DislikedIs it just me or is it extremely selfish to come to an area of sharing and bragg about figuring out what so many are struggling with while refusing to share. Keep in mind..Skunny started this thread to give back and help others. The post below does'nt share that spirit in my opinion. Enjoy your AH HA. If you don't give back, it probably won't last.Ignored
Well.....you did ask....so here's my 2 cents worth.
No offense, but this sounds like sour grapes to me.
Skunny started this thread with a basic premise that we all need to remember:
1) He was not going to teach a system.
2) He was not going to tell us everything he does.
3) He was not going to show us how he trades.
4) He has only shown us (so far, I hope) a few % of what he knows.
5) He has said that practice and repetition is the key.
6) He said he was giving us tools to make us traders and not indicator slaves....find our own "moley quail".
7) He said he wanted this thread to remain positive or he was history.
QuoteDislikedIs it just me or is it extremely selfish to come to an area of sharing and bragg
Every class I've ever been in, I've noticed that some "got" the material right away and others struggled a bit. In the end......all that stuck with it passed the class and learned something. Only those that felt the work was not worth the reward quit the class.
QuoteDisliked...about figuring out what so many are struggling with while refusing to share.
1) Are you sure you have "struggled" with this as long as Grkbear has? If not.....how much longer should you have to "struggle" till he or anyone else tells you everything they know? Does someone who has, say, studied forex for years and worked for 100's of hours running fibs have the obligation to tell somone who happens into forex last week and in their 2nd post here want to know "everything"?
2) Refuse to share?.....all I saw him say is that he understood why people who got this don't just give it away. Did you ask him any questions? He might be willing to give some guidance. How many people that used to post at the outset of this thread are not here anymore? What if they "got" it and are now trading well? Should they be condemned? Or did Skunny just succeed at helping them? Didn't Skunny say something like only 1/2 might get this and be able to trade it successfully and even he didn't know why (paraphrasing)?
QuoteDislikedKeep in mind..Skunny started this thread to give back and help others.
QuoteDislikedThe post below does'nt share that spirit in my opinion. Enjoy your AH HA. If you don't give back, it probably won't last
I am not here to speak for Skunny or anyone on this thread. These are my feelings.
I really would hate to see this thread turn into a lot of jealous sniping. There is far too much of value here to learn. I really believe that what Skunny has already provided is more than enough to point the way.
This thread is about self-discovery. Grkbear claims to have discovered something that works for him. He's been at it for months.....going for days without sleep. Good for him! Will it work for you or anyone else? Who knows? With only what has been given so far, IMO, if someone can not improve their trading 500%......they just aren't trying hard enough.
Skunny's whole methodology has been to drop hints.....give general directives. It's all there. Read his posts.....eat drink and sleep his charts. There are enough hints out there.
Seriously......I'm not trying to break bad on you here. Just feel that condemning someone for actually getting what Skunny is teaching is not in the spirit of this thread. Perhaps put some more pressure on the teacher if you feel that is the right thing to do....not the students.....I think the teacher can handle the heat!
P.S. Skunny is too classy to mention this so I'll throw it out there again. I would strongly urge anyone who is having success with what is being taught here to show your appreciation with a contribution to Skunny's charitable foundation.....I'll be cutting a check this week!