Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD) | Page 459 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Related Instruments

EUR/USD

Similar Threads

Planetary cycles, astrological theory of cycles of the markets 510 replies

Forecast Forex using Numeric Cycles and Astrology Cycles 38 replies

Opinions on "Planetary cycles, astrological theory .. of the markets" 41 replies

Planetary / Astrology indicators 3 replies

Planetary Cycles... Plotting Cycles into the Future 0 replies

Attachments: Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD)
Exit Attachments

Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD)

  • #9,161
  • Apr 29, 2018 9:31am Apr 29, 2018 9:31am
Quoting rudy5
{image}
That's a bummer, I thought the q spectrum will be available with primo
  • #9,162
  • Apr 30, 2018 4:37am Apr 30, 2018 4:37am
Hi guys,

May I ask that why WD Gann related teachings seems to be focusing on commodities? I know nowadays people are adapting it to different market, but articles and readings I see around seems to be focusing on said commodities.

Are there any specific reasons?
  • #9,163
  • Apr 30, 2018 10:50am Apr 30, 2018 10:50am
Quoting Blu3D4rren
Hi guys, May I ask that why WD Gann related teachings seems to be focusing on commodities? I know nowadays people are adapting it to different market, but articles and readings I see around seems to be focusing on said commodities. Are there any specific reasons?
Well, I'm not expert of Gann, but the main reason is that commodities are strictly linked to natural cycles
Currencies are not, for example.
  • #9,164
  • Apr 30, 2018 11:05am Apr 30, 2018 11:05am
Hello all,
I'm into astrology since early 90s, but not good at using it for trading.

Jnevins I'm really impressed by your research.
One question: when I try to find planetary cycles suitable to trade, I focus on a restricted number of events. Or better: the same astro events, forever.
What surprises me, instead, is that every week, in your forecast, you use always different ones. Yet they work.
E.g. this week you write:
"The green line is Mars-Saturn phase 7h and the brown line is Saturn-Saturn, phase, 3h"

Last week: " The light green line is Sun-Sun, Geo, 4h.
The red line is Uranus alone, 6h, phase."

How possible? Shouldn't we expect that the same astro events affects price in rising or decreasing?
  • #9,165
  • May 1, 2018 4:30am May 1, 2018 4:30am
Jerry,

last week you used Sun and Uranus. This week its different. Are you using the composite astro expert to find relevant and recent cycles or are you doing the changes manually based on your own knowledge?

edit: haha just realized I have a similar question as the last guy
  • #9,166
  • May 1, 2018 9:24pm May 1, 2018 9:24pm
Quoting jack-fx
Hello all, I'm into astrology since early 90s, but not good at using it for trading. Jnevins I'm really impressed by your research. One question: when I try to find planetary cycles suitable to trade, I focus on a restricted number of events. Or better: the same astro events, forever. What surprises me, instead, is that every week, in your forecast, you use always different ones. Yet they work. E.g. this week you write: "The green line is Mars-Saturn phase 7h and the brown line is Saturn-Saturn, phase, 3h" Last week: " The light green line...
Hi Jack-fx,

Thanks for the kind words. As I searched for suitable cycles to apply each week, I found that a good cycle broke down and didn't work in the following week... As I searched for reasons that might happen, I started to develop a theory of a kind of hierarchy of what works and what doesn't (backed up by much back testing). I found, for instance, that if the Moon crossed a planet during the trading week, the projection line seemed to get disturbed and became inaccurate. Conjunctions, squares and oppositions also caused a disturbance. When I post a new line for the week, I look for planets "in the clear", free of those disturbances. Lately I have been also searching for the holy grail of astro forecasting, why an inversion might occur... I am still trying to find a consistent reason... One phenomenon I did observe is that as the sun entered a new house, (the 21st and 22nd each month) That an inversion of another wise stable cycle occurred. That isn't the only time however. So far this week, I have seen an inversion occurring from the prediction in post 9155 . The chart below shows the exact setup, but inverted. I don't know why this occurred this week. Mars is joining Saturn in Capricorn this week... and Saturn is also exalted in Capricorn... hence an emphasis on Saturn this week. No other complications as listed above are present. Saturn is in retrograde right now... An area I want to look at is could a retrograde contribute to or cause an inversion?

