Can we sell a set of studies we wrote that work?

I don't want to appear like I am being deliberately opposite in here, I came to ask for help/guidance. We have been using FF and its calendar for years and it was only recently that I read a question in the forum that asked if one can make a living from forex. I replied as I know several men who do.

This lead to a discussion in the group about the system and it's potential and here I am.

I have taken a screen grab of our top pairs, and how the system has worked in the time I have been here trying to get help in the last few hours. You may assess it against your own sanity but the system HAS shown CLEAR entries (Not one single failure) as follows: (This while I have been trying to convince phantom online opponents)
EURAUD +29 and +29
GPBAUD +13 and +39
EURNZD +67
GBPNZD +76 (Note how beautifully it reacted to the 75% ADR study I chose to leave on to illustrate accuracy)

Thats 223 pips in the time I have been here, without a single failure. At a 20pip Take profit level it has generated 5 x 20 or 100 pips. Again.



Any guidance on how to proceed invited.

HP

Why? Mr Dittman will probably be offended by your comment. That is the risk you take when you go down the road of trying to profit from people. Why do you consider your system superior to those of Mr Dittmans? Where's your proof?

This is a place where many, through the generosity of their own heart, readily help others by sharing their skills and experience and ask for nothing in return, maybe just a thank you. You see, they probably make enough money of their own. They are genuine.

I have never met nor assessed Mr Dittman's systems so I am unable to compare. I did interpret YOUR message as insulting.

This isn't the cure for cancer, it is a working system with a serious commercial driver at its core. I came here to explore potential, not be questioned as to my (or the teams) philanthropy.

Either way, we will leave here with some ideas on how to share it, or we won't. Quite why a new system needs to be treated like one needs a tin-foil cap to open is astounding. I would have thought even the most disingenuous raving lunatic would be welcomed by anyone willing to learn/listen. Perhaps I was mistaken.

HP

I don't understand what you are trying to do here. Are you sharing or not? Are you bragging but without proof? Are you asking us to be guinea pigs to evaluate your system so you can go and sell it? Or are you asking for marketing advice?

1) I accept this may have been posted under completely the wrong thread and for this I have apologised. The discussion is the merit/demerit of turning a good few years hard work by a team of motivated, intelligent people into a shrink-wrapped box.

2) It works for all the team members.

3) It requires a basic knowledge of Guppy and Retracement but this can be learnt quite easily.

4) We are some distance from a product in a box. We may never have a product in a box.

5) What suggestions if any are there for a team of successful forex traders, to share their system with the world in the optimal way.

6) If I knew the answers to all of the above, I certainly wouldn't be inviting criticism from random strangers.

I hope this makes it clear. I have a handful of sensible, genuine responses and I believe as such it is taking shape. If you want to debate the moral conscience of selling our hard work for profit, you have my answer in my first post.

HP

Ha ha ha, I laughed. I haven't tried to sell anyone anything. I accept you will not be forming part of our crack squad.

G'day.

HP

In a further step since my first enquiry this morning, if there is anyone who is willing to be a 'tester' (basically we'll use you as a test case) to establish the best method to present and execute the system.


You will need to forgive that we are in a setting up phase and not a commercial entity.

Please message me directly if you are interested. You should be proficient in eSignal and have a working knowledge of the Guppy system. While this is not essential, it will save us a little time not having to do any training.

HP

If you are trying to sell something then no one will be interested without proof. By that I mean verified accounts posted on myfxbook or a trade explorer. But then if you can prove it, then why on earth would you want to put yourself at the mercy of potential disgruntled customers. With proof it would be so easy just to get others to follow your account and if you or your system is that good then the sky is your limit and you could be raking in tens of thousands a month - a lot more than trying to flog some system for which you have no proof works. And a lot less aggro.

So until you can come up with proof, we shall assume it is no better than snake oil.

Thanks jen101, again your advice on how to proceed is graciously accepted. We have asked for help on how to get it out there, not a monologue on how cross you are that you can't access my bank account.

This was completely the wrong forum to ask. It is currently working on eSignal and this is 99% an MT4 environment.
If I had asked for help on how to make a cake because I have a fantastic recipe no doubt you would rant on about free samples in every supermarket.

Thanks. We already do 'rake in' tens of thousands per month. Though no doubt you'll object. I have shown what we are doing to a handful of people who have troubled to ask, along with offering them the system for free. So far 10/10 have agreed it would be worth paying for and have ALL volunteered to be test cases if we proceed, but then I guess until you get to interview them under oath you'll simply come up with something else to whine about. We didn't set this up to link into an explorer or an fxbook and as of right now you have a better chance of impregnating me by pineapple than you do of getting me to dry-run on a phantom system.

In truth this place is a den of bitter, malicious vipers and comments like yours have completely turned us from the idea. We have tried to sell nothing yet you carry on like your firstborn has been offered in sacrifice. You have been asked for nothing but help. No money. No effort, not even feedback at this point. It's pathetic.

Good luck to you all.

HP

Yes, I don't know if it's the kind of people that are attracted to Forex Factory or what...difficult place to converse...

Images are taken from the post no. 21.

Hi! Hedgepiglet, Thanks for sharing info about the system you have there. I am not gonna put any thing negative but I know every system or indicator has some problems or missing features. You have presented that you had not any wrong signal in your trades. I dont know what timeframe you are using with that FXCM platform. What would you like to say about these?

Regards,

Name your product. Create a PDF file with all the rules and instructions. Create a website with actual pictures of trades, both winning and losing. Determine a price you want for your product and list it. Another way would be to create a skype group and give trade recommendations to those who follow you for a specified time. That way they can see the results for themselves, and determine if they want to join a paid group where you share the indicators, instructions and trade with them.

Just my 2 cents.

Hi QueFx,
The screen grabs are from the 'basic/front end' screen if thats the right term. The simple answer to your question is that the signals are correct, one must however use GMMA rules for entry, I simply wanted to showcase the signals to underline that they arent anomalies.

Further to this we have a 'Zone' we apply within sides of an EMA as well as safe entry rules.

I'd be very happy to go through the additional trade screens if you wish, the idea was to invite ideas at the time (we have since begun a project) by showing that this isnt witchcraft.

Please PM me if you need any more info.