Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Which one is better: an ECN broker or OANDA? 9 replies

Cheapest ECN Comissions - Vantage FX ECN 10 replies

Reliable ECN access which can't markup price 13 replies

ECN, fixed spread or variable spread account? why? 1 reply

Oanda spread versus MB Trading spread 27 replies

Attachments: Which MM or ECN brokers can beat Oanda Spread?
Exit Attachments

Which MM or ECN brokers can beat Oanda Spread?

Right now on FXCLUB's ACT Trader platform average spread is 1pip. On majors of course.

Some times it shows zero spreads but I am not sure if you'll be able to execute your trade at this price.

Lava
interactive brokers...generally .00005 spread on majors, and tight on others.
get away from mt4 crap and you'll find decent brokers.
In addition to already mentioned, MB Trading, Dukascopy
Make your losses in demo. Earn your profits live.
Quoting Forexia
In addition to already mentioned, MB Trading, Dukascopy
90% of time, if you add commission to the spread, Oanda is cheaper than MBT in all currency pairs, I know it because I have accounts in both brokers.
Quoting Trader KGB
Yes and other ECNs show MARKET DEPTH, where's yours? Oh right, you're just an unregistered white-label pretending to be an ECN..

Keep on shilling..

Listed Principals
No principals currently listed

• NFA MEMBER PENDING STATUS WITHDRAWN 07/22/2010
• FUTURES COMMISSION MERCHANT PENDING STATUS WITHDRAWN 07/22/2010

http://www.nfa.futures.org/basicnet/...JSS1RE%3d&rn=Y
Check oneclick plugin in MT script to see depth on MT ECN

oh cool, NFA is not omnipotent controller of FX, and yes they are pending, so ? were is REFCO ? a fully regulated NFA broker now?
If i remember correctly, Refco futures customers from the regulated onshore entity were made good, Refco FX clients (which was offshore) lost most of the funds. That would be more a case for regulation, rather than against.
I'd say FxOpen ECN spreads beat Oanda's.
Quoting bugscoe
{quote} There are usually only a couple reasons why people don't realize why it would matter: 1. You're a longer term trader- 1-5 a day, etc. 2. No matter what style of trader you are, if you're losing money, connection never seems to be an issue. If you consistently make money day after day using a high freq short term strategy that involves 100-200 transactions (not RT) a day and aren't having connection issues, I'd love to hear from you.
I doubt those people would be here worrying about you ..
maybe in Monaco trying the new Ferraris..
Quoting moztrader
{quote} I doubt those people would be here worrying about you .. maybe in Monaco trying the new Ferraris..
Well done to replying to a four year old thread
We have that culture of replying to every one . we don't see the age actually before replying to anyone . Do you really see your dad's age before replying to him??...haha LOL
heh shivanshu

Let's discuss about spreads again! Retail brokers often call their average spread 0,2 - 0,4 pips on majors as "raw" and say that they are transparent. However it is far from a truth. For example my average spread on majors is currently lower than 0,1 pips - that is true interbank market spread.. So do not let them to cheat you!
Quoting 4-ex
heh shivanshu Let's discuss about spreads again! Retail brokers often call their average spread 0,2 - 0,4 pips on majors as "raw" and say that they are transparent. However it is far from a truth. For example my average spread on majors is currently lower than 0,1 pips - that is true interbank market spread.. So do not let them to cheat you!
A True ECN doesn't have spreads - you are the spread - you can create your own 0.1 spread if you so wish .

You pay brokerage for the privilege.
Quoting lasty
{quote} A True ECN doesn't have spreads - you are the spread - you can create your own 0.1 spread if you so wish . You pay brokerage for the privilege.
I do NOT understand you. Are you saying that true interbank market doesn't have spreads? There are both positive and negative spreads, however interbank market has spread.. but of course no commission
Quoting 4-ex
{quote} I do NOT understand you. Are you saying that true interbank market doesn't have spreads? There are both positive and negative spreads, however interbank market has spread.. but of course no commission
If a price maker in the interbank market makes 55 choice what spread is that ?
Quoting qwertymyfx
I'd say FxOpen ECN spreads beat Oanda's.
Could you, or anyone please tell me if you had some troubles withdrawing money with this broker?! Other than that they look great... I'm choosing a broker to try my luck, but I would try with small deposit
Quoting qwertymyfx
I'd say FxOpen ECN spreads beat Oanda's.
Can you give more details ? (spread and account you're trading)
0 traders viewing now