DislikedTest on Y with a UT & driven down now...
4hr,
Attachment
1hr showing trap upmove on previous ND area..
AttachmentIgnored
When? soon i hope..
VSA-divergence trading 187 replies
How to Blow $200 account using VSA--- 594 replies
VSA Journal 57 replies
VSA broker history change datas 11 replies
DislikedTest on Y with a UT & driven down now...
4hr,
Attachment
1hr showing trap upmove on previous ND area..
AttachmentIgnored
DislikedHow can you say that you were wrong after one incident?
If you have 30 losing vsa trades out of 100, then VSA would be a money machine. But have you actually checked how it fares over a long timeframe?Ignored
DislikedDon't get me wrong - I'm not dissing VSA - I just don't think it adds anything to my current method.
It probly does work and no I'm not judging it based on the last trade.
I've been looking into VSA for a long time and I must admit that I still don't fully understand it. And I'm not prepared to do the necessary research and testing to find out how it works because, basically I'm happy with my trading as it is.
Just playing devils advocate lol.Ignored
Disliked...i swear, this thread & all of FF needs more stricter rules.Ignored
Dislikedoh God, why is it SO difficult to visit FF & see a thread free from squabbles?
-there is no holy grail nor guru.(subject to interpretation &/or debate --replies not welcome & expected)
-why would anyone follow someone else's trades if he/she doesnt know the trade's ins & outs?
-we dont know for sure if mal et.al. is/are profitable or not, at the same time it's NOT our business. what i know is they are willing to help & they share part of their life with us, like some other traders in other threads.
-we are not aware of all...Ignored
DislikedSC,
Don't be so sensitive - It's called debate where I come from not squabbling.
And it's good to question our belief systms sometimes. That's why I came here in the first place, I thought VSA had something to offer.
I am sure there are newb's on FF who would have taken a position based om Malcs posturing last week and if I can prevent that from happening(just once) it's all good.Ignored
DislikedOh come on we all know that is normal. Newbies like me do not need protection, we need learning.Ignored
DislikedIn all fairness, Mals thread is under the, "Interactive Trading" section here at FF, making it subject to scrutiny on trade talk...
Learning threads you can find under the, "Trading Systems", headings.
Much as I can appreciate that the idea of this thread is based around VSA and the methods of effective trading through the use of this system, whenever you find yourself in an interactive thread, you can expect to see some bickering.
Not trying to take away from the spirit of the thread, just stating an observation is all.Ignored
DislikedAnd that is what we do. Here anybody (from expert traders to newbies) is free to give his/her analysis of a chart, and that helps all of us to have a deeper view. That is all. No signals, no foretellers....just opinions. If interactive channels were distributing truths we would be all millionaires.
Malcom and other more expert ppl are helping us to learn. That is what I call HELP.Ignored