ichimoku-clouds Breakout

unimak said it well...

the info is in this thread for free, if you need to be spoon fed, then you need to pay to have your hand held. i don't see what the issue is. Either you are the type of person who likes research or your the type of person who likes for others to do the research for you. If you do your own homework then you don't have any added cost, your fee is your time and effort. If you want someone else to do the work, then you should expect to pay...

Good system zamanib! Dont care about the critics.

Well Said--

Well said- thank you

Well said thank you

please
ZAMANIB SUPERTREND_V1
can you post mql file?
or do you have write in c++ for sierra chart?
please thank you

Just wanna say find out your own style, your own strategy..I got enough from My trades already and this is not for sale.

Good Luck

Hi all, I was way for a while and then I noticed that FF moved this thread to Commercial Forum, my first thought was "that's crazy" no matter what Zamanib decided, he gave us legit tools to make money consistently. Of course with good money management and self discipline, if you stick to the rules and follow this system from post 1, you will make money. After you gain confidence suite it for your trading style. Zamanib gave us this system for free and this system works and don't cry like a little baby if new shiny toy came up in store .. I still love my old Lego blocks.

Thank you bro--

Why is it crazy? Zamanib is selling his time and his U Turn indicator, how is not "commercial"?

I traded the original system as per Post 1, it is a good system that generate pips and it is FREE.

I then spend countless screen time study, research & testing to find a way to better suit my trading style with range bar. And now, I managed to fine tune it to suit my trading style and it really a pips generator.

I would advice those that interested to trade the original system from Post 1, stick to the rules and hang in there, u will make pips everyday. From there put in your time and effort to fine tune the system to suit suit your own trading style if you want more.

Pls do not demand too much, he is not obligated to share with us whatever he has. Zamanib already give us a Free & profitable system as in Post #1.

Thanks again Zamanib, you are such a kind and selfless guy, god bless.

... qqsamudra...

It appears you are not using the clouds. How is your chart relevant to Zamanib's thread?

Richard in Colorado

Good point-- I was going to say that-- but you did it -- thank you

SuperT Matrix is out-- Can be trades with -- cloud and rangebars

Hello Zamanib... which is the latest indicator of the lines.... the crossing

will be free -- here you go used with any rangebar and cloudlines settings

Hey Zaman,

Thanks for the indicators! I am grateful for all the stuff you have given for FREE in this thread to help people make money trading. I am using the ichimoku and range bars (along with some other free stuff I found here and there) and it really is working to make more profits than losses. Let me repeat it more clearly... I am just using free stuff - not any bought indicators.

And, if I may, I would like to make an overall comment about the criticisms you have received for selling stuff here. I believe that capitalism is the best system on earth. If I have something that people want I can either keep it to myself, give it away or sell it. If people want it badly enough they will pay for it. If not, then they won't. It's that simple. If people want your premium stuff for free, then why shouldn't they expect to get your car for free, or your home for free. It's really the same thing. Think about it.

Making money is not bad - it's good. After all, isn't that why we all are here reading these forums - to make money? I know that's why I'm here. I want to make a ton of money.

One more thing... Zaman, since they have deemed you a commercial member, why not just let it all hang out and post an itemized list (with individual prices) of whatever you have to sell. Bring it all out in the open. Be a real capitalist. Then we can all decide whether to buy or not. That's capitalism!

Richard in Colorado

There are some very confused people on this thread. And I don't think it's a coincidence that their message is the same; that would be consistent with the actions of a concert party or a few individuals posting under multiple user names.

So, let's consider their argument; Zamanib has given something free and that's good – no argument there; Zamanib is entitled to charge for his time and effort – no argument there either (although not one of these individuals took this stance when it came to obtaining illegally distributed rangebar material which some of them, and perhaps all of them, are using, so no moral high ground can be claimed.). The point is this, and this is what all the fellaters have missed, that it is against the rules of FF to do both at the same time. As soon as anyone decides to make money from Forex, they are required to declare this interest and to become a Commercial Member, as, for example, Titch and Colostarr did. This is in order to protect the very people who are bleating in his defence, the noobs with a few posts who can't trade for themselves, haven't posted 1 constructive post between them and can't tell a scammer from a small patch of brown liquid, possibly creosote.

