Price action at the core / tma intra day | Page 131 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

TMA Reality Tour 116 replies

Happs with TMA Trading Journal 25 replies

Is it possible to get a sound on TMA when touched by price? 4 replies

MTF TMA 287 replies

SnakeForce - simple TMA with alert? 3 replies

Attachments: Price action at the core / tma intra day
Exit Attachments

Price action at the core / tma intra day

  • #2,601
  • Mar 24, 2019 4:03pm Mar 24, 2019 4:03pm
Quoting princefred
{quote} I'm not for talks hence the call for a TE. Even if i want talk, TE can do a lot of talking. It sounds like what i asked for - a TE so stop assuming or projecting any other thing to it. If i want any other thing i would have asked. It sounds like you and running from and deflecting from the only thing i asked for; a TE - a minimum prove of concept not all talk.
Why are you crying for a TE? No one wants to show you TE. Focus on your own trading.
  • #2,602
  • Mar 24, 2019 4:10pm Mar 24, 2019 4:10pm
Quoting bluesteele
Everyone is all talk..until it comes down to talk...then they run away lol...
Last night I had the pleasure speaking with George and Peter. I was an early skeptic and had even posted one or two of the first rude comments -- though @bluesteele and others subsequently wrote more scathing criticisms (sorry, @bluesteele, I just had to add that to needle you a bit). @bluesteele's reversal was one of the main reasons I decided to grow up, contact George and see if I could gain a better understanding of what the story was behind this thread. I now have zero doubt George is the real deal. Thank you George and thank you @bluesteele.

For those naysayers who demand proof, well, here you go:
ROBOTS4ME ,,,, SAYS ,,,, GEORGE ,,, IS ,,, THE ,,,, REAL ,,,, DEAL ! ! ! !
There you go -- there's your proof...

Seriously -- for those who demand proof -- what a crock of BS. To @kenshit and @calebfx @failinforex, @STrading and @ZenNY -- you dudes should grow up and spend less time playing video games. Some of you have yellow badges after your aliases -- really? What did you do to deserve those -- "like" one another's lame posts? If you have a yellow badge after your alias I assume that means you are an experienced trader -- well, if so, then show me proof. I don't believe you guys know sh-t. I think everyone needs to see what you've done here to deserve a yellow badge. I've been told I have a nice a-s and sometimes I'll mention that online. But I'm hesitant to do so here because then those same fellows will demand proof and I'll have to pull down my pants again and bend over. Sometimes I'll oblige, but not here...

Learning to trade is an experimental task -- it's something you do. As has been posted elsewhere and by a very wise trader -- it is never a waste of time to experiment and learn something on your own. If you are not so smart, or are incapable of learning, or need someone to hold your hand then, yes, of course you would demand proof -- that's the request of a lazy person. But if you have the desire and interest and motivation, then take the plunge and don't hide behind "show me proof" as an excuse to continue sitting on your duff, patting your behind, and playing your video game.

Okay -- come on naysayers -- put those game controllers down and show what you are really made of. Let's see what kind of trader you really are. And by the way, insults don't count. I mean, of course you can use insults when discussing trading, but we all know those are used as a substitute by people who don't know how to trade. It's okay for me to use insults because I'm a lousy trader and know it. But you guys claim otherwise and, so, we need proof.
  • #2,604
  • Mar 24, 2019 4:38pm Mar 24, 2019 4:38pm
Quoting kenshin
Well, you believe whatever frog shit you want, but don't try to make a fact-based statement and then have f*ck all evidence to back it up with.
@kenshin -- okay I get it. I apologize for my rudeness and insults -- I'll make more of an effort to filter those in the future.

I understand now we have fundamental differences that can never be bridged -- we are quite different people. What we share in common is we enjoy coming here because it is a way to socialize and interact with other traders. Where we differ is you assume everyone is lying unless they show you proof -- even in a public forum that we both know is littered with BS. I don't require proof. In my previous life I was a research scientist and I enjoy the empirical approach -- that is, give me some pointers and then I'm content to go off and figure things out for myself. Sometimes it works out -- which is tremendously satisfying -- and sometimes it doesn't. But I have confidence that if there is value then I'll get it to work. Other people need to be shown proof before they will move from their current position.

This type of difference in people is neither good nor bad -- it's what makes the world go 'round...
  • #2,607
  • Mar 24, 2019 4:52pm Mar 24, 2019 4:52pm
woof woof blah blah ,isnt this going to end.

If George is helping people improve their results in trading at no charge,as reported on numerous occasions,

who cares what you find believable. lets just concentrate on improving our own trading.

