Menu
Sister Sites

Options

Bookmark Thread

First Page First Unread Last Page Last Post

Print Thread

Similar Threads

Forecast Forex using Numeric Cycles and Astrology Cycles 36 replies

Planetary cycles, astrological theory of cycles of the markets 495 replies

Planetary / Astrology indicators 3 replies

Planetary Cycles... Plotting Cycles into the Future 0 replies

Opinions on "Planetary cycles, astrological theory .. of the markets" 40 replies

Attachments: Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD)
Exit Attachments

Planetary Cycles Trading (EUR/USD)

Quoting Suryananda
Free books:

http://cura.free.fr/DIAL.html#AA
Thanks Suryananda
Quoting dragan53
have u guys actually made money trading planetary cycles or is it just blabering?
A better question is whether their propositions are falsifiable. The problem is that most planetary traders don't know about falsifiability. wikipedia's pages on homeopathy and astrology are illustrative guides to applying Karl Popper falsification. Once you grasp the concept you will realize that most technical analysis are colorful hogwash on a chart.
Quoting StephanusR
A better question is whether their propositions are falsifiable. The problem is that most planetary traders don't know about falsifiability. wikipedia's pages on homeopathy and astrology are illustrative guides to applying Karl Popper falsification. Once you grasp the concept you will realize that most technical analysis are colorful hogwash on a chart.
most technical indicators are based on moving averages nd strenght and weakness,but that can be seen in 1m & 5m chart very well,and indis just lag after price
Quoting dragan53
most technical indicators are based on moving averages nd strenght and weakness,but that can be seen in 1m & 5m chart very well,and indis just lag after price
Moving averages especially aren't falsifiable. One could choose any type of cross-over system. The 200day mov average is arbitrary, why not the 189? The problem is that most traders don't have the mental acumen to comprehend this.
80 smooth is a good one,
'i myself invented a ma smoothed,system 9,18 smoothed its easy,but as i look at 1m,5m chart i kind of find myself with price action and analysing patterns,
Quoting StephanusR
Moving averages especially aren't falsifiable. One could choose any type of cross-over system. The 200day mov average is arbitrary, why not the 189? The problem is that most traders don't have the mental acumen to comprehend this.
whats ur trading style trend or ?

i havent found my true style yet,im getting close though ,using 1h with 80ma smothed slope direction line on eurusd for analysing trends,and 1m 5m i use to get intraday action
Quoting dragan53
have u guys actually made money trading planetary cycles or is it just blabering?
Dear Dragan53, yes I use planetary positioning and aspecting for trading successfully. Don't bother about people like StaphanUs who do not have the mathematical (statistical) abillities to verify these techniques for themselves and demand proof and statements from tax authorities and all that nonsense, it comes and goes just like the jokes about Uranus ;-)

Fact of the matter is that the markets do not move a pip in a direction that you cannot know beforehand.

I spend 8 years proving for myself that it works, if there are people who "demand" to prove or disprove this, then I believe the onus is on them. Why should I feel the responsibility to do this? Now, it is a different story if these people were to be interested in finding out what it is what we do and based on that information try to prove or disprove something for themselves. In that light, please if you are interested in understanding the workings of what we do, please feel free to ask and the answers will come.
Quoting dragan53
whats ur trading style trend or ?

i havent found my true style yet,im getting close though ,using 1h with 80ma smothed slope direction line on eurusd for analysing trends,and 1m 5m i use to get intraday action
50 and 20 SMA on 1 hour chart work well.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: MA.JPG Size: 58 KB
Quoting Ilovepippin
50 and 20 SMA on 1 hour chart work well.
i had a look on ur blog,because i really want to inderstand elliot wave but its just too difficult,so ill just look on ur take of elliot wave in the future ,i saw on eurusd 4h that ur forecast is bearish,i also saw that todd gordon from aspentrading and forex.com technical team,said that its gonna go down,so good guess i followed his analysis on elliot wave and made 110 pips so nice stuff there fellas,

is this a good forecast?
http://twitpic.com/3edo62


sti
quote
""Dear Dragan53, yes I use planetary positioning and aspecting for trading successfully. Don't bother about people like StaphanUs who do not have the mathematical (statistical) abillities to verify these techniques for themselves and demand proof and statements from tax authorities and all that nonsense, it comes and goes just like the jokes about Uranus ;-)""

hmm ,if u made consistent gains on it,than it must work for sure,i dont know how;
many of the major politicians and bankers in top european and u.s banks are in societys like freemasons and other cults,do u think they might be manipulating the markets on the course of the astrology ? how do u actually forecast that its gonna the way it is,using astrological stuff???
i remember i watched wall street warriors tv show,and sandra went to a financial astrologer,she didnt really belieave in his works at first,but after year the stuff he said is gonna happen happened;she met a rich guy and are together now,or something like that,im not really sure what happened fully
ouh actually i made a mistake ur chart of s5 looks similae to todays chart of eurusd ,and a pretty much the same forecast,but its from september,lol,how did i miss that?
dragan53,

the count you have provided the link in your post #2549 is not correct. The pattern since the last high is corrective and not impulsive - intersection between wave i and iv is not possible in a normale impulse.

