DislikedLoL.....That really cracks me up.
You think this is still a bullish PB in anyone's style?
Sure, the people that blow their accounts in under a month.
Hey, maybe we should ask Jim to revise the PA basics.
You certainly are expanding the concept of Pin Bars.
Don't you think it would be better to get the basic PA down before you start expanding any concepts?Ignored
Pinbars don't HAVE TO open and close within the prior bar, they just have to show rejection 2-3X the BODY.
Some of the pinbars you guys show here, or atleast in the beginning of the thread are more like dojis and spinning tops. And you don't put into account that there are different feeds that maybe show that "pin" like a spinning top.
James has his way of playing pins and I'm trying to learn it, and while doing so I am also trying to contribute.
Both you and I know very well I'm not the one that should expand the horizons about what we agree on as pinbars or any other candle; however, both you and I know that anyone that has an idea and researched even a small bit about it can contribue with an idea and if it's good. It will make all of us moer profitable.
That said, I am not saying this particular idea was a smart one, I was just wondering IF it was possible. Because I have read in other places that THESE TYPES OF PINBARS ALSO WORK.
Once again I will say this, I have no hard feelings at all when writing this. You have to understand, I am just trying to learn it all! We all know you guys know more about trading than I do, so please understand, what I am writing (ideas) are only attempts to contribute, not to change.
BTW. Thank you very much Mike for helping me out here and also, you were right about my charts from yesterday.
Thanks!