Firehorse's trading spreadsheet 45 replies
Broker Chart Comparison 6 replies
Real Time Broker Comparison site 4 replies
DislikedAgain thanks for the spreadsheet nice work. Just want to ask since it seems your a bit biased towards pepperstone, how do you create the analysis for spread on the various pairs and since you only have one for pepperstone and on some occasions only for a marginal period of time one could say its not entirely apparent if they do indeed offer those spreads throughout the day or at all. Could you do that for all the brokers and could you inform us on your experiece with pepperstone. They seem to have the whole package from the looks of what i saw on...Ignored
DislikedI have tried to compare the spread during NFP, but the log does not have the data. On Jan 6, there is no data between server time 14:55 to 20:13.Ignored
This is my personal broker comparison spreadsheet i have compiled over the past few months whilst looking for a new broker. I'm uploading it just to share with others, to start general discussion about broker comparisons, and to hear your feedback/comments/amendments.
It is tailored to my needs so won't suite everyone, for example i've only compared spreads and commissions for EURUSD, and only entered account ccy if GBP is not provided.
DislikedMy personal Broker Comparison SpreadsheetIgnored
DislikedFirstly - AWESOME spreadsheet!
Looking at the total cost, it appears that MBT is the cheapest, having the tightest spreads and no commission etc. I use Refund FX for my rebates who pay a little higher than cash back. Using their rebates on Vantage FX of 0.3 that brings the Vantage FX cost to 1 pip making them and pepperstone (as you get 0.35) in second place. IBFX who are not on your list would be nearish 4th or so, with an avearge spread of 1.9 and a 0.8 pip rebate.
On your slip fields, I have had slippage on my live accounts on pending...Ignored
DislikedOn your slip fields, I have had slippage on my live accounts on pending orders with Axi and Pepper where you have indicated No. I didnt have any slippage for along time, but the last month its seems like I get slipped on every tradeIgnored
DislikedIt is interesting that both of them are doing this.
Are you experiencing this with all your trades irrespective of currency pair?
What times do you trade?Ignored