing but words

They opened subscribe service cuz they are genuine , they are good men , they do it not for money but for their hobby ...their main income is from trading (as they claimed)

Both has many workshippers who have favor with them or simple who are brainwashed do everything to protect them and ignore the fact james16 is no difference than jacko ( i mean 99% the same)

For everyone...
i will admit these days its hard to trust any1..however i joined the grp 3 years ago i think..i learned so much..and now i have free membership for life..joining the site was a fantastic decision..one of the best i have made in my life time..i have limited succes so far (if u can call it that) and i use 80% of the teaching derived from the free thread..i think this the difference..support is there for free

people join because they support him and his team and get more education, one way or the other u need to pay for education, either it goes to a teacher or the friggin market..nobody is putting a gun to any1s head here

dont throw out $%%# unless u can back it up
  • #1,109
  • Feb 27, 2012 11:24pm Feb 27, 2012 11:24pm
Don't feed the trolls....
  • #1,110
  • Feb 28, 2012 3:04am Feb 28, 2012 3:04am
Quoting onlydragon
[b]James vs Jacko there are many same things between them

Both have +30 years trading experience

Their threads are free

No bank's statement, no evidence..nothing but words

They opened subscribe service cuz they are genuine , they are good men , they do it not for money but for their hobby ...their main income is from trading (as they claimed)

Both has many workshippers who have favor with them or simple who are brainwashed do everything to protect them and ignore the fact james16 is no difference than jacko ( i mean 99% the same)

For everyone...

Lolz...you are obviously not a trader and don't plan on ever being one.

What will a bank statement do for you? Will it tell you where the market is going? I bet PA will.

Do you have a problem with 30years of experience? So many dedicated newbies become successful after a couple of years of hard work and dedication.

If you encourage newbies to spend half the time you're spending here castigating Jim on mastering Price Action on his free thread here in FF, you'll be doing more good for the newbies than most ppl.

Whether you LIKE it or not, what Jim teaches is real and pure and nobody needs a bank statement to be convinced about that...oops probably except you.

I also know James to be a very honest person. We I first paid for membership of his group, my subscription got delayed for 4days, he rectified it, back dated it and kept on apologizing about it. He was so troubled by the delay I experienced that he gave me another month of access free of charge.

Needless to say, the wealth of knowledge in there is staggering.

So quit the attack....what James teaches is real and works and THAT'S ALL THAT MATTERS.
SNR with Price Action...
BitCrossNG Return Today: na
  • #1,111
  • Feb 28, 2012 3:07am Feb 28, 2012 3:07am
Quoting diallist


Hahahaha! Thanks dragon! That's the best laugh I've had in a very long time! Why? Because I've sat with James16 in his trading room and watched him trade live, and was blown away by the intricate depth of knowledge he has about trading. What he teaches in his forum is only a fraction of what he knows, but at the same time, what he teaches is MORE than enough for anyone willing to put in the necessary time to study Jim's information to make as much money as they want trading.

It was Jim & Merlin who put me on the right track. Jim...

Sir,
What you said is pure. I remember you in the PF. Thanks for everything.
SNR with Price Action...
BitCrossNG Return Today: na
  • #1,112
  • Feb 28, 2012 3:25am Feb 28, 2012 3:25am
Request to all,

Let us make this is a 'James is credible' thread...
  • #1,113
  • Feb 28, 2012 3:34am Feb 28, 2012 3:34am
Six reason why onlydragon is not credible

1. OnlyDragon has never attempted to learn James16 material.

2. If he has attempted , he has failed in the attempt.

3. Is Jealous of James

4. Has nothing better to do on forum like may be learning ,instead chooses to spew hatred.

5. Does not back up his statements with any proof.

6. lost a lot of money in trading and is looking to blame someone.
  • #1,114
  • Mar 1, 2012 12:14pm Mar 1, 2012 12:14pm
Quoting wooli
Hi OD,
Did you pick the initials for your username on purpose or is it just a coincidence?
.
OD = Obsessive Disorder?

Quoting Pumlitch
..go out and watch the trees, people, river, ducks......



Quoting zamfir
Don't feed the trolls....
sometimes we need to feed them, so they can have the opportunity to become enlightened

Quoting onlydragon
1,5 years pass since i start this thread, and it is like 7 years since James in this website ...
Still no "live call"....
1.5years have passed & u are STILL WHINING? lol
u could've done a lot of constructive things in such a long time.

until u change your attitude, nothing good will ever happen to your life.


btw, i posted here mainly to say hi to Sir Diallist/Charles. i cant believe it, donald duck is still here with us. looking forward to meeting u in the future..
  • #1,115
  • May 22, 2012 2:57am May 22, 2012 2:57am
Quoting Pumlitch
How old are you? 15? I read some of your posts and it looks like posts of a histeric child: "The next door kid has more friends then I have".

Why do you still babble about bank statements, live call etc.? Are people here obliged to make live calls to show their skills? Only indiot will post his account statement on an anonymous public forum, only even bigger idiot ask for it.