Walter
  • #2,608
  • Mar 24, 2019 4:59pm Mar 24, 2019 4:59pm
Quoting kenshin
No problem man. Don't take me too serious here.
I'm glad we can tone things down a bit. You are now invited to my next birthday party...
  • #2,609
  • Mar 24, 2019 5:10pm Mar 24, 2019 5:10pm
Quoting oztrader
woof woof blah blah ,isnt this going to end. If George is helping people improve their results in trading at no charge,as reported on numerous occasions, who cares what you find believable. lets just concentrate on improving our own trading. Walter
Cheers Walter

That's the spirit ! And isn't what you said ..what this all is about !

Improving ourselves ...

All the best to you Walter,

Kevin
Master your Mind,,,Master the Market
  • #2,610
  • Mar 24, 2019 5:26pm Mar 24, 2019 5:26pm
It just amazes me that 2,608 (this should be 2,609th post at the time of writing) on this thread, there are still those that stay around asking for proof/ TE's without putting in the effort them selves.

Maybe it is their ego, or George has shown something that they think is impossible because they failed to achieve it them selves? Who knows what the reasons are... Chasing some TE/ proof will not make anyone a better trader from my humble opinion, doing the actual work to gain practice, experience and knowledge will.

If anyone thinks that if after they get access to Georges/ other successful traders TE/ trade histories and proofs of accuracy of entries; they will become as good as those trades think again. Like stated by countless others: it takes lots of hard work (years) to even get close or if ever to such a skill level...

If you take a tennis player for example, say you were able to obtain their diet + training journals as well as all of their techniques. Does that mean you can then go out and play at their level, or even vs someone that has been playing tennis non-professionally for a year? Of course not, you will get more wrecked then an egg being crushed by a bowling ball. Why? Playing tennis at the highest level requires 100's of HOURS/ YEARS of PRACTICE to master each stroke as well as having a PHYSICAL change occur to your body! That's right, the professional tennis players you see are physically different to those not playing tennis professionally in terms of bone composition. (Here is some PROOF -.- , want more search google scholar).

So please, to those that keep asking: Do your self a favour, let go of your ego if you have one and either put in the effort to get some value from the thread or just move on to the next thing as there is nothing for you here.

Best Regards,
Kola
"Work hard, put in the effort, and follow your dreams..." -Me
  • #2,611
  • Mar 24, 2019 6:07pm Mar 24, 2019 6:07pm
Hello Trader,
I am new one in this forum want to have some input ,No one like George.Look at us ,when we have experience like him .Are we going to threads online from pages to pages teaching us ,draw charges using his health to help us like that,no way we want to do that.Every one live with their selfish ,keep their secret to make money ,enjoy their own life . That always of nature life ,no complain about that of course your guy don 't have to teach some one and now he the one to help why we have to complain . I am new one in this forum ,afraid to ask because stupid questions ,or newbie no one want to help newbie ,just wast their time.Even I was looking for mentor ,willing to pay you think they will help me .Ah ah ah ,no one will help newbie ,professional whoever charge for class trading ,you might pay but but you are not going to make money .Anyway pay him a respect and appreciate whatever the time he put with us.I have nothing to learn from him yet ,because I don't have enough knowledge to learn ,even George show pictures and words from step to step ,just reading and watching until I learn enough to ask George. I hope by that time he still help us ,when we need it .Your guy ,please, enjoy your free ride and learn as much as you can,later on when you look back and feel sorry because you didn't take advantage when he is here. Peoples always look back and think why didn't I learn that and do that.Sorry English it is not my main language ,just try to express what I think about George help and hope everyone can make from George trading.If you don't like what did I say from this threads,please forgive me ,because i am newbie.
Cheer
Munchie
  • #2,612
  • Mar 24, 2019 6:21pm Mar 24, 2019 6:21pm
Either you have gain some knowledge from the thread or from George directly via Skype or NOT.

For those of you still in the "NOT" group time to move on as no one cares about your opinion or your silly requests to show his trades or his trading account.

Time to concentrate on your own methodology that's working for you rather than trying to tear down another trader who is just trying to help others.

Dave
  • #2,613
  • Mar 24, 2019 6:23pm Mar 24, 2019 6:23pm
Quoting munchie
Hello Trader, I am new one in this forum want to have some input ,No one like George.Look at us ,when we have experience like him .Are we going to threads online from pages to pages teaching us ,draw charges using his health to help us like that,no way we want to do that.Every one live with their selfish ,keep their secret to make money ,enjoy their own life . That always of nature life ,no complain about that of course your guy don 't have to teach some one and now he the one to help why we have to complain . I am new one in this forum ,afraid...
I think most of us here feel that way.....Sums it up very nicely...couldn't have said it better!!!!

