Circle Of Money We win or Lose?

I was Discussing about this Topic in another form... But i think im not much clear to my answer. I know forex is a zero-sum game. If im winning than any one else will be losing and if im losing than anyone else will be winning in my place... I think i am right??? Anyways what's if im winning & another person is also winning...? & wht's if im losing & another person is also losing? or if we both winning or losing inthe same time ?? So in that case the money we lose where she goe's??
Is it necessary that if im winning than anyone else must be losing & vice-versa?
It will be nice to discuss about this in little detail Thank's.
PipHacker

Hey Guy's seems my question is difficult one lol Nobody Know's the answer
PipHackker

piphack,

why do you care?

The forex market is fragmented. There are so many variables such as unregulated feeds, dealers taking the other side of your trade, bucketing trades, shadowing the price with an offset....etc...

You do not get these issues in regulated markets...plus because of the commisions I will say there is not ONE zero-sum game out there..

ES

Hey Man like others i also dont care's but it's not the matter of anyone care's or not but i think this knowledge will be handy.
Thank's

Also you have to remember that this market is different than say stocks. People and companies HAVE to buy Euros for example, as a price of doing business in Germany.

So sometimes when you win, it could be against Rubbermaid. (I met the guy who trades for them, as well as the Honda trader.)

He told me more than once he is told to "buy Euros, cheap if you can.....but buy them either way." As they pay their German employees....it doesn't matter if you make a little off the transaction, they have no choice but to be in it.

So it's a harder question than you think to answer.

Please excuse this nagging question...How will you use this information?...why is it handy?

Oanda keeps track of their traders aggregates...it's there somewhere...they are the only dealer the reveals this info...but I was curious what you would do with it?

ES

Our thread author refers to a phrase "Circle of Money"....


I suppose one can extrapoliate that he "waxes philosophical" when hinting to that phrase in his thread title.

We all live our lives and we make and spend money

1. Some of us spend less to keep more of what we make
2. Some of us make more to keep more after we spend it
3. Some of us spend what we make
4. Some of us make what we spend

I speak with younger employees of companies and some of them did not realize that they must give to a company more than it gives them as the sole existence of a company is to make a profit.

In Sweden they feel that employment is a RIGHT.

In life if you want to have more money it all comes down to trust and delegation. You need to have other people make money for you. Bill Gates and his CEO are very good at that. Warren Buffett leaves the managment intact on all the companies that he buys...

This sole quest that a Forex Trader has is to sit in his living room in his boxer shorts and eek out a living....else they live in denial or they are very successful and are not here in these Forums...as I know of not anybody that is consistently profitable in Forex year over year...

ES