vsa with Malcolm

Quoting Vcv13

Disliked

{image} bars A & B are stopping volume & market was knocked sideways, I did see (even in real time) bar C as stopping volume (that's me ) the first ND & upthrust was a perfect wyckoff entry as it was a retest, but this was not a VSA entry coz no confirmation. When it comes to enter a trade VSA has an edge over wyckoff, I like Gavin's "let the market come to you" method. Any comments anyone why you would/would not enter short on that ND? the trend was still down.

Ignored

Quoting LuckyMind

Disliked

Placed pen. We see how price break high vol bar and then show us ND Edit: close cuz of scary upbar at EU {image}

Ignored

Quoting pres78

Disliked

{quote} I am in a long on UJ also. I don't normally start trading until later in Jan but since I'm on vacation I figured I'd trade a bit today. Zone, break high, test 50% with an ugly NS (so I waited) and then we got a lovely 2BR into the high so I entered at market on the next bar. 6 pip SL, getting ready to fire up my trailing EA. {image}

Ignored

Quoting pres78

Disliked

{quote} I am in a long on UJ also. I don't normally start trading until later in Jan but since I'm on vacation I figured I'd trade a bit today. Zone, break high, test 50% with an ugly NS (so I waited) and then we got a lovely 2BR into the high so I entered at market on the next bar. 6 pip SL, getting ready to fire up my trailing EA. {image}

Ignored

Quoting LuckyMind

Disliked

I closed UJ at 1:0.5 cuz of some SOW (see chart). Start to understand trigger numbers/ zones a bit, but got exciting question: When we see H1 bar with vol bigger, than at LO H1 bar what should we do? Draw only new zone and delete LO, retain LO or draw both? For me is logical to redraw and delete lower vol H1 zone, but looking at attached chart i think it's not best decision. Otherwise if i will draw both zones + yesterdays zone - it will be too many lines at chart, that can confuse. I would be grateful for the help {image}...

Ignored

Quoting Vcv13

Disliked

{image} bars A & B are stopping volume & market was knocked sideways, I did see (even in real time) bar C as stopping volume (that's me ) the first ND & upthrust was a perfect wyckoff entry as it was a retest, but this was not a VSA entry coz no confirmation. When it comes to enter a trade VSA has an edge over wyckoff, I like Gavin's "let the market come to you" method. Any comments anyone why you would/would not enter short on that ND? the trend was still down.

Ignored

Quoting odines

Disliked

{quote} Im taking a read at this topic... take a look at this Pres's reply #20,189, he was talking about your question I think. This post is from some years ago, so he may have changed something, anyway thats the post: http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...1760&page=1010

Ignored

Quoting odines

Disliked

interesting background at 1/HR TF coming on USD/CHF IMHO.. higher TF 4 hour/daily still looks a bit weak though, needs confirmation in my opinion chart says all, any comments? {image}

Ignored

Quoting LuckyMind

Disliked

{quote} My broker show me this {image}

Ignored

Quoting odines

Disliked

{quote} ye different feeds a bit but I would have the same conclusion.. the bar that i have marked as "squat" is not technically a squat at your chart since it has decreasing volume, however still a narrow candle on high volume

Ignored

Quoting LuckyMind

Disliked

{quote} Anyway, i think, i would expect prive close above or below this lvls {image}

Ignored

Quoting ramzam

Disliked

how you do draw this lines at what base {image}

Ignored