Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

People waiting for Chrismas, I'm waiting for FOMC 0 replies

Thoughts/Thought Experiments on Money Management and Trading 10 replies

DmitryFX's trading experiments 20 replies

Order Comment blank after order closed 4 replies

Attachments: Experiments - while waiting for an order to get closed
Exit Attachments

Experiments - while waiting for an order to get closed

Quoting herbie88
So ,as far as I see the whole case is the multi time frame indicators are re-calculating because 1 hour time frame indicator is not complete on 5 minutes time frame chart.Because 1 hour time frame indicator (cci, rsi etc...) lags 12 bar on 5 minutes (12x5 minutes= 1 hour) charts . And Mladen found a new way of coding/calculation in mql5/mql4 that any 1 hour time frame indicator is complete on 5 minutes charts.And no more waiting 12 bars to complete for 1 hour time frame indicator (cci, rsi etc...) in 5 minutes charts.Is that correct?
Yes,correctly as you describing
the new nrp ATF (all time frame) see the details of ATF here
https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...0#post13515470
as per your example at M5 chart indicator with H1,at every single bar of M5 the indicator calculate and display H1 indicator data correctly that never repaint like all the early mtf versions of every type and variant
Indicator is just a supportive tool-Use it only if it can benefit you
Quoting herbie88
{quote} Mladen, Is it possible to visualize 5 minute time frame indicator on 1 hour chart without the recalculation of data ?
Have you ever tried as you asking - by applying lower tf indicator at higher TF chart ?
i think any indicator when applied like you described,it displayed by its current TF indicator data,no difference if it is M30,M15,M5 or M1,the same display like the current TF indicator data
But Mladen can better explain you -
Indicator is just a supportive tool-Use it only if it can benefit you
Yes I tried and applied lower time frame to higher time frame and I saw what you saw no difference.

But when applying 60 period EMA on 5 minute chart shouldn't be look like look like 5 period EMA on 1 hour time frame chart instead of no data difference?
Quoting herbie88
Yes I tried and applied lower time frame to higher time frame and I saw what you saw no difference. But when applying 60 period EMA on 5 minute chart shouldn't be look like look like 5 period EMA on 1 hour time frame chart instead of no data difference?
Two different things and differently displayed,you can not compare it in that way
Indicator is just a supportive tool-Use it only if it can benefit you
No , what I am trying to say is when you apply 1H time frame indicator on 5 minutes chart the indicator lags 12 bar on 5 minutes charts which make sense.

But when you apply lower time frame indicator on higher time frame the indicator only displays its current time frame data ,no difference.So that is not a lower time frame data on higher time frame chart.
Quoting herbie88
No , what I am trying to say is when you apply 1H time frame indicator on 5 minutes chart the indicator lags 12 bar on 5 minutes charts which make sense. But when you apply lower time frame indicator on higher time frame the indicator only displays its current time frame data ,no difference.So that is not a lower time frame data on higher time frame chart.
No,it is not lower TF indicator data on higher TF chart but indicators current TF data on current TF chart,whatever lower TF indicator applied
Indicator is just a supportive tool-Use it only if it can benefit you
Quoting mladen
{quote} Here you go : {image} {file}
is this MT5 indi still working for you mladen?

it isnt working on version 5.00 build 2957
Quoting mladen
{quote} Here you go : {image} {file}
I confirm that it doesn't work even on a newer version.
It would be nice if it worked.

Thanks for your commitment.

Attached Image
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe
Quoting Trader-IT
{quote} I confirm that it doesn't work even on a newer version. It would be nice if it worked. Thanks for your commitment. {image}

what sort of things?
Guys
It is working with me at "ver 5.00 build 2940" (official ver not the beta) by 21 May 2021
try allowing dll and pressing on/off button or see something your part
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: EURUSDM5-off.png Size: 25 KB
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: EURUSDM5-on.png Size: 27 KB
Indicator is just a supportive tool-Use it only if it can benefit you
Quoting mntiwana
Guys It is working with me at "ver 5.00 build 2940" (official ver not the beta) by 21 May 2021 try allowing dll and pressing on/off button or see something your part {image}{image}
build 2940 is before build 2957
Quoting mntiwana
Guys It is working with me at "ver 5.00 build 2940" (official ver not the beta) by 21 May 2021 try allowing dll and pressing on/off button or see something your part {image}{image}
Hello mntiwana.

If I apply the button to a single MT5 full screen window, as in your example, it works,
even if the difference is really insignificant, between frame and non-frame.

This function of removing borders (button, not button, indicator or script) only makes sense in case of many open windows.
I expect it to work like in the MT4 version:
with frames
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: cornici.png Size: 68 KB

without frames
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: senza cornici.png Size: 62 KB


instead on MT5:
With frames. I can enlarge or move the windows.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: cornici MT5.png Size: 95 KB

Without frames. You can still see them, but my windows are frozen. Impossible to stretch, tighten or move.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: senza cornici MT5.png Size: 95 KB


PS:
I confirm that the dll is enabled. And thanks for your help.
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe
Quoting Le.Metier
{quote} what sort of things?
Hello Le.Metier.
Sorry, but I can't understand your question (bastard machine translation), can you rephrase it, please?
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe
Quoting Trader-IT
{quote} Hello Le.Metier. Sorry, but I can't understand your question (bastard machine translation), can you rephrase it, please?
here
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: what sort of things.png Size: 215 KB
Quoting Le.Metier
{quote} here {image}
Now I get it!!!
"A picture is worth 1000 words".
You are not the first to ask for this.

Let's say that I have seen, heard, read, known, a lot in my life. Both in the workplace and in the private one.
Unique experiences that a normal person is unlikely to face.
Places, situations, people. Facts, documents, theories, evidence. Philosophy and science.
Too much, to talk or write about it even for a year.
Besides, nobody would believe it.

Anyway thanks for asking.
Curiosity was that "thing", that made the Human Being what he is today.
I've seen things you people wouldn't believe
Quoting Trader-IT
Unique experiences that a normal person is unlikely to face. Besides, nobody would believe it.
same...there is more to life than meets the eye
but you wouldnt believe me so I cant tell you
Quoting mntiwana
{quote} Yes,correctly as you describing the new nrp ATF (all time frame) see the details of ATF here https://www.forexfactory.com/thread/...0#post13515470 as per your example at M5 chart indicator with H1,at every single bar of M5 the indicator calculate and display H1 indicator data correctly that never repaint like all the early mtf versions of every type and variant
Hi mntiwana, has mladen released the atf indicators? I can’t find them.
  • Post #598
  • Quote
  • Edited at 10:22pm Jun 18, 2021 9:16pm | Edited at 10:22pm
Quoting LearnALot
{quote} Hi mntiwana, has mladen released the atf indicators? I can’t find them.
Partially,yes
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: EURUSDM1.png Size: 62 KB
Indicator is just a supportive tool-Use it only if it can benefit you
Quoting mntiwana
{quote} Partially,yes {image}
Where can I download this?
Quoting Le.Metier
{quote} is this MT5 indi still working for you mladen? it isnt working on version 5.00 build 2957
bump
1 trader viewing now