Amntrader systems - question.

Hello.

Maybe someone can help me.

I use NinjaTrader in my trading. I want to buy an automatic system from the Amntrader company.

There is little information about them, maybe there are real users of these systems who can answer a couple of questions.

Thanks in advance!

I apologize to admins if I created a topic in the wrong section.

Hi Tuba
I have two systems from this company. It is a working systems with good performance.
What exactly would you like to know?

Did you create an account just to advertise for Amntrader?

If I registered recently, it doesn't mean that I don't read this site.
Where do you see advertise?
The person asked about the system and I answered, is there a problem?

Hi Jumbothetrad
I am also interested in the AMN Trader, I want to use it to trade micro such as MES, MYM, M2K, M6E, QM and MGC.

I am considering either AMN Trader or BoxB which is a new release.

Which 2 systems that you bought ? Do you trade any of the above with the 2, or are they mainly for FX ?

Do you need to optimize the systems often? Are you live results as good as they claim on their web site ?

Do you have large draw downs with your 2 systems?

Any comments are aprecaited. Tkx.

Hi
I have two of their systems, AMNTrader and Ichimoku. Systems have many parameters, and it is initially difficult to deal with many. But the system kit also includes blanks for creating your own templates. All parameters during template creation are calculated automatically with maximum efficiency.
I don't know anything about their new system.
If you are interested in trading micro contracts then an Amntrader is more suitable for you.
I added some images for a couple of micros.

Thank you very much jumbothetrad

If you don't mind, could you show even more results for other instruments (mNQ;mGC;m2K;ES;NQ;GC etc) for the Amntrader system?

I would be grateful for any information!

I just subscribed to the AMNTrader trial, backtesting shows great results, just like the web site.

But running Market Replay shows a very different scenerio. Only MES is consistent, but not other markets.


Back test uses bar close, and ignores the sequence of tick data coming in, e.g., the low could occur before the high, and tick data would have sold at the low, and got stopped out at the high for a loss. Whereas in back test, it would have taken the close only and would show a profit instead.

So I will test more before jumping to conclusions - use Market Replay, not just back test.

MES Back test vs Market Replay results :

Backtest results:

Market replay over the same period:

Hi Mchiang
What type of chart did you run tests on?
I do not know how you test.
My results are quite decent and the results of testing with real trades coincide by 95%! After I made sure that the SIM account was working properly, I launched a real account (I upload a trade performance report) I am satisfied with the results for three trading instruments ! the guys made a high-quality strategy with a low price. Other developers cannot be compared with this company either in terms of the prices of their products or the efficiency of their systems. I've tried a lot of systems and I know what I'm talking about.
To get good results, you need to work with the settings to reach their full potential, but it's worth it. My advice to you is to use full Renko i.e. with HLOC. Always set the fill resolution high and 1 tick + 1 sipread in the final testing.
Attached screens from VPS

I am using the 3 line break chart as suggested by the vendor. I first tested with 10 Renko bars using templates supplied by the vendor but got poor results.

I always use market replay to test each contract , eg, MES/MNQ 12-20, 09-20, 06-20, 03-30

All settings were based on the templates supplied by the vendor.

As discussed above, back test on all contracts (3 Line Break, Renko bars) gave very good results but which are not attainable by Market Replay, because back test ignores the sequence of data coming in. That's why I always test by Market Replay, and it took me 5-6 hours to run each contract set.

I tested all contracts using 10 and 20 Renko bars that comes with NT8, I also tried other Renko bars by other vendor, again, based on the template settings supplied by the vendor. Results were poor.

With 3 Line Break charts, only MES showed profit from April to now. 03-20 contracts (Jan to March) gave poor results, because the optimized templates for that period was not available.

I hope I can purchase the system to test it for a longer period because of its potential, but now I am confused. Live SIM account with MNQ/MYM/M2K/MES since last Friday is still -ve. I now deleted all other contracts and let MES run alone and see.

Hi Jumbothetrad
Would you mind sending me the template files that you are using to trade to get the above results?

I can send me you email address to receive it or you can uploading it here.

Tkx

Hello Mchiang
I can give you template for mes

Hi, I am thinking about a couple of the systems that are available from this company.
This is the only place where there is any discussion about these systems that I can find.
As the posts here are from some time ago, is there anyone with more recent experience with these systems?
When I see systems that are hitting over 90% win rate and high profit factors that just don't seem realistic,
it begs the question, are these results or anything close achievable?
To be honest, I am more realistic about what I expect, I just want to see some consistency and perhaps an indication of how robust
these systems are.
I am considering AMNTrader and Ichimoku as is shown above.
Has anyone been trading these systems more recently and able to provide some evidence of real results?
Thx.