So, what has Zamanib given us so far? Rangebars and the Kumo. He didn't create either of these concepts, and perhaps deserves credit for putting them together, but is what he has given a system, a methodology? I think not. There is no defined rangebar size, no hard SL or TP, no trade management, no trade calls, no logs of trades over a decent period of time, no P&L, no statement from Strategy Tester, just sporadic claims from pet poodles like Sissi, (whose 1000 pips from January is actually 500 pips to most traders) posted after the fact, and intermittent charts illustrating successful trades, during trends which anyone except Forex Girl could have traded successfully.

Now we have the Supertrend and the Kumo, using settings Casperby figured out immediately. Incidentally, has anyone noticed the development in the chart in post #955? Sell above the Kumo and buy below the Kumo – well, that's new. Shurely shome mishtake? So it's now not even Supertrend and Kumo, it's just Supertrend, maybe with a few spurious filtering rules thrown in, although there seems to be no mention of this anywhere. Again, nothing original.

The Traffic Light system was offered at $2,000, although it seems that may now be $1,500. Again, nothing new here, just 5 different versions of the Kumo to filter out some trades, and a chart hurredly removed before it could be figured out. Alas, too late. And how would this system have fared during the last few days, using 8pip rangebars? Not very well, I can tell you, but how would you know? Well, you'd just have to take Zamanib's word for it.

Finally we come to the U Turn. A system using the Kumo, and candles which call the Uturn 'like magic'. Once again, these candles are not Zamanib's work, but that of the well respected SwingMan, who has given this work free to the FF community, so what right does Zamanib have to charge for their use? Perhaps he can claim some degree of originality for putting them together with the Kumo, but this is not hard work and not even anything which could be claimed as intellectual property, as anyone is free to do the same. What SwingMan thinks of this is as yet unknown, but apart from being one of the best coders ever to grace FF, he's also a kind and generous man, so it's entirely possible that he won't mind his work being distributed to help others. This raises the question of whether Zamanib should profit from another's work, but no doubt the capitalist Richard from the red river State would approve of screwing a worker or two.

Anyone on this thread should ask himself why Zamanib has decided to sell his methods. He is not a full time trader, as he works for Cisco according to the Skype conversation I had with him.

[12/01/2012 14:23:09] fxtradewin: see siiissss
[12/01/2012 14:23:54] fxtradewin: result
[12/01/2012 14:23:59] fxtradewin: she is doing well
[12/01/2012 14:25:32] fxtradewin: i dont trade all the time
[12/01/2012 14:25:43] fxtradewin: i am very bussy with business
[12/01/2012 14:25:54] fxtradewin: i am cisco engineer
[12/01/2012 14:25:57] fxtradewin: ccie voice

But even as a part time retail trader if his methods were as sound as he claims and had been thought through fully until they could constitute coherent strategies, it would be more worthwhile for him to trade them than to sell them, as he would be able to give up his job within a year at most, if he could replicate sissi's claimed results.

So, to the wee keechs who have been posting in support of Zamanib: get your facts right and think things through. You can't use the rangebar and Kumo strategy which you have as justification for Zamanib having broken the FF rules, the two are mutually exclusive. Neither is your support of any help to Zamanib in his quest to become a successful Forex system seller. (Anyone else remember his User Title? I AM A MENTOR NOT A SALESMAN. Well, not any more) Zamanib's ability to market his stuff to noobs is now severely restricted and rightly so. The best thing he could do is go away and work out a marketing strategy which doesn't involve FF. This is actually in his own best interests, as the scope for selling stuff on FF is poor and Zamanib doesn't really have the credibility required to sell to members, not unless he's prepared to post charts, call live trades, run Stratgey Tester (if he knows how to with rangebars), and all over a period of time much longer than would be needed to set up a website where fools would be only too willing to part with $2,000 for any old rubbish.

Right on the napper. Stitch that.

Brotyboy's summary seems a very fair one to me

I have asked Zamanib numerous times to post some more examples of the U Turn indicator, how anyone can expect people to part with $2,000 based on one screenshot baffles me, perhaps there are some truly gullible people out there.

And I also can't understand why anyone is complaining that Zamanib has been made a Commercial member. Yes, the thread started with some free indicators (although neither were his creation),but he is now selling U Turn for $2,000 and, although TL is free, you have to have 1-2-1 training at a cost of $1,500 to get this "free" indicator

There are no purely mechanical entry and exit rules, and profitable trades are shown after the event.

All in all a rather sad decline in what could have been a promising thread.

Andy