Let's start the fight to brokers!!

Hello,
i trade in forex since 2 years.
in my trading experience i learnt a lot of things.
trading is not for everyone, need nerves! and also... money!

then, after 'billions' of trades, losses, profits, stops @BEp etc i find me very angry and tired by how brokers scam markets, charts, and use our money like it is their money.

i think i will find a lot of traders agree with some rules i would like to see in every broker:

1st: every broker MUST have same candles in every time frame (from m1 to monthly etc..)
2nd: every broker MUST show weekend interbank trading and not hide those moves. they can simply disable trading during it, but this at least would not fake our charts.
3rd: we MUST NOT fund into broker account. money MUST stay in our bank account or where-ever we want to, like it was some year ago.
4th: broker MUST have a fixed spread in whole markets, and same spread for every broker. i think an average 2pips on majors n 4pips in other shall be enough!!!
5th: brokers MUST let traders to install 1 and only 1 platform, which can execute orders in more than 1broker! so we can have 2-3-200 brokers, but only 1 platform running and decide if execute an order in 1 or in 150 brokers. this would be more true until there is different spreads!!!
6th: brokers MUST disable things like what happened to me once : i had a sell stop order with a target and a trailing stop, they opened the trade 5pips near what was the target, then price went against and triggered the stop loss, without triggering the trailing stop causing me an heavy loss! they say it is due because in low liquidity they execute orders as near as they can.... does this make sense??? they MUST give us the possibility to set a max range where open or not open the trade!!!

i think most of you can agree this.
we are broker's customers, and costumer is always right!
in last years they are scamming us. we MUST let them listen our voices!
we need to be a lot of people and we need a good lawyer maybe!

but c'mon: we can stop this shit and trade without the fear to be scammed by our trading broker!!!

every add-on is welcome!

your asking way too much, good luck

You're asking for a fixed exchange, which would be nice. Not exactly sure why fx is OTC, but I'm sure there's a reason.

I'm not sure about "1 platform only." Let's not get communist now

Why don't you just change your broker to start with?

Look for a good broker rather than a dodgy small one offering this and that...etc. remember you 'll have to pay a decent fees for a good service !!

Mate some of your demands are pretty crazy - my fav is this one:

3rd: we MUST NOT fund into broker account. money MUST stay in our bank account or where-ever we want to, like it was some year ago.

That way, I can trade really hard and if I lose money, well then the broker has to be chase me for the money.....

7th: We should have right to withdraw our initial deposit if we lose it all within a month.

8th if brokers are going to manipulate the market they should only manipulate it in our favor

hello,
i mean all those who uses mt4! we could have 1 mt4 platform which can run more accounts of different brokers!

still searching....

true!
but also not impossible. mostly point 1-2 n 5

good point, though i don't use mt4.

wish i could start a brokerage that solves all these problems and gives a fair balanced view, the brokerage should be interested only in its brokerage and nothing else. , anybody interested in the idea

trade FX Futures most the above will be solved.

9th : All must be ECN MT4 Brokers.

All Brokers must surrender their 1st born as collateral.

It was really like that few years ago? Then how can broker collect money from clients if they lose?

I've never heard of any broker doing this.... makes no sense.

just trade 30mins and above timeframe and u will be fine...............no matter how mean your broker is.......they cannot win u if u made the right decision.............

in 1999-2000 i was trading directly from my bank account
then things changed

try some broker if you have time and check moves in CHF pairs last week.
in GBP CHF some one shows a down move to 1.36, some others to 1.37, some others no down move only a 1.39.
no matter the timeframe you use.
if some one decide that is time to burn positions, they do. and you cant do anything.
there are too many confused things by brokers. thats it!
we need clear rules to trade in a crazy market like this.
and there is nothing clear at moment imo