i checked historical data according to your rules. Great approach you did. I am just little worried about middle line (slight risky trades for me).
Anyway thank you for detail description! :-)
the mid band play and the mild strike DT/DB play are the riskier than the other two for sure...
but.. they also pay off the best once they decide to run.. so in the long run the RR is in your favor only if one can bear with the small set back (big part of trading this little thing).. and not to mention that this type of trades keeps you in the game constantly and leads to sharpness.. it does more for mental aspects than just pips and that is key in trading.
with me in here.. you will get a lot of mental toughness stuff.. i drop live knowledge here and there that i know is the breaker... it has done for me.. and it has done for the people who have worked with me in the past