Layne
Layne Rockhill
  • #2,614
  • Edited 6:52pm Mar 24, 2019 6:28pm | Edited 6:52pm
Selling GBP/JPY right now
Trade closed
  • #2,615
  • Mar 24, 2019 6:31pm Mar 24, 2019 6:31pm
Munchie[quot[/quote]I am new one in this forum ,afraid to ask because stupid questions ,or newbie no one want to help newbie ,just wast their time.Even I was looking for mentor ,willing to pay you think they will help me .Ah ah ah ,no one will help newbie ,professional whoever charge for class trading ,you might pay but but you are not going to make money .Anyway pay him a respect and appreciate whatever the time he put with us.I have nothing to learn from him yet ,because I don't have enough knowledge to learn ,even George show pictures and words from step to step ,just reading and watching until I learn enough to ask George. I hope by that time he still help us ,when we need it .Your guy ,please, enjoy your free ride and learn as much as you can,later on when you look back and feel sorry because you did

Sorry missed the meat!
Layne Rockhill
  • #2,616
  • Mar 24, 2019 6:51pm Mar 24, 2019 6:51pm
Quoting behof
Selling GBP/JPY right now
good decision. Hold until Friday for best results, and add into the downtrend if you know how to do it.
  • #2,617
  • Mar 24, 2019 7:28pm Mar 24, 2019 7:28pm
Long on usdjpy right now
  • #2,618
  • Mar 24, 2019 7:33pm Mar 24, 2019 7:33pm
Hi George,

Wish you a quick recovery for your health!
Thanks to help me to be BOUNDLESS MINDSET!!

Still a lot of work must done with screen time, backtest and find best entry.

God bless you Sir George!

Edwart
- X -
  • #2,619
  • Mar 24, 2019 9:16pm Mar 24, 2019 9:16pm
Quoting bluesteele
{quote} The funny thing is here Prince Fred... George has put himself available to anyone.... to actually go over charts with anyone LIVE... Man to Man... To me that is far more impressive than a TE... Everyone is all talk..until it comes down to talk...then they run away lol... And really...IF anyone is half assed serious they will contact George personally. A TE proves absolutely nothing.... You can give 10 traders the same method and you will get 10 different results.. So if I post up a TE it means nothing ....only to me it does...Its irrelevant...
A TE has a lot more than %gained/lost.
The max DD, the trade duration, biggest gain/loss, lot size, the time log that help you plot each trade on your own chart to understand better, etc.
Sometimes a picture can tell 1000 words, indeed.
It give a fast summary what to expect the least.
As an experienced trader I am sure you understand that.
I would bet you would agree that if you go to the ''''ding systems' section, min. 50% of the time just reading the rules would give you an idea if the system viable, and 90% of time looking at some examples you could recognize when it is likely a waste of you time to look further into.
A TE, even a shorter period can aid this decision making, to near 100% of time.

I mean...
I really don't care if George post one. I am more interested all the enlightened followers, and why no one bothers with even a demo TE.
Your example of the winning trader losing for 9 months study and study is a possible version to answer.

But ( and without disrespect) when in the " homework to George " thread you find someone happily marking up historical charts, with huge hindsight bias - other points ignored and unmarked even if similar kind, entry points assumed at low or news and time of day, etc.
Does that do any good?
Is that superior in understanding/learning a system or concept vs. a same 1 week period on a do TE?

I think, wrongfully, many think a TE to show equity, or profits...and miss just how effective a tool it is with the trade list...or to show how good one understood the system as a 'forward test of knowledge'.

Why is it a challenge to post 1 day, or 1 week, or 1 month period?
And then let the picture/data help doing the explanation.
It could be a huge boost toward learning what is offered here.

Happy weekend!
there is always, always another trade!!
  • #2,620
  • Mar 24, 2019 9:49pm Mar 24, 2019 9:49pm
Quoting profitfarmer
{quote} A TE has a lot more than %gained/lost. The max DD, the trade duration, biggest gain/loss, lot size, the time log that help you plot each trade on your own chart to understand better, etc. Sometimes a picture can tell 1000 words, indeed. It give a fast summary what to expect the least. As an experienced trader I am sure you understand that. I would bet you would agree that if you go to the ''''ding systems' section, min. 50% of the time just reading the rules would give you an idea if the system viable, and 90% of time looking at some examples...
agree. TE gives important insights into someone's trading results. George said he can't explain his trading with "TYPING", ok fine, then do a TE of a 100 trades and let the results do the talking. Explanation is a lot easier with actual results that you can plot on the chart like PF said.

the thing is, sitting with someone and watchign them trade live for a few sessions is not enough, unless of course you're sitting with them over 100 trades or more. I think a few good sessions gives off recency bias. I mean, i could post few good livestream trading, and you think i'm a good trader. Further from the truth!

Now, i'm not asking for Geroge to post a TE up, cause I don't really give a shit. This is a fun thread to visit seeing people argue..

i have no life...back to trading
1 trader viewing now