I really think you should go to see a doctor. This is an anonymous internet forum. If it makes you crazy (your posts look like) how do you solve real problems in real...
Why do everyone try to close this thread? Dragon's opinion have right to live. In opposite, James16 must put the link to this thread in his first post to give people a choice (to trust him or not) before spending a money. I think, people must know that there is another opinion to James16 thread.
Why do everyone (and James16 too) want to teach more and more people James16 system? Because, if many traders will know about system, then market efficiency will not allow to earn money. That's why Classical TA, Rashke's models, and other well known systems give 50/50 winning/losing ratio today and work with noise.
  • #1,116
  • Jun 2, 2012 3:56am Jun 2, 2012 3:56am
dragon thinks that james is scamer and calls for fbi, cia and probably sis as well (sis = slovakian inteligence service) loooool...
the point is:
if I am a member of any group for any amount of money per mont and I see that this group, or service paid per mont is totally bullshit, I have options:
1. stop paying and go off and complain at the internet
2. ask an owner of "learner"site to stop bullshitting and start talk seriously
3. call everybody who even think about a sign up to stop and hit their head towards the wall before they pay MONEY.
cos hit the head towards the wall AFTER pay is too late...

so... everyone who wants, can see a free thread of James16 and take a consideration about go in or stay out...
so, dragon, just stop bullshitting and some serious job to improve your trading.... or sign up for james to figure out how its going...
  • #1,117
  • Jul 27, 2012 5:40am Jul 27, 2012 5:40am
To Dragon and anyone else that has a problem with someone like James16,
First off, let me say that I 'just joined' FF so that I could post this! Second, I do not know James or any of the people talked about on this thread. I have been trading (learning) for about 4 years which has had me sitting, reading, charting, and both losing and making money. And yes, I have been a visitor to this fine site on many occasions. I am also over 50 but still love to play some AC/DC on my guitar!!

I have just started my own blog (don't worry FF, I won't be mentioning it here) but it has to do with the golden rule and how society seems to be slipping away. I started this blog because of people like Dragon. It seems to me that human beings and their ability to 'think' is going down the tubes. I just realized that I'm already going off on a, well, you know. So back to the point.
Dragon, I too cannot afford to join James16's member area. However; I CANNOT EVEN BEGIN TO FIGURE OUT HOW I WOULD BLAME HIM FOR THAT!!!! From what I can tell, and have seen, heard, and so on from reading the threads on this site, this man has given more of himself FOR FREE than I can even believe. And next is the kicker!
I just went to his site for the very first time last night. Now before my next comment, let me remind you that I have been trading for 4 years, 2 live accounts! I looked around the site, looked at how much the member area costs, and watched a couple of video's. In one particular video, I was amazed that I was being shown something that I just never really 'saw' before. It blew me away! I am now trying to figure out a way to come up with the money to join.

Now I mentioned that I have started a blog about people for a reason; I study people, what they do, what they say, and how they do and say it. Unless James16 is the best actor to ever live, and unless he has spent the last 10 years planning how he comes across to people in order to get them to become a member of his site, this man is the real deal! Just from hearing him speak, what I've heard of him, so on, I can say that to be around this guy would be an absolute pleasure and if more people were like him, this world would be a better place!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Unfortunately; some people just 'can't think'. I have been seeing it in all of the forex websites. There are some that just can't comprehend why others won't give them MORE! You see it everywhere, "why don't you just show us how to do it", "why won't you just give us your indicators", "I don't understand why you won't just show us exactly how you enter the trades", Gime, gime, gime! "They" actually have an advertisement going in the US right now for the benefits of Food Stamps. Tell me there's not a problem with that thinking!
Bottom line; no one owes us anything yet James has been giving for years as far as I can tell, and still is. I spend money I don't have every year to make sure that some kids have school supplies, some have Christmas presents, to help cancer study, and yet, there are people still try and make me feel bad when they call and ask for money for 'their' cause. I guess that's a little different and I can't blame them.
Anyways Dragon, it's unfortunate that there is little we can do to help people like you and your way of thinking but anyone with the same issue just needs to answer this question: WHY? That's it, just why. If you are not getting something you want, just ask why. I can teach a pretty good golf swing, and have to some for free but if I have a worth while, wanted product, and 100's or 1000's want it, 'WHY' would I be wrong in asking a little something for my time? I can't imagine someone coming to me an demanding that I teach them how to swing a club like a pro and if I don't they're going to tell everyone that I'm a crook!
That's all.
Oh PS, James, please don't stop your site anytime soon, I just found it!
  • #1,118
  • Sep 16, 2012 4:48am Sep 16, 2012 4:48am
Quoting mportt11
That's funny you say "no evidence" because you have none either. Have you ever considered that these "worshippers" as you called them are actually people who have made profits from the methods he has shown? That would give them a reason to be on his side.

And I will tell you right now I'm not a J16 "worshipper" I have looked through his thread and found information I found very helpful, but have a different system I use. I find your accusations very ignorant and that is the sole reason why I am even writing on this thread. Because you...
Guys,
Dont lie each other.
You all speak about how he educated you and you learned a lot from him,you maybe learned but 99 % guys are still unsuccesufull so point is if is material he teach you good and right?
And dont make something big he teach you simple BUB,BEB and BOUB,BEOB.
They are simple builish bars , bearish and outside bulish bearish.
My best opinion is everyone need to create system for himself and than try to get concistently results.Point on Forex is to earning consistently (years).
I wrote on my Journal we got negative one year intraday trading and 2 positive years but that is true and that is Forex,guys on this Forum write like all is positive and all earn everyday milions,just write realistic and this place will be better.
In that sense i like threads like this casoue threads like this shows that isnt everything suny.

Seya
Petar
"Buy on fear, sell on greed !!!
  • #1,119
  • Mar 22, 2013 12:48pm Mar 22, 2013 12:48pm
I keep it short but big so everyone can see
I'm neutral
But in my country have a sentense:"100 listen not worth for 1 see"
So when i saw someone profitable, i will study him
End of story
  • #1,120
  • Mar 22, 2013 3:14pm Mar 22, 2013 3:14pm
Is this trader enough profitable for you ?
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: rt.png Size: 202 KB
1 trader viewing now