Ratios & Harmonics: a Different Way to Trade

I have seen Jason and akil's teachings on harmonics but I have understood more from Mr. Pip's videos which simplifies trading...rather than bash the TS you should try and impact others with your vast experience which wins you 200% a month way more than what most hedge funds make annually and if you totally disagree with what is taught here as you stated that you wasted one year on this BS thread...then start your own thread...don't come here saying the thread is a BS thread and yet you continue to post your charts on the BS thread...if truly it is, you don't need to waste any more time here more than the one year you already wasted

Monocor , lets talk , dont bring your emotion here , if you were so emotion , how to be a trader

Mr.Pip way work , he himself proved it + others who has been also successful

we all here to learn , whether you can be profitable or not , you still learn something , appreciate please

Mr.Pip way work , Jason way work , Akil way work , which one the faster you can fully understand , learn , apply , which way you will choose

so you Choosen Jason and Akil way , glad to heard that you have been profitable

and if you were to post others strategy , please open another thread and send me the link , teach me , guide me , for years , for free, then give your conclude here again.

i understand your frustration that cant be profitable when others can , but please do it the appropriate way , post your question here ,post your chart here , we would like to help.

Mr..Pip himself has used 8years of unprofitable time to continuous refine this skill until today.

can i know how long you have been trading ? i myself have been trading for 6years + and not successful yet

Edit : thanks for introducing another successful strategy , please send me the link for more info , i would like to learn any way that can be profitable.

I could have drawn like in the shown chart. The box shows my TP area (minimum- maximum). I expected a NSL and at best a move like the yellow line.
Hope you understand what I mean.

Do you remember the USDJPY WEEKLY, and my expectation last week?
My trade on demo account is 74 pips up now but i have changed my expectation for the next weeks, with another spike of price down before the major bullish movement. Compare the two chart. I am not going to exit the trade ,I will keep it as is with my SL at same location and report the result next week again.

Yes I got it now, thanks!

Yeah, you can trade that strategy for la low cost of $4k in one of the sites, Thats so niceeee, to be the perfect trader like you, I have to only invest 4k in one site and 300 on the other... Hahahahaha, You are crazy man....How much money they pay you or how much % they discount you to make this bs???

I can see your comments from march 2018 and you trading wedges and flags all over the place. you're jumping strategy to strategy like crazy.
GTFOH

hahahah you make my morning jaja!!

Dear Friend, pls share your trade plan and trades. We are all Traders here. I’m sure it’ll be interesting to see what you are doing right.

Just a thought. 200% a month sound like you had to take on a lot of risk per trade

Monocor,

You cannot identify a swing or an expectation yet you have studied this thread for a year? This makes all of us laugh, nothing more.

It is obvious that you have been posting on this thread this past week only so you could drop some youtube links.

Lets be very very clear about a few key points:

1. Mr Pip has zero commercial interest in this thread. All his material is taught in an open-source format and has been for many years.

2. Mr Pip gives credit when credit is due, for example to Scott Carney with respect to advance pattern qualification, and to his own student for a 127Ext trail idea that proved to be efficient.

3. The entire reason for the existence of this thread is to empower aspiring traders with real information for free, and, also make a dent into the sales of "trading educator" who prey on the naive/desperate/lost traders still looking for an edge. These are the exact types selling the trading course you linked too. My guess is their sales are hurting, and you a trying to drum up so leads. Shame on you.

4. There are aprox 490,000 members on FF, Mr Pip is number one when it come to transparency: He shares live trades daily on short and longer term orderflow. Anybody who pays attention long enough can do the simple math and see the edge that exists in this method. Moreover, you will also notice that this trader practices what he preaches, and in the trading world, that is more rare than anything!

You picked the wrong thread buddy, sorry. Good luck with your sales, i have a feeling you'll need it.

N.

I usually don't post here but i feel like i have to. I have been following Mr. Pip's system for about 7-8 months and have been seeing very decent results. Link to the results is here (https://www.myfxbook.com/members/arpan366/pps-harmonics/2419112). It is a real account with a reputable broker so there is little chance of manipulation. I have only been using Mr.Pip's system (with a few small modifications) for this account. Trades here have become less as I have moved on to Ninjatrader. My objective is in no way to advertise anything but only to counter the claim that this system does not work. If it does not work for you, please move on to something else but please refrain from slandering Mr Pip whom we all respect and are very grateful to. Thanks.

1st trade this morning +44

YM144

Two trades so far today
+37 +61

Also on a longer term YM1597 trade (presently +104)

Target hit +153 on YM1597

I entered this about a day ago-ish.. It is getting close to my target.. If it pull backs at this D point, then I will close it. However, I will try to pay attention to how my area of interest is being approached. Using a If/Then thinking process.

2nd trade + 72

Well done. I got in about the same time but hit my take profit a bit early. Should have agressively trailed so I only got +61

Looking at the daily.. it seems like there is some possible semi strong confluence just below. If it is approached with some power.. I will be looking for more shorts next week. Time will tell.

It might be time to close this.. and call it a week. It is really reacting to the red level just underneath it.

I'm going to call it a day +251 pips. Happy with that.

+37, +61 +153

Lessons to learn are that I need to be quicker to aggressively trail my take profit (I left money on the table) coming out too quickly on trade 2 and the long term trade.

Good luck to those still trading and have a great weekend.

Adjusted my stop loss. Observing how precisely price hit my S/R level that I have had for about 2 weeks.

Still testing and learning.

You are awesome guys! Great trading ..I managed to get 45 points on NQ today.
I'm noticing lately that I take a trade, most times I manage it well and than I feel drained and just spectate. Kudos to the guys taking 3+ trades.

In order to be fully transparent and fair, could you also tell us how much all of the above people charge to teach someone or for someone to buy their products?

I believe Jason charges $597 for his 'mastery course'? (fact is he also sells other course such as 'podcast domination for $794 and 'Online Business Kickstarter Course' for $397). Is he a web entrepreneur or a full-time trader?

Jason Greystone is the same - offering various courses from 'trading' to 'mentoring' to 'how to start a business'. Same question, is he a full time trader or a web entrepreneur?

The fact is none of the above two have ever come up with anything original themselves. They too are simply re-packaging whatever appeals to them and trying to sell it a a price. The fact that they are not full-time traders also speaks volumes don't you think?

Fact is, there is a huge difference between some who tries to teach what works for them, for free, and someone who charges and doesn't really care if you succeed or fail and have umpteen other enterprises on the go.

Mr Pips has always said, practice, practice, practice, and develop your own rules and your own way. This is the true way forward for any endeavor in life.

Messrs Stapleton and Greystone, on the other hand make you believe you just have to buy their course and soon you'll be rich and a trading legend.

If you truly believe you have a more better way of teaching a trading system, may I suggest you set up your own thread. I am always looking to learn and expand my skills and I look forward to learning from you :-)

Please do not take this as a personal attack - I think you are trying to compare apples and oranges, and your verbal attack was very un-called for.