Hi Guys,
Do you guys enter with market orders or are you setting limit/stop orders at the blue/red dots level?
FuturePips with all the respect for your hard work, you did not reply exactly to MSLDIN regarding his positions noted on his chart.
Pos 1 - He mentioned his position 1 taken on May 20 was a winning position - You consider it as a loss
Pos 2 - Not taken as already in Pos 1 - You don't take it as already in Pos 1
Pos 3 - Entered as Pos 1 was a gain and in a correction after an impulse in line with blue Qsigma trend indicator - You don't take it as you consider you are still in Pos 1
Pos 4 - resulted in a loss - You discard the entry influenced by your decision in Pos 1.
In your video you comment that to be considered as a valid buy signal. you mention that you should have had a correction then a another correction.
The essential question is how important is important enough to be considered as a correction? just by mentioning this you are not respecting your "systematic rule" as it is more a appreciation and therefore it becomes discretionary.
Pos 6 - Traded and win - you trade it and win
Pos 7,8,9, Not traded as in pos 6 - compare your chart with MSLDIN - on his chart there is an extra signal not visible in your video.
Pos 10 - traded and was a loss - you took a loss as well.
Pos 11, 12 not taken as per impulse rules
In your final conclusion why do you consider the signal given on the 19th as valid, If a trader would have study this approach on the 19th and started on the 20th It would never have considered the entry at all. you were given a fixed date range 20th to 26th.
Could you without unveiling all your secrets ingredients, explain what you consider an impulse move and a correction (not the basic stuff that we can find everywhere) but explain what do you compare to consider that a movement is an impulse or a correction?
Thank you for your attention
Gerald
Do you guys enter with market orders or are you setting limit/stop orders at the blue/red dots level?
FuturePips with all the respect for your hard work, you did not reply exactly to MSLDIN regarding his positions noted on his chart.
Pos 1 - He mentioned his position 1 taken on May 20 was a winning position - You consider it as a loss
Pos 2 - Not taken as already in Pos 1 - You don't take it as already in Pos 1
Pos 3 - Entered as Pos 1 was a gain and in a correction after an impulse in line with blue Qsigma trend indicator - You don't take it as you consider you are still in Pos 1
Pos 4 - resulted in a loss - You discard the entry influenced by your decision in Pos 1.
In your video you comment that to be considered as a valid buy signal. you mention that you should have had a correction then a another correction.
The essential question is how important is important enough to be considered as a correction? just by mentioning this you are not respecting your "systematic rule" as it is more a appreciation and therefore it becomes discretionary.
Pos 6 - Traded and win - you trade it and win
Pos 7,8,9, Not traded as in pos 6 - compare your chart with MSLDIN - on his chart there is an extra signal not visible in your video.
Pos 10 - traded and was a loss - you took a loss as well.
Pos 11, 12 not taken as per impulse rules
In your final conclusion why do you consider the signal given on the 19th as valid, If a trader would have study this approach on the 19th and started on the 20th It would never have considered the entry at all. you were given a fixed date range 20th to 26th.
Could you without unveiling all your secrets ingredients, explain what you consider an impulse move and a correction (not the basic stuff that we can find everywhere) but explain what do you compare to consider that a movement is an impulse or a correction?
Thank you for your attention
Gerald
1
![Click to Enlarge
Name: GBPCADM15 [2].png
Size: 57 KB](/attachment/image/3669802/thumbnail?d=1592661530)
![Click to Enlarge
Name: EURUSDM15 [2].png
Size: 62 KB](/attachment/image/3669940/thumbnail?d=1592689644)
Nice work keep it up