vsa with Malcolm | Page 333 | Forex Factory

Options

Go to
Permalinks
Print Thread

Similar Threads

VSA-divergence trading 187 replies

How to Blow $200 account using VSA--- 594 replies

VSA Journal 57 replies

VSA broker history change datas 11 replies

Attachments: vsa with Malcolm
Exit Attachments

vsa with Malcolm

  • #6,641
  • Nov 12, 2010 2:31am Nov 12, 2010 2:31am
Quoting tfflyer
So Mal, one more time...

Why are You showing me post KNOW which is 90 mins before where You are writing that You are out of EU.. but 35 mins ago You wrote sold ( and also posted it 25 mins after it....

Somehow not logical specially with this last post which is 90 mins old and refering to me it know. ..


Juhanimi... if You just would looked to what i said, You would understand what i am talking about.

Just wanted to found some logic, if You see it very logical - tell me what is there logical



Best,
Tom
There was actually complete logic and it made sense ... Malcolm did say he was in a long, but then got stopped out (didn't have the 'courage' I think he said). I tried following along on the EU VSA action and would have done the same thing. I in fact took 10 pip profits in different directions, because I can't time it as well as Malcolm ... don't know your trading style, but at potential reversal points like this, I can be in multiple positions & directions, and be in get stopped out multiple times ... Malcolm is cool enough to report it all.

Don't really get why people make issues out of this - don't know about you, but if one is trading real money - and not microlots - there's nothing easy about this - I'm trying to minimize the gut wrenching feel in my stomach ASAP, that a bad trade would bring.
  • #6,642
  • Nov 12, 2010 2:37am Nov 12, 2010 2:37am
Yes yes yes.. i have hard understanding.. learning disability, etc.... As You wish

Perhaps, that why i see no logic in some of Your posts and just asking You exact questions, where You all time are starting to talk about something else..

Instead of answering to my exact answers, You are refering something about managing accounts, trading signals, etc...

You didn't answered nothing about why You were refering to Your old post about EU . I yet cant see any logic

Mal, i am not saying that all Your posts are like "this" and You are not good person in helping others...

Best,
T



Quoting malcolmb14
So one more time for you Tom as you having a...
  • #6,643
  • Nov 12, 2010 2:40am Nov 12, 2010 2:40am
Anyone thinks buyers can have this one Friday for themselves? I'm still not convinced with this down move. Yes, I'm stubborn like that. While we had a little break out of the range during weird hours, I thought it was weird there was very little follow-through.

Just noticed EU going higher! Woo! We'll see for how long though
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: eu_m15_2010-11-12.png Size: 50 KB
  • #6,644
  • Edited 2:49am Nov 12, 2010 2:45am | Edited 2:49am
Beljevina, logic ?

1. I posted that Mal posted a trade 25 mins late that he is short EU when trade was already in profit.... Ok, no problem.
2. Mal saying i want trading signals that why i am refering .. Ok, let it be.. I have hard understanding etc etc etc.. that why i want trading signals, as he wish
3. After EU is starting going up he also added to me refering for his 90 min old post that i should think he is out of trade - Does he tough i will think that he posted this post just now instead of 90 mins before?

I don't say that Mal isn't BOSS in trading and .... i have nothing personal to him, i just asked why ?

Best,
Tom





Quoting Beljevina
There was actually complete logic and it made sense ... Malcolm did say he was in a long, but then got stopped out (didn't have the 'courage' I think he said). I tried following along on the EU VSA action and would have done the same thing. I in fact took 10 pip profits in different directions, because I can't time it as well as Malcolm ... don't know your trading style, but at potential reversal points like this, I can be in multiple positions & directions, and be in get stopped out multiple times ... Malcolm is cool enough to report it all.

Don't...
  • #6,645
  • Nov 12, 2010 2:48am Nov 12, 2010 2:48am
Quoting comapip
Anyone thinks buyers can have this one Friday for themselves? I'm still not convinced with this down move. Yes, I'm stubborn like that. While we had a little break out of the range during weird hours, I thought it was weird there was very little follow-through.

Just noticed EU going higher! Woo! We'll see for how long though
M15 has a good angle up, and long from 09, hope this will go that daily range all the way up.
  • #6,646
  • Nov 12, 2010 2:50am Nov 12, 2010 2:50am
Quoting tfflyer
Beljevina, logic ?

1. I posted that Mal posted a trade 25 mins late that he is short EU when trade was already in profit.... Ok, no problem.
2. Mal saying i want trading signals that why i am refering .. Ok, let it be.. I have hard understanding etc etc etc.. that why i want trading signals, as he wish
3. After EU is starting going up he also added to me refering in his post 90 min old post that i should think he is out of trade - Does he tough i will think that he posted this trade just now instead of 90 mins before?

