Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Multi time frame Simple MACD system 823 replies

Time Frame Vs Personality, Which to choose as Main Time Frame? Who Are You? 10 replies

Multiple Time Frame Trading: In a divergence, which frame dictates? 6 replies

Time frame and Enter/Exit, Time frame and S/L, T/P relationships. 91 replies

Question on Lower Time Frame Indicators Vs. Longer Time Frame 7 replies

Attachments: Another simple system - Time-Frame 15
Exit Attachments

Another simple system - Time-Frame 15

Quoting afos
NOT U 2

HAhahahaha,..

Its brother, Afos..lol..
Never claimed to be a sister.
Arjun told it many times.

But never faked anything as well.
Ill PM u my skype ID.

Hope that helps.

Ciara
Ideas shape the course of history
Quoting Ciara
HAhahahaha,..

Its brother, Afos..lol..
Never claimed to be a sister.
Arjun told it many times.

But never faked anything as well.
Ill PM u my skype ID.

Hope that helps.

Ciara

hello ciara pls can i have you skype id too so plss not am not a scammer
Quoting orko_555
Post 653 and Post 664!!!!

OK guys, i'm pretty much destructed by these post;

IT MAY SOUND VERY RUDE BUT... THIS IS MY OPINION

1) well, post 653:

[i]Dec 10, 2012 14:45 (5 hr ago)
garrye
Member Member Since Mar 2009
287 Posts

the reason is making money out of newbies,thats why they have been pushing hard for private website,they even placed that phun deck in the thread to make out this free system is being sold on ebay.thats why they have been collecting emails so they can sell the system at a later date .
you know the extra...
Dear Roman,

I totally agree with you brother !

Peace,
dom
I am not here to defend Gibril but I was to be objective.

I was so surprise that the number of people viewing Gibril Trading journal at the same time today are more than 15 people. Very interesting! I usually see 5 at maximum at the sametime. I may be wrong. Where were those people all this while? I think there is more to this.

Anyway, I learnt so much from all the analysis Gibril has been doing both on Master Arjun thread and his journal. It has really help alot of people. Even if it is indeed a fakey has we all confirmed, there is no trade he did not explain well for us to understand. I alway go throuhg my chart to see same and it worked perfectly. It is possible that the chart he posted is from different broker while the statement is from another broker. Remember, Gibril once said he trades 3 different accounts. I am sure there could be 3 - 6 pips difference in executing trade on different platform almost at the same time. Remember, the statement was posted later after he read the rules stated by Arjun.

I went through senior members post and there is no one that matches GIbril' analysis. Let be frank with ourself. He is an asset. He Could answer a question with 5 different post. Even the senior members from Arjun thread visit his Trading journal for references and anlysis. The Journal indeed has help alot of people on the main thread myself inclusive.

The trading journal has served has a motivation for us because I know that all what he had shown us here is quite possible.
There are alot of things he explained on the Trading Journal that was never mention on the main thread. Master Arjun even said it is a most to read. Gibril occassional call himself a copy trader king. We could see how he was able to use Emmanuel Popgun for a good trading opportunity.

I still respect him for his analysis and insight in analysing the chart with simple S/R, FIB, Trendline and Pivot. He could'nt have been done more than this.

So if truely he faked the trades, what are the reasons behind it? Is it to motivate us or what? Is it to cheat us? is it to show Ego? This is the question for him to answer.
What about the fake charity saga? Could it be to motivate people to do the same? I have started thinking of how to start an orhanage home becos of what Arjun, Gibril, Assange etc preaches. To be honest, I have started training my dry cleaner how to trade bcos i see talnet in him. He is discipline and I am not. I am sure you know what I mean.

I am sure alot of people were dreaming to trade the way girbil claimed. I am sure we all know it is possible that way. I remembered when he exposed the way looser sees chart and how big boys try to shake retail trader away from the market. I have not seen anybody that really has any reason to condem his trade apart from this inconsistence between the statement and the chart.

I want to ask folks this questions for clearification.

1. I want anybody to point out any trade he took that did not follow the rules on Master Arjun thread or the LOGIC.
2. I want someone to tell us if GIBRIL has requested for money from him or her before.
3. Has anyone offer Gibril money for trading which he accepted.
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GOOD AND EXCELLENT IS ATTENTION TO DETAILS.
Quoting orko_555
Post 653 and Post 664!!!!

OK guys, i'm pretty much destructed by these post;

IT MAY SOUND VERY RUDE BUT... THIS IS MY OPINION

1) well, post 653:

[i]Dec 10, 2012 14:45 (5 hr ago)
garrye
Member Member Since Mar 2009
287 Posts

the reason is making money out of newbies,thats why they have been pushing hard for private website,they even placed that phun deck in the thread to make out this free system is being sold on ebay.thats why they have been collecting emails so they can sell the system at a later date .
you know the extra secret...
You know what they say...Opinions are like assholes, and everybody has one.
I'm not here to pick a fight, since your post is not about me...it's not my battle.

