So I have just had this chat with FTMO help:
Hello, welcome to FTMO. How can I help you?
12:34
Hi, I have traded a free trial demo, before I buy challenges can someone check that my style of trading will be acceptable to FTMO?
Mohammed Taleb
12:35
Once you finish your trading period we will send you a Trading Analysis of your account.
12:36
What will that do?
I want to know that if I buy a challenge and trade just Oil at $250/tick whether you will pay me out after 14 days or not
Mohammed Taleb
12:37
Your trading style is completely up to you. We have no reasons for limiting or restricting your trading strategy, whether it’s discretionary trading, hedging, algorithmic trading, EAs, etc. As long as your trading is legitimate, conforms to the real market conditions and we can replicate your trades on our live corporate accounts, there is no limitation to your trading style or strategy.
12:38
How would I know if you can replicate my trades on your live corporate accounts?
Thats not my problem is it?
Mohammed Taleb
12:38
It's not your problem correct.
12:39
Your problem is to have a good risk management and a consistent strategy.
As I told you, As long as your trading is legitimate, conforms to the real market conditions and we can replicate your trades on our live corporate accounts, there is no limitation to your trading style or strategy.
12:41
But how do I know if you can replicat emy trades oe not?
12:42
replicate* my* trades*
Mohammed Taleb
12:42
We use our own method to do so, I can't tell you that information because I don't have it.
12:42
Have a look at the link I sent to my trial demo just. Can you replicate those trades?
12:43
you can see, size, duration etc etc
Mohammed Taleb
12:43
I can't give you a response C*****e. If you are using a legit strategy with good risk management, then there is nothing to worry about.
12:43
what do you mean by a "legit strategy"? It is my own strategy trading USOil at $250/tick
Mohammed Taleb
12:44
Depends on your SL
If your SL for example is 4% of the account.
12:44
the SL is 12 ticks
Mohammed Taleb
12:44
Then will not be legit.
12:44
its 3%
12:45
Ok so please can you tell me what the stop losses need to be then? (As it doesn't mention this anywhere on your website)
Mohammed Taleb
12:46
What I mean by this is that your risk management must be good, that is, we are not going to force you to use SL but if we see that you over-operate with many lots without stopping as a "gambling" mode, that could be considered trading not allowed. .
12:46
Do the maximum risk per trade vary from instrument to instrument or is that just on Oil?
Mohammed Taleb
12:46
For Normal type accounts we recommend a maximum of 1% for each operation, your account being Aggressive type would then be equivalent to 2% per trade.
12:47
Apply for everything I'm just giving you a recomendation in order to don't have any problems.
https://ftmo.com/en/faq/which-instru...llowed-to-use/
Please read the article if my explanation is not good enough.
12:48
It seems very ambiguous to me, I thought the drawdown rules were 10%/day and a maximum of 20% overall? No one mentioned that the risk has to be 1-2% of the account balance before.
Mohammed Taleb
12:48
I'm telling you that is a recommendation from my part.
And that all I can say.
Check the link If you want more info about this.
12:51
Ok I appreciate that, another question I have is. If I trade through the challenge and verification period and then the first 14 days and then ask for a profit share (and its a big one hopefully) I understand that FTMO have to analyse the account at that stage. Is that correct? If so what are they looking at as all my hard work has been done by that stage? I am particularly concerned about getting to the profit split stage and being accused of duplicating strategies or too many accounts on your system trading the same strategy. If this happens when do FTMO tell me this?
Mohammed Taleb
12:52
Yes, we always review your results on all the phases and also on FTMO Account once you request the Profit Split. Our team of analysts looks at things like only taking advantage of GAPS, taking advantage of some Delay on the server or some kind of trading that takes advantage of an error to benefit. PLease don't worry I already told you If you strategy is a normal one with your regular analisis, there is nothing to worry about.
12:54
Oh ok, what about if someone else has accounts at FTMO and my trading strategy looks very similar to his. Doubtful as my strategy is my own creation. But say there is, what happens then?