As you can see, there is nothing easy or automatic about this area of inquiry!
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Capture.JPG Size: 99 KB
  • #9,167
  • May 1, 2018 9:26pm May 1, 2018 9:26pm
Quoting rudy5
Jerry, last week you used Sun and Uranus. This week its different. Are you using the composite astro expert to find relevant and recent cycles or are you doing the changes manually based on your own knowledge? edit: haha just realized I have a similar question as the last guy

Hi Rudy,

Right... see my answer above....
  • #9,168
  • May 1, 2018 9:32pm May 1, 2018 9:32pm
Quoting Blu3D4rren
Hi guys, May I ask that why WD Gann related teachings seems to be focusing on commodities? I know nowadays people are adapting it to different market, but articles and readings I see around seems to be focusing on said commodities. Are there any specific reasons?

Gann also worked with stock trading... Here are excerpts from an Investopedia article...

W.D. Gann was born in 1878 in Lufkin, Texas, the first of 11 children in an impoverished cotton-farming family. He neither graduated from grammar school nor attended high school as he was needed at home to work on the farm. His education mainly came from the Bible (he was raised a Baptist), which he used to learn to read, and in the cotton warehouses, where he learned about commodities trading. Gann started his career working at a brokerage firm in Texarkana and attending business school at night.

One of the strongest pieces of evidence bolstering Gann’s reputation as a master trader hails from a 1909 Ticker and Investment Digest article by Richard D. Wyckoff, a well-respected figure on Wall Street at the time. The article describes Gann’s performance recorded by an independent observer: “During the month of October, 1909, in twenty-five market days, W D Gann made, in the presence of our representative, two hundred and eighty-six transactions in various stocks, on both the long and short side of the market. Two hundred and sixty-four of these transactions resulted in profits; twenty-two in losses. The capital with which he operated was doubled ten times, so that at the end of the month he had one thousand percent of his original margin.”

Read more: The Mysterious Life of Trading Legend W.D. Gann | Investopedia https://www.investopedia.com/article...#ixzz5EJ8pBURU
  • #9,169
  • May 1, 2018 10:27pm May 1, 2018 10:27pm
Euro M5 futures
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Screenshot1.png Size: 249 KB
  • #9,170
  • May 1, 2018 10:41pm May 1, 2018 10:41pm
Quoting rudy5
Euro M5 futures {image}
You say that a negative 5.7% correlation is the best you can get...

I have 92.5% and 89.8% on my inverted curves.... 30 min data, 10,000 bars EDT.... But it is high as it is on the bars generated since the market open.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Capture.JPG Size: 232 KB
  • #9,171
  • May 1, 2018 11:38pm May 1, 2018 11:38pm
Quoting jnevins
{quote}As you can see, there is nothing easy or automatic about this area of inquiry! {image}
Indeed. I had a feeling I was being naive thinking I could run all the experts and find something.


Some noticeable differences on the tests which were run by the composite astro expert compared to what you are showing:

 

  1. The number of bars in my test category is almost as many as you have total
  2. All the options are looking at Last Cycles whereas you have All Bars selected

Here is EUR m15 730 days 47,239 bars.

Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Screenshot1.png Size: 535 KB
  • #9,172
  • May 1, 2018 11:46pm May 1, 2018 11:46pm
Quoting jnevins
{quote} Hi Jack-fx, Thanks for the kind words. As I searched for suitable cycles to apply each week, I found that a good cycle broke down and didn't work in the following week... As I searched for reasons that might happen, I started to develop a theory of a kind of hierarchy of what works and what doesn't (backed up by much back testing). I found, for instance, that if the Moon crossed a planet during the trading week, the projection line seemed to get disturbed and became inaccurate. Conjunctions, squares and oppositions also caused a disturbance....
how to use these system? can you teach me..?
  • #9,173
  • May 2, 2018 12:18am May 2, 2018 12:18am
Quoting jnevins
{quote} Gann also worked with stock trading... Here are excerpts from an Investopedia article... W.D. Gann was born in 1878 in Lufkin, Texas, the first of 11 children in an impoverished cotton-farming family. He neither graduated from grammar school nor attended high school as he was needed at home to work on the farm. His education mainly came from the Bible (he was raised a Baptist), which he used to learn to read, and in the cotton warehouses, where he learned about commodities...