But I would like to share my opinion (my asshole) with you and those happen to come across this post.

I don't know how long you've been doing this...but if you're been doing this for a long time, and if you're lucky enough to do it full-time, then you end up with a lot of free time during the day...So I read a lot...lots of trading books and posts in forums, and even this thread...

Trading is such a lonely business and it is devastating to most. As you know, it's a zero-sum game...for you to have a position, someone else has to take the opposite side, and vice versa. Unfortunately, only 5-10% of traders are profitable, and the rest are losers...hard earned money and accounts are being wiped out. Honest and hardworking people (sometimes) are pushed to the edge of bankruptcy...these good people are desperate for a solution, or a savior to rescue them (their families) from financial ruin. This is the very reason why there are so many scam artists in this business...these scam artists start out by getting people to trust them before preying on these people's vulnerability. I guess the bottom line is that it's hard (impossible) to scam people if they think you're a non-caring, non-expert, ignorant asshole.

So in the end, just be skeptical...read a lot, always be alert to learn, to pick up the bits and pieces of information here and there that might be of use to you...ignore the rest, and remember to speak up when you sense something's wrong...then you'll be okay.

Stay sharp and trade well!
Quoting eai.reg
Hi Roman. Sorry for late answer. There were a couple of pins befor on 800ema/RN. I waited price to broke 800ema and shorted. stop above 10ema.
Also I was expecting price to broke daily s/r area and go at least to previous day low/ Daily 10ema. and actually it did but without me. Maybe stop was to small for that pair
Looks like a beautiful minimalistic painting.Thanks you gave me ideas.http://www.forexfactory.com/attachme...0&d=1355140801
In trading, you have to be defensive and aggressive at the same time
Two trades for me today. Both made on H1 timeframe.
first e/u with established support and confirmed entry. exited in +8 pips, too many obsticles above.

second is e/aud , same trade, same reason as e/u. TP at H4 10ema, +20 pips
Attached Images (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: Greenshot_2012-12-10_13-02-45EUH1.png Size: 25 KB Click to Enlarge Name: Greenshot_2012-12-10_13-11-53EUHIST.png Size: 2 KB Click to Enlarge Name: Greenshot_2012-12-10_13-05-31EAH1.png Size: 25 KB Click to Enlarge Name: Greenshot_2012-12-10_13-10-06EAHIST.png Size: 2 KB
If you're going through hell, keep going. Winston Churchill
Quoting ejiexe
I am not here to defend Gibril but I was to be objective.

I was so surprise that the number of people viewing Gibril Trading journal at the same time today are more than 15 people. Very interesting! I usually see 5 at maximum at the sametime. I may be wrong. Where were those people all this while? I think there is more to this.

I went through senior members post and there is no one that matches GIbril' analysis. Let be frank with ourself. He is an asset. He Could answer a question with 5 different post. Even the senior members from...

Hi mate...,

The whole idea behind Arjun's thread is honesty and transparency.

One lie reflects the whole character.

Im not sure about your experience but there is a MASSIVE difference between an analyst and a TRADER. They are not even close.

The trades well, have you looked closely at them? I dont need to as i can spot them straight away, but put some of the trades in a simulator (a friend did as he was breaking his head about perfect entries and exits).

You think its only about the charts? Careful consideration was taken before posting all this info. You think other things were not looked into? You think he is from Muscat?

Remember the statement 'All is one, one is all'!!! (or something like that)

He maybe trading multiple accounts - no idea, does he trade at all? Like i said there is one thing trading and another thing presenting charts. I can see this with experience. False hopes to new traders is not a good thing at all, this is real money.

I do not wish to keep posting such items (even look at the charts he has on this thread), but everyone praised his video. How many people spotted some glaring mistakes? Anyway i will post a snapshot of one here.

Keep it simple - follow Arjun and thats all
.
.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: gibr-lots.png Size: 87 KB
Quoting aryary
...

He maybe trading multiple accounts - no idea, does he trade at all? Like i said there is one thing trading and another thing presenting charts. I can see this with experience. False hopes to new traders is not a good thing at all, this is real money.

...
.
Golden words of wisdom...

If I may add to what you wrote...

"Like i said there is one thing trading and another thing presenting charts" after the facts.
Quoting ejiexe

I went through senior members post and there is no one that matches GIbril' analysis. .
I disagree.That's rather bold statement infused by personal trappings.
Objectively I find Emmanuel,Aryary,Ciara,Arjun's analyses (they are more) insightful and logical.I don't need bold red 20 size fonts screaming posts...