Mohammed Taleb
12:54
That's normal, nothing happens, how many traders do you think have similar strategies? What we are going to monitor is if the strategy is exactly the same.
12:55
Is that clear?
12:56
Was there anything else I could help you with?
12:57
Ok this all sounds encouraging. Once I have completed the free trial would it be possible for someone to review that account and tell me if the trading is acceptable BEFORE I buy 2x$100k accounts at a cost of £2k?
Mohammed Taleb
12:57
Yes, we will send you the review once the trading period of the Free Trial ends.
12:58
And would that review tell me that if I traded in the same way on real accounts then I wouldn't have any problem being paid out? No matter the amounts?
Mohammed Taleb
12:58
Yes, If there is something wrong we will tell you no worries.
12:59
So your advice is trade the free trial to the end and see what the review says and if that's ok then go for a proper challenge knowing that if I trade in the same way then payout will not be a problem?
Mohammed Taleb
13:00
You already passed the objetives just don't use it until the period ends or you can keep practising if you want. And again check https://ftmo.com/en/faq/which-instru...llowed-to-use/ if you have more doubts about your trading strategy I can't tell you more about it.
13:00
Please can you email me this chat transcript.
Mohammed Taleb
13:01
The transcript will be available once we end the chat. Please check the article and https://ftmo.com/en/gambling-is-not-...to-make-money/ that one as well.
Was ther anything else I could help you with?
13:01
thats all thankyou
Mohammed Taleb
13:01
You're welcome, should you have any other questions please contact us again. Have a wonderful weekend!
13:02
closed the chat
So there was mention that taking 4% risk per trade was too much and could be considered as gambling. My initial thoughts were to take 3% risk per trade or probably less. It seems that the review of my free trial will tell me all, I very much doubt that as I've passed it already so could just stop now and I'm not sure what they can gain from looking at just 7 trades!!??
Looking back it seems that TraderOtakar who is the FTMO representative tends to reply on Fridays, so maybe he can comment on if FTMO can "replicate your trades on our live corporate accounts" or advise on anything else I have mentioned.
Hello, welcome to FTMO. How can I help you?
12:34
Hi, I have traded a free trial demo, before I buy challenges can someone check that my style of trading will be acceptable to FTMO?
Mohammed Taleb
12:35
Once you finish your trading period we will send you a Trading Analysis of your account.
12:36
What will that do?
I want to know that if I buy a challenge and trade just Oil at $250/tick whether you will pay me out after 14 days or not
Mohammed Taleb
12:37
Your trading style is completely up to you. We have no reasons for limiting or restricting your trading strategy, whether it’s discretionary trading, hedging, algorithmic trading, EAs, etc. As long as your trading is legitimate, conforms to the real market conditions and we can replicate your trades on our live corporate accounts, there is no limitation to your trading style or strategy.
12:38
How would I know if you can replicate my trades on your live corporate accounts?
Thats not my problem is it?
Mohammed Taleb
12:38
It's not your problem correct.
12:39
Your problem is to have a good risk management and a consistent strategy.
As I told you, As long as your trading is legitimate, conforms to the real market conditions and we can replicate your trades on our live corporate accounts, there is no limitation to your trading style or strategy.
12:41
But how do I know if you can replicat emy trades oe not?
12:42
replicate* my* trades*
Mohammed Taleb
12:42
We use our own method to do so, I can't tell you that information because I don't have it.
12:42
Have a look at the link I sent to my trial demo just. Can you replicate those trades?
12:43
you can see, size, duration etc etc
Mohammed Taleb
12:43
I can't give you a response C*****e. If you are using a legit strategy with good risk management, then there is nothing to worry about.
12:43
what do you mean by a "legit strategy"? It is my own strategy trading USOil at $250/tick
Mohammed Taleb
12:44
Depends on your SL
If your SL for example is 4% of the account.
12:44
the SL is 12 ticks
Mohammed Taleb
12:44
Then will not be legit.
12:44
its 3%
12:45
Ok so please can you tell me what the stop losses need to be then? (As it doesn't mention this anywhere on your website)
Mohammed Taleb
12:46
What I mean by this is that your risk management must be good, that is, we are not going to force you to use SL but if we see that you over-operate with many lots without stopping as a "gambling" mode, that could be considered trading not allowed. .
12:46
Do the maximum risk per trade vary from instrument to instrument or is that just on Oil?
Mohammed Taleb
12:46
For Normal type accounts we recommend a maximum of 1% for each operation, your account being Aggressive type would then be equivalent to 2% per trade.
12:47
Apply for everything I'm just giving you a recomendation in order to don't have any problems.
https://ftmo.com/en/faq/which-instru...llowed-to-use/
Please read the article if my explanation is not good enough.
12:48
It seems very ambiguous to me, I thought the drawdown rules were 10%/day and a maximum of 20% overall? No one mentioned that the risk has to be 1-2% of the account balance before.
Mohammed Taleb
12:48
I'm telling you that is a recommendation from my part.
And that all I can say.
Check the link If you want more info about this.
12:51
Ok I appreciate that, another question I have is. If I trade through the challenge and verification period and then the first 14 days and then ask for a profit share (and its a big one hopefully) I understand that FTMO have to analyse the account at that stage. Is that correct? If so what are they looking at as all my hard work has been done by that stage? I am particularly concerned about getting to the profit split stage and being accused of duplicating strategies or too many accounts on your system trading the same strategy. If this happens when do FTMO tell me this?
Mohammed Taleb
12:52
Yes, we always review your results on all the phases and also on FTMO Account once you request the Profit Split. Our team of analysts looks at things like only taking advantage of GAPS, taking advantage of some Delay on the server or some kind of trading that takes advantage of an error to benefit. PLease don't worry I already told you If you strategy is a normal one with your regular analisis, there is nothing to worry about.
12:54
Oh ok, what about if someone else has accounts at FTMO and my trading strategy looks very similar to his. Doubtful as my strategy is my own creation. But say there is, what happens then?
Mohammed Taleb
12:54
That's normal, nothing happens, how many traders do you think have similar strategies? What we are going to monitor is if the strategy is exactly the same.
12:55
Is that clear?
12:56
Was there anything else I could help you with?
12:57
Ok this all sounds encouraging. Once I have completed the free trial would it be possible for someone to review that account and tell me if the trading is acceptable BEFORE I buy 2x$100k accounts at a cost of £2k?
Mohammed Taleb
12:57
Yes, we will send you the review once the trading period of the Free Trial ends.
12:58
And would that review tell me that if I traded in the same way on real accounts then I wouldn't have any problem being paid out? No matter the amounts?
Mohammed Taleb
12:58
Yes, If there is something wrong we will tell you no worries.
12:59
So your advice is trade the free trial to the end and see what the review says and if that's ok then go for a proper challenge knowing that if I trade in the same way then payout will not be a problem?
Mohammed Taleb
13:00
You already passed the objetives just don't use it until the period ends or you can keep practising if you want. And again check https://ftmo.com/en/faq/which-instru...llowed-to-use/ if you have more doubts about your trading strategy I can't tell you more about it.
13:00
Please can you email me this chat transcript.
Mohammed Taleb
13:01
The transcript will be available once we end the chat. Please check the article and https://ftmo.com/en/gambling-is-not-...to-make-money/ that one as well.
Was ther anything else I could help you with?
13:01
thats all thankyou
Mohammed Taleb
13:01
You're welcome, should you have any other questions please contact us again. Have a wonderful weekend!
13:02
closed the chat
So there was mention that taking 4% risk per trade was too much and could be considered as gambling. My initial thoughts were to take 3% risk per trade or probably less. It seems that the review of my free trial will tell me all, I very much doubt that as I've passed it already so could just stop now and I'm not sure what they can gain from looking at just 7 trades!!??
Looking back it seems that TraderOtakar who is the FTMO representative tends to reply on Fridays, so maybe he can comment on if FTMO can "replicate your trades on our live corporate accounts" or advise on anything else I have mentioned.