I don't say that...
So go back, look at the chart, see what happened at that time. Then, if you see something you don't understand, post a chart here and ask a question instead of posting something obscure.
  • #6,647
  • Nov 12, 2010 2:58am Nov 12, 2010 2:58am
Comapip, i see what happened on chart, but i am not sure You want to see what happens in posting.

Green pips.

Best,
T

Quoting comapip
So go back, look at the chart, see what happened at that time. Then, if you see something you don't understand, post a chart here and ask a question instead of posting something obscure.
  • #6,648
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:03am Nov 12, 2010 3:03am
51 % that it will test 1.3610

Best,
Tom

Quoting juhanimi
M15 has a good angle up, and long from 09, hope this will go that daily range all the way up.
  • #6,649
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:04am Nov 12, 2010 3:04am
Quoting tfflyer
...
I don't say that Mal isn't BOSS in trading and .... i have nothing personal to him, i just asked why ?

Best,
Tom

Hello Tom

I wander if this correspondence between you and Mal is related to his comment regarding your sale of Trade Guider software back in August 2010? Maybe you should PM him and tell him all what you think about him and his trading....

I think that this great thread should be clean from personal issues...

Regards
The Market pays you to be disciplined
  • #6,650
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:06am Nov 12, 2010 3:06am
Quoting tfflyer
Beljevina, logic ?

1. I posted that Mal posted a trade 25 mins late that he is short EU when trade was already in profit.... Ok, no problem.
2. Mal saying i want trading signals that why i am refering .. Ok, let it be.. I have hard understanding etc etc etc.. that why i want trading signals, as he wish
3. After EU is starting going up he also added to me refering for his 90 min old post that i should think he is out of trade - Does he tough i will think that he posted this post just now instead of 90 mins before?

I don't say that Mal...
I was following along on the forum and clearly remember Malc's posts ... yes, I recall that #1 item being about 10 or so min after the fact ... Malc was also in 2 other forums helping there, & posting about ES. Again, I recall it all because I was rather convinced we were going to see some form of a EURUSD turnaround.

I sometimes spend ~10 min doctoring up a chart with arrows, boxes, etc ... these things do take time & if I post after the fact, I really don't care as I'm not out to prove or challenge anyone ... take it or leave it and move on.

As for the remainder, I have no idea what you're after or what the purpose is .. this is like arguing about the weather with the weather channel ... learn the stuff yourself, take & accept what is offered & what you deem valuable. I'm pretty certain you're stuck in some sort of a communication or cultural misunderstanding/gap on this issue ... it always amazes me that people contribute oodles of help & information, and then someone brings out the guillotine for something that rubs them. ... Honestly, this isn't worth any more of my time.
  • #6,651
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:06am Nov 12, 2010 3:06am
No, nothing with that.

About personal issues - i havent said anything about Mal, instead of that he is talking about personal things about me..

Best,
Tom

Quoting mima
Hello Tom

I wander if this corespondence between you and Mal is related to his comment regarding your sale of Trade Guider software back in August 2010? Maybe you should PM him and tell him all what you think about him and his trading....

I think that this great thread should be clean from personal issues...

Regards
  • #6,652
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:08am Nov 12, 2010 3:08am
Quoting malcolmb14
So one more time for you Tom as you having a hard time understanding .. maybe you have a learning disability
Personally I think this statement was a little rude and uncalled for, but hay, it's your thread.

I for one would actually like to thank Malcolm for showing us a great (and simple) system which has been working well of late. Here are the rules ...

1. When Malcolm says Buy ... Sell.
2. When Malcolm says Sell ... Buy.

Check the charts against post times ... works a treat
  • #6,653
  • Edited 5:14am Nov 12, 2010 3:09am | Edited 5:14am
Beljevina, You tell me why mal is refering to me old post that EU has hitted supply after he posted that he went long.

Simple question


EDIT:

I made nice mistake about that 90 min post.. sorry to alll, that post has nothing to do with what i said and ask question why he was refering it to me and it was unlogical.

So sorry to all for about that.

But about posting 25 min late .... That will be actual always , when so late posted

edit one more : And mal, in that time volume was huge for buyers and You told that there was tonn of supply...Where You took also short.. Sorry for loss, but as always, You are already in profit somehow

And Mal, no problem for Banning me from this thread


Best,
T

Quoting Beljevina
I was following along on the forum and clearly remember Malc's posts ... yes, I recall that #1 item being about 10 or so min after the fact ... Malc was also in 2 other forums helping there, & posting about ