Fratelli Intraday trading system

can you post ure chart on eu 10 mins like it looks rigt now
thank you

This is my chart by applying the latest template peter posted. Difference are the horizontal lines for PO and the bar colour as I circled it.

do u have any alpari mt4 installed
can u try it there as well
?

It works on my alpari but not on oanda mt4.... No idea why.

have u requested from oanda to allow expert advisors on ure account?

i use oanda, and it seems ok for me

Hi Micky, I'm sorry but didn't was at the screen & saw your PM just now.
I answer here because didn't was able to attach images in PM.

Here are 2 charts just taken (23:55 GT +1) EU 5 min TF

As you can see after changing to 15 TF e back to 5 TF the candle of 23:30 turned from red to green....

Hope it helps to understand what's happening, also if I don't believe it will influence much in our system based on 10 min TF because we need the arrow, the macd, the 89 ema and the breakout of signal candle to enter...

Yeah I've gone to options and ticked the box to allow live trading, where is the allow expert advisors? It's on my work pc so il have to check it tomorrow. But point me in the right direction.

If you allow me to give some asistance... (I know more about repainting then most people because many years ago I deliberalty made a repainting indicator as a joke but it kept people busy for many years who wanted to be fooled... if you want to know more about it google on "solar wind indicator" -- I developped it and someone else wrote it for me because I don't know mql4--some scammers even started to sell my indicator).

So please do the following:
Place your indicator with the setting that so called do not repaint on a 1 min chart (I know that you gonna say that you trade from 10min charts but that does not make any difference--if the indicator is so called correctly programmed then any time frame should work properly or the programming was not good).

After placing it on a 1min chart (1min is because it will trigger a lot more signals to check) ... the moment you get a signal wait 5 more bars or min. Then take a printscreen. After taking the printscreen the change your chart from 1 min to a 5min. chart and then back to a 1min. If you then see that your chart does not match up anymore with the printscreen that you took then you have a problem. Do that for at least 10 signals because 1 non-repainting signals does not proof that the indicator is not repainting.

If you want to do it even in a quicker way then start your backtester and place your default MACD EA on a 1min chart and place the backtest on visual mode(make sure that you do not run the backtest on full speed,30, because the signals will shoot by on your screen).
You start the back test and as soon as the EA starts then push the "pauze" button. Then place on that chart your template. It will place all your indicators on that same chart. Then push on start again and let it run till your template has generated several signals (lets say 10). Then push on pauze again. Then take from each signal a printscreen or quicker place on each signal that you see a vertical line. When still on pauze you change the time frame from 1min to 5 min and back to 1min. Then check your current signals on your chart with the printscrteens or with the vertical lines and make your conclusions.

Friendly regards...iGoR

PS. I do not understand why the printscreens are doubted. They clearly show that the indicator repaints. So improve programming on the repainting problem and problem is fixed.
PS2. I could do that backtest but I am not trading this system at all.

so u only switched tf and than back to 5 minutes yes?

u did nothing else

This is my chart on alpari. Circled the differences i see so far, there might be a lot more...

Nothing more, nothing less......

As you can see, I've in the chart only Fratelli's indicators (Last version with macd line), just to avoid interference with any other indi's

here is mine on oanda john

I have worked with indicators that need manual refreshing. All I did was just apply the template again to the chart and it will update and refresh to be the accurate one. However, it seems like our problem here is due to data feed and possibly the no. of bars set on the history. I see the no. of bars parameters in one of the indicator to be 100000, if we do not have the same no. of bars on the chart or if one of our bar is different due to data feed or broke over the course of 100000 bars, we will have significant diff results. This is the main cause of why people perform better than others while they use the same rules and same template.

i will test the candles and see what happens on 1 minute

My template on Alpari UK and same template on Oanda mt4 are both exactly the same regarding line crosses, candle colour changes and macd etc. So hopefully i am all correct and bug free

You have the same arrows and candle colour as I do. However, Peter have different ones as hes missing the two arrow that I circled in my previous chart post. The MA is different though, significantly...

as just mentioned in my new post, i have compared it to alpari which i WAS running it on, applied all new stuff to my oanda platform and everything is exactly the same

reality is i never tryed it on real charts.... only on the offline ones

so i will not test it on real tf before i make anymore comments about it.(repainting)

I am talking with MickeyMouse on skype now and he is doing the test as I explained and he will see if it repaints... (my ellbow feeling says that is repaints)(I hope not for you guys but...)


FXiGoR