Hey jnevis, thanks for the reply.
I came across this article too.
My knowledge about this type of trading is shallower than skin deep, it's just that I have been seeing here and there people quoting/citing along the lines of "...who and who said soybean has always been deem related if looking at the time cycle...", "...bitcoin is extremely sensitive to mars cycle..." and so on.

I have started to make a book list and acquired related books on this type of trading just to get a better idea what is this about. May be it's already explained by the books? I don't know because I'm yet to start reading related books.

Then I came across this thread and think may be practitioners here can shed some light on this.
  • #9,174
  • Edited 3:08am May 2, 2018 2:52am | Edited 3:08am
Quoting Blu3D4rren
Hi guys, May I ask that why WD Gann related teachings seems to be focusing on commodities? I know nowadays people are adapting it to different market, but articles and readings I see around seems to be focusing on said commodities. Are there any specific reasons?
Before asking undocumented questions - you should do some homework - for example by using Google or similar

you will find some books from Gann as

- Stock Market Forecasting Courses
- Wall street stock Selelector
- New Stock Trend Detetector
-
  • #9,175
  • May 2, 2018 9:26am May 2, 2018 9:26am
Quoting rudy5
{quote} Indeed. I had a feeling I was being naive thinking I could run all the experts and find something. Some noticeable differences on the tests which were run by the composite astro expert compared to what you are showing: The number of bars in my test category is almost as many as you have total All the options are looking at Last Cycles whereas you have All Bars selected Here is EUR m15 730 days 47,239 bars. {image}

Given enough study, you will find something. On the chart you posted, I noticed that the Sun-Merc 1h helio curve forecast the PA for this week very well... but notice the prior week... not so well... why?

My hope is that more eyes and brains looking for answers, and working together can shed more light.
  • #9,176
  • May 2, 2018 9:28am May 2, 2018 9:28am
Quoting Blu3D4rren
{quote} Hey jnevis, thanks for the reply. I came across this article too. My knowledge about this type of trading is shallower than skin deep, it's just that I have been seeing here and there people quoting/citing along the lines of "...who and who said soybean has always been deem related if looking at the time cycle...", "...bitcoin is extremely sensitive to mars cycle..." and so on. I have started to make a book list and acquired related books on this type of trading just to get a better idea what is this about. May be it's already explained...

The Timingsolution.com site has many informative articles http://timingsolution.com/ Also click the ??? link at the top for more reading material.
  • #9,177
  • May 2, 2018 1:27pm May 2, 2018 1:27pm
Today s Venus opp. Pluto @ 6.26

and Mars square Neptune @ 15.54 ALL HELIO

just produced this magnificent LOW in between in Euro.

Enjoy

  • #9,178
  • May 2, 2018 2:16pm May 2, 2018 2:16pm
Quoting F.g
Today s Venus opp. Pluto @ 6.26 and Mars square Neptune @ 15.54 ALL HELIO just produced this magnificent LOW in between in Euro. Enjoy
does this information help me predict the near future using trading solution?
  • #9,179
  • May 2, 2018 6:09pm May 2, 2018 6:09pm
Mate Toddao ,
you mean Timing Solution...?

NO. No relation . Finally the low was later at the Mars square Neptune HELIO event at 15.54 at 1. 19 37~

Got stoped and reentered long . I am not sure it won't go lower but I tried long here . If it works OK
  • #9,180
  • May 3, 2018 12:50pm May 3, 2018 12:50pm
Quoting parisboy
{quote} Before asking undocumented questions - you should do some homework - for example by using Google or similar you will find some books from Gann as - Stock Market Forecasting Courses - Wall street stock Selelector - New Stock Trend Detetector -

Hi, thanks for your list of recommendations. I will have a look at them.
And yes, I did google, I did make a list of books I plan to read to further understand this approach/school of thought. It's just that I am currently occupied, thought I could throw out some questions here to quench my curiosity.

Perhaps I should refine my searching terms in google.

Not everyone is as bright as you, gentleman.
Anyhow, thanks and cheers.
5 traders viewing now