{quote} there is too much good review in the video so i think it should be profitable, but i am not sure.
Ignored
i backtested your Bar ea, the ea is not profitable because it requires very small spread, which no broker has. So i think he is not a scammer, just the broker have more spread.
The iSwing EA is not spread sensitive, since it is a swing ea. I bought it because it trade 24/5, not just night scalper.
{quote} i backtested your Bar ea, the ea is not profitable because it requires very small spread, which no broker has. So i think he is not a scammer, just the broker have more spread. The iSwing EA is not spread sensitive, since it is a swing ea. I bought it because it trade 24/5, not just night scalper. Here is my signal: https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/403489
Ignored
Ok great thank you lets see how this signal goes it will prove whether this guy is a scammer or not...
{quote} i backtested your Bar ea, the ea is not profitable because it requires very small spread, which no broker has. So i think he is not a scammer, just the broker have more spread. The iSwing EA is not spread sensitive, since it is a swing ea. I bought it because it trade 24/5, not just night scalper. Here is my signal: https://www.mql5.com/en/signals/403489 Update: Looks like to be curve fitting EA, only profitable in 2017 to 2018 March 1st. Sorry guys
Ignored
Why did you disable your signal after only a few days?
I paid $298 for this EA, but i'll share it for FREE right here... enjoy His scam EA name is now changed to Bar Pro V7 and he has given his scam youtube channel a makeover https://www.youtube.com/user/nhatvinhbk AVOID AT ALL COSTS, DO NOT SEND THIS SCAMMER ANY MONEY AND REPORT HIS CHANNEL ON YOUTUBE {image} {file}
Ignored
Dear u should upgrade ur EA now into bar ipro v10.1 great. And if u got it kindly must share
I saw a acc that is running on it
Ic market real 10
1000048085
Goprofit1
I hop it will best for u.
Gud luck
{quote} Yes, I'm hoping people share their test results to see if forward testing matches the backtest results like the author claims... i paid US$ 298 and I am at least generous enough to share with everyone here for free, there are so far 233 downloads of the EA but not many people are providing feedback so please if you have downloaded the EA try to give some feedback whether its positive or negative so we can at least discern whether this EA is worth taking serious or not.... if not then I can request a full refund from the author which he claims...
I wanted to pm you but i am a new member and am unable to do so
First of all Thank you for sharing your purchased EA, even if it did not turn out to be what you expected.
I like how the EA works and I have been back testing and forward testing your EA both on Demo and Live acc for a month now on VPS
I have found that with the right pairs, timeframe and settings (not what is suggested by the seller), and on a low spread account this EA is profitable in the long run, even after accounting for commissions. The issue i have come across is that the EA will open trades more frequently in Demo acc than in Real acc. (In demo it will open trades every day, whether on live acc every 2-3 days)
I run the EA from Mon evening till Thur evenings and stop it from Fri to Sun evening, so you can see my problem
I am running the EA with the exact same settings, TF and pairs at the same time on demo and live and can clearly see how the EA works.
The EA still makes money but very slowly, BUT if it could open trades daily on live acc as it does on demo, it will be even better.
I am not a coder and i dont have the mq4 file but i don't know whether it is written in the code for the EA to trade less on real acc than on demo. After running this EA with the same broker, settings and pretty much the same price feed, this is the only thing i can think of that stops the EA from trading more often on live acc
As an example
I run the EA on 10 pairs. Last night on demo the EA opened orders on 5 pairs, 4 profitable and 1 loss.
On live account it didn't open any orders at all which is very frustrating
If this issue can be solved, i believe this EA has great potential
In case you, or anyone who understands how to resolve this problem, have any ideas/suggestions you can contact me at the above email address
{quote} @Suetombo I hope you see this msg. If you do, pls email me [email protected] ("[email protected]") I wanted to pm you but i am a new member and am unable to do so First of all Thank you for sharing your purchased EA, even if it did not turn out to be what you expected. I like how the EA works and I have been back testing and forward testing your EA both on Demo and Live acc for a month now on VPS I have found that with the right pairs, timeframe and settings (not what is suggested by the seller), and on...
Ignored
Thank you for posting your experience / results here for everyone. I am glad you didn't PM - why keep things secret when we are all in this together? You receive the EA for free, yet you want to hide things and not give back to the community?
So how about I share my idea to help you: Why don't you copy trades from Demo to Live using FX Blue Internet Trade Mirror or Personal Trade Copier?
Can you please explain what pairs, timeframes, settings you are using profitably on Demo?
{quote} Thank you for posting your experience / results here for everyone. I am glad you didn't PM - why keep things secret when we are all in this together? You receive the EA for free, yet you want to hide things and not give back to the community? So how about I share my idea to help you: Why don't you copy trades from Demo to Live using FX Blue Internet Trade Mirror or Personal Trade Copier? Can you please explain what pairs, timeframes, settings you are using profitably on Demo? I hope we can all make money from forex some day.
Ignored
The demo account has nothing to do with the real one. The demo accounts are real because no broker monitors them. The real ones monitor them constantly, add latency, spread, etc ... This is what actually destroys the EA. The testers that you make with any EA, even if you get 100% quality does not mean that they actually work in the same way. If you test the EAs in demo, you will not have the same results in real. Brokers play a lot with latency and the law whether FCA, ASIC or whatever, allows it. If you do not believe me, you can see what exactly the FCA regulates.
I know this thread is very old, but wanted to share my tests with you so everything should be very clear about this EA.
In the backtests, most profitables trades are coming at midnight, when the spread is too high for the EA to trade, so I've created some "What If" alternatives. If we delete trades at these hours, the EA is a total garbage... I joined you some screenshots.