See post #3181 for the correct solution:
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...01169&page=213

Sixer
Quoting dragan53
hmm ,if u made consistent gains on it,than it must work for sure,i dont know how;
many of the major politicians and bankers in top european and u.s banks are in societys like freemasons and other cults,do u think they might be manipulating the markets on the course of the astrology ?
No, not a chance, because there is historical data available for Gold and Silver that goes way way back in time, and all graphs follow the same rules. Don't forget that a centruy ago, one of the first westerners to have his hand at this was William Gann, he was a Freemason. Don't believe all the negative things you hear about Freemasonry. On the other hand, don't believe all the stuff about Gann making 50 million dollars either. There is just no way that he was able to do by hand what can be done with a computer today.


Quoting dragan53
how do u actually forecast that its gonna the way it is,using astrological stuff???
In the course of my studies, I have found evidence only of 2 things. The planets have their effect only when in aspect with Earth, not with eachother. When there are no aspects of this type going on, the market is moving allong lines of aspects of the Moon. The strongest lines are those of the longtitude of the moon and the lines between new-moon full moon. And the new-moon/full-moon with Lilith (As if Lilith were the Sun).
This is all you need, but you need to be able to program it all, and that's where the majority of people are just not in a position to test it.
Quoting Sixer
dragan53,

the count you have provided the link in your post #2549 is not correct. The pattern since the last high is corrective and not impulsive - intersection between wave i and iv is not possible in a normale impulse.

See post #3181 for the correct solution:
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...01169&page=213

Sixer
thanks for reply ,but i do not understand much what u said,since my knowledge of waves is low,i have to start learning,
im gonna start with a book called Prechter__Robert-_The_Elliott_Waves_Principles
?any suggestions of where else i can learn waves ?except ff,some great books would be nice
dragan53,

start with the following link before you buy the Prechter book:

http://www.actionforex.com/education...-200411145694/

Read the part about "corrective patterns" more carefully than the rest.

Sixer
Quoting Sti
Dear Dragan53, yes I use planetary positioning and aspecting for trading successfully. Don't bother about people like StaphanUs who do not have the mathematical (statistical) abillities to verify these techniques for themselves and demand proof and statements from tax authorities and all that nonsense, it comes and goes just like the jokes about Uranus ;-)

Fact of the matter is that the markets do not move a pip in a direction that you cannot know beforehand.

I spend 8 years proving for myself that it works, if there are people who "demand"...
I have been for 6 years working with statistics on astrology, AT and neural networks. Astrology is what works best.
Quoting Suryananda
I have been for 6 years working with statistics on astrology, AT and neural networks. Astrology is what works best.
really?what does astrology say about eurusd?
Quoting Sti
No, not a chance, because there is historical data available for Gold and Silver that goes way way back in time, and all graphs follow the same rules. Don't forget that a centruy ago, one of the first westerners to have his hand at this was William Gann, he was a Freemason. Don't believe all the negative things you hear about Freemasonry. On the other hand, don't believe all the stuff about Gann making 50 million dollars either. There is just no way that he was able to do by hand what can be done with a computer today.



In the course of...
Dear Sti,

I can upload tables of the gold and silver price since the thirteenth century in England.

Best wishes.
Hello Suryananda,
I am agree with you, astrology works effectively. I am trying to learn Vedic Astrology. If you dont mind, let me tell you one interesting thing abt your name.
According to Sanskrit language (which is old scripture language), the meaning of your name is " Son of Sun". which is very powerful & auspicious name.
Quoting Sti
No, not a chance, because there is historical data available for Gold and Silver that goes way way back in time, and all graphs follow the same rules. Don't forget that a centruy ago, one of the first westerners to have his hand at this was William Gann, he was a Freemason. Don't believe all the negative things you hear about Freemasonry. On the other hand, don't believe all the stuff about Gann making 50 million dollars either. There is just no way that he was able to do by hand what can be done with a computer today.



In the course of...
that sounds like a whole uni degree has to be done on this,i just dont have the knowldge to understand this system,
any way is the analysis done in
weekly or monthly charts?
is there any indicators on mt4 that predict these type of events?
1 trader viewing now