DislikedInteresting fantasy world you live in. Here's what happens in reality.
Tades entered at A,B,C are closed for small loss at D.Ignored
A, B, C, trades are NOT closed at a loss. This strategy NEVER closes a trade if it's in a loss. Any trade that is closed will only ever be closed when it is in profit.
Read PearsonFX's message again and you will see that anything in green was a buy... and he indicates where they were closed for a profit. Anything in the darker red colour was a short and he indicates where he closed those trades for a profit.
No one knows where the market will go, but the market does range more often than it trends and this strategy is taking advantage of that fact.