To me someone who can manipulate posting fabricated charity work is pure charlatan and frankly I can care less about everything else including all his "work".
In trading, you have to be defensive and aggressive at the same time
keep an eye on EJ
Its about to break 10EMA to south
53.5 now
In trading, you have to be defensive and aggressive at the same time
Quoting Davit
keep an eye on EJ
Its about to break 10EMA to south
53.5 now

Be careful... It is now sitting just above RN and 4 Hr 10ema, then just below all this is the
50ema. This time of the afternoon it could just bounce around on these levels for awhile before
making a break up or down.
Kilo
Quoting Davit
keep an eye on EJ
Its about to break 10EMA to south
53.5 now
Nice call. But timing is important. I will wait till tokyo may be we may see 106.70 area for rejection. Thanks for the info
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GOOD AND EXCELLENT IS ATTENTION TO DETAILS.
Quoting BorisViven
Sister Ciara,

like many others in this thread i feel sad, i learnt so many things from this guy, and i trusted him..
Like you i hope he will explain..

Peace
dom
ever wondered how many years of experience you would need to have with the market to be able to pick entries and exits like that?
here comes the guy who claims he has less than a year of experience to be able to trade like that should have raise the red flag. not to mention a 25yr old girl, claims 5yrs of market experience? gotta have a chuckle at this. lol
Quoting Davit
I disagree.That's rather bold statement infused by personal trappings.
Objectively I find Emmanuel,Aryary,Ciara,Arjun's analyses (they are more) insightful and logical.I don't need bold red 20 size fonts screaming posts...

To me someone who can manipulate posting fabricated charity work is pure charlatan and frankly I can care less about everything else including all his "work".
Fortunately for the scam artists, most people don't believe the way you do...After all these evidents, there are still people coming to the defend of this he/she/it person.

OMG, when are people going to realize that analysis and fake-trading AFTER THE FACTS don't and can't make them money???
Quoting aryary
Hi mate...,

The whole idea behind Arjun's thread is honesty and transparency.

.....
I do not wish to keep posting such items (even look at the charts he has on this thread), but everyone praised his video, yes good. How many people spotted some glaring mistakes? Anyway i will post a snapshot of one here.
.....
Keep it simple - follow Arjun and thats all
.
.


Well done, mate. Have to add, that lot size is hilarious (no mistakes --- only compared with what he posted when we asked him)..

What is important is that we get rid of negative energy - the positive energy was the real force behind this Thread. And sharing your knowledge to others. This is a also a warning for future attempts of having different purposes, targets, other then the ones brother Arjun has been able to incorporate into his Thread. You will be discovered! And right so.

We are only guests here..I've learned a lot..even from Gibril..so I forgive him. Arjuns good name has been misused - the thing he will have to forgive (I think he's done it already).

To you, brothers and sisters, focus on trading, focus on good things here. Follow the rules ARjun shared FOR FREE with us and if u start to seeing the light (I am) share this with others. If you make good money, dont just leave, but give some back by posting your setups and trades. More than the successful trades themselves..post the reasons for taking them.

Brother Emmanuel's posts are usually not directly related to the method - he is giving us added value (like cherry topper) on top of everything. U may use CS formations for reentris, for SLs etc..and to spot out the right setup a bit earlier (very important). Thank you Emmanuel. Appreciated.
We need to move on, to share and to care...if u take any good out of these posts.

I will keep on posting here and hope we make our house clean and attractive again.

Love u all,

(brother) Ciara
Ideas shape the course of history
Does it mean Gibril has finally flew. Let give him 48hrs to answer. Otherwise, I implore everyone that vouch for him remove the vouch please.
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GOOD AND EXCELLENT IS ATTENTION TO DETAILS.
He may be reading now
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: gib.jpg Size: 101 KB
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GOOD AND EXCELLENT IS ATTENTION TO DETAILS.
Quoting pkimnyc
ever wondered how many years of experience you would need to have with the market to be able to pick entries and exits like that?
here comes the guy who claims he has less than a year of experience to be able to trade like that should have raise the red flag. not to mention a 25yr old girl, claims 5yrs of market experience? gotta have a chuckle at this. lol
I was under impression Chinese actress photo shoot was one of us traders from Mongolia!
this is hilarious! This thread is sure entertaining to say the least.One can't complain being bored of trading.Little drama spices things up
In trading, you have to be defensive and aggressive at the same time
Quoting Gibril
To some people takng from others is just like a thief.........

Never know how to show gratituted.


http://forexnforums.blogspot.com/p/strategies.html


http://forexsuccess.webs.com/

I wrote to him and ask him to quote the source to respect the Great man


Gibril

So he is the one!!!
THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN GOOD AND EXCELLENT IS ATTENTION TO DETAILS.
0 traders viewing now