Seeking explanation for code anomaly

There is an indicator that can be found at this post. the version has 58 errors and 4 warnings when compiled. Other clean versions exist. The anomaly is that a trade r called Robinho has been posting winning results using the code with the errors while others have struggled with the cleaned up versions. So what about the code with errors and warnings is good versus the cleaned up code?


http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...68#post8103468

VS.


http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...63#post8258163

TYIA for all answers

The main issue appears to be that the cleaned up code version flips around too much changing the top strong and bottom weakest currency while the error version keeps the top and bottom in place more steadily longer. Both are being set to daily timeframe, yet there are clear discrepancies when they are side by side and the market is moving. .

It would be great to have clean code that is more effective for actual profits. help appreciated.

after all whats more important, the code being right or the profits being right?