Astrology is much more complex then people first expect as i seeI have no idea how to read planet-sign relationship for a specific trading instrument... I once read Mercury - Gold relationship for two signs (Sagittarius and Capricorn). May be better to more concentrate on declination studies and only consider important astrological events grouped in a short time frame to catch polarity shifts on cycles.
Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD)
- #5,123
- Sep 28, 2012 12:23pm Sep 28, 2012 12:23pm
- Joined May 2008 | Status: Gannalist | 1,184 Posts
By the chance may be you saw this but a good study worth sharing on this forum
at the risk of becoming the grumpiest individual on this thread, i do have to point out a failure in that logic. 
all discussions about pips per angle are fantastic for individual planets, however, just as with individual aspects or "rulers", i have to protest against the same thing here. There are no on or off switches.
It would be unlogical to assume that if you were to take 120 pips per degree for one planet, that all other planets have no influence at that time. In other words, you cannot take 120 degrees for said planet, because you will have to compound the pips-per-degree for the other planets as well.
You can however take a fixed amount of pips per degree per planet if you want to compund them, because a flexible amount (based on distance, speed etc.) would be a horrible task to calculate, even automated.
But having a "fan" line based on 1 planet with a "normal" pips per degree would get you only so far, not all the way.
just my 2 cents, sorry.
all discussions about pips per angle are fantastic for individual planets, however, just as with individual aspects or "rulers", i have to protest against the same thing here. There are no on or off switches.
It would be unlogical to assume that if you were to take 120 pips per degree for one planet, that all other planets have no influence at that time. In other words, you cannot take 120 degrees for said planet, because you will have to compound the pips-per-degree for the other planets as well.
You can however take a fixed amount of pips per degree per planet if you want to compund them, because a flexible amount (based on distance, speed etc.) would be a horrible task to calculate, even automated.
But having a "fan" line based on 1 planet with a "normal" pips per degree would get you only so far, not all the way.
just my 2 cents, sorry.
- #5,129
- Sep 29, 2012 1:59pm Sep 29, 2012 1:59pm
- Joined Apr 2012 | Status: ipsa scientia potestas est | 682 Posts
Yes there is a great harmony among the three biggest body of our solar system The Sun, Jupiter & Saturn... In one year sun moves 360 degrees = Jupiter 30 degrees = Saturn 12 degrees additionally moon 12*360 degrees... And a year 12 months and a month 30 days appr.
Honestly I preferred to look with an empirical view to techniques
But harmony between planets stated above can be the reason. Because of the elliptical orbit of the planets, their speed changes but change is not dramatic(From Heliocentric view) Every planet individually effect price movement. So their total is also important. That's why GANN used averages of all planets as well....
Honestly I preferred to look with an empirical view to techniques
But harmony between planets stated above can be the reason. Because of the elliptical orbit of the planets, their speed changes but change is not dramatic(From Heliocentric view) Every planet individually effect price movement. So their total is also important. That's why GANN used averages of all planets as well.... - #5,130
- Sep 29, 2012 7:44pm Sep 29, 2012 7:44pm
- Joined May 2008 | Status: Gannalist | 1,184 Posts
Yes there is a great harmony among the three biggest body of our solar system The Sun, Jupiter & Saturn... In one year sun moves 360 degrees = Jupiter 30 degrees = Saturn 12 degrees additionally moon 12*360 degrees... And a year 12 months and a month 30 days appr.
Honestly I preferred to look with an empirical view to techniques
Speed changes the price angle, that goes for small trends and big trends. But all cycles repeat.
I called my bank and told them to deposit several planet and moon cycles. They hung up the phone on me.
Anyway, thanks, you were statistically in time to make sceptic remarks, so you proved me right and i won a drink
- #5,133
- Sep 30, 2012 6:56am Sep 30, 2012 6:56am
- | Commercial User | Joined Oct 2010 | 1,137 Posts
Had you called a real bank they would have invited you for a job interview instead... so even if you "rofl" virtually, you might be surprised in real life.
Anyway, thanks, you were statistically in time to make sceptic remarks, so you proved me right and i won a drink
No wonder Gann kept it so well hidden, I can see why.
All the best
Mike
- #5,134
- Sep 30, 2012 6:58am Sep 30, 2012 6:58am
- Joined May 2008 | Status: Gannalist | 1,184 Posts
Had you called a real bank they would have invited you for a job interview instead... so even if you "rofl" virtually, you might be surprised in real life.