No one has the magic key believe it or not that allows them to win on every trade, and I wonder whether that is what you are expecting?
If you look at SPs method for example, it allows for at least 60% losing trades (of course not that he'd be happy with that I'm sure), but the point is he knows he won't win every trade but his winners should outweigh his losers in the long run.
Similarly, he has his own method of determining a trade entry which he has attempted to outline on many occasions. Here, the point is that in your trying to replicate his method has led to your confusion, because it is impossible to be inside someone elses mind.
I have noticed over the years that the single biggest problem for the majority of traders is their indecision and that is without a shadow of doubt caused by confusion, either from others or themselves.
This should of course lead to some obvious conclusions to you. My immediate observation, when looking at your chart is that it is too busy. An oscillator for example is an oscillator....I mean how many sockets are needed to change a spark plug for example... that's right, just the one, and it is my opinion that you have too much going on in your chart, and it is therefore no wonder that you have got yourself confused.
Based upon what I've said. you know what you ought to be doing to reduce the confusion....that would be a good starting point imo. I'm sure SP being the kind of bloke that he is, would be more than happy to help you with some of those points.
1