Williams%R, SAR X-over 15 minute candles

Quoting rockypoint

Disliked

2 trades a small win and a big one, then some supersonic PA that was not tradeable, now slowing back down with some consolidation, There were a couple of entry signals after the super fast PA but I passed wanting to see price slow down for awhile first. {image}

Ignored

Quoting vidvad

Disliked

This is my personal live account on ninjatrader. You can compare my entry to the ADX lines. Again, I got in early compared to the ADX and my entry made my +25 tick fixed profit. I would not have gotten that waiting for an ADX entry and this would likely have been a very small profit, +2 to +6 ticks at best. {image}

Ignored

Quoting rockypoint

Disliked

2 Hours behind NY. Took another trade. {image}

Ignored

Quoting vidvad

Disliked

I'm trading a Tradovate Demo account this morning as part of a side project I am doing so I will have to show my trades on an M1 chart: {image} The first trade I was stopped out for +2 ticks after price came within6 ticks of my 25 tick profit target. Then the short hit my +25 tick profit target and I am done with the eval account for the day. Here is how the rocky chart looks. I used vertical lines to show the ADX signal candles (entry would have been made on the candle following the signal candles. I use an up arrow to show where I entered long...

Ignored

Quoting driven18

Disliked

{quote} vidvad, I appreciate you starting to show your trading with 1 Min Candles chart..many subs on FF have only MT4 and MT5 and can not get proper Renko. There is no need for MACD at all and ADX does not work as it is always late. I believe the way you have it with 34 EMA and 8EMA channel will work out the same, I suggest add HA candle to 1 Min TF chart for Stop Loss following.

Ignored

Quoting driven18

Disliked

{quote} vidvad, I appreciate you starting to show your trading with 1 Min Candles chart..many subs on FF have only MT4 and MT5 and can not get proper Renko. There is no need for MACD at all and ADX does not work as it is always late. I believe the way you have it with 34 EMA and 8EMA channel will work out the same, I suggest add HA candle to 1 Min TF chart for Stop Loss following.

Ignored

Quoting vidvad

Disliked

{quote} Who are you using for data feed? I have three data feeds and I don't see that fast rise and fall that you marked as "untradable" on your chart on any of them. I have Think or Swim, Ninjatrader Continuum, and CQG feeds and not one of them show any unusual and fast price action at 9:46 AM NYC time, which would be 7:46 AM your time.

Ignored

Quoting rockypoint

Disliked

{quote} I use Rithmic, going to contact Ninja trader, as I just opened platform back up and that untradeable section is gone!

Ignored

Quoting vidvad

Disliked

{quote} I don't know if tradovate offers the renko HA set up either. For now, I'm using tradovate's DOM for order entry/position management and Ninjatrader for my charts. I agree. I think ADX is entirely too slow for me to use as a trigger. I prefer to enter based on the candles action, not a subpane indicator. The ema's with the 34 ema work out well for me and the entries I have grown accustomed to making using just the ema's are typicall a bar or two quicker than if I use ADX, and that bar or two difference is important. My trade in my Ninjatrader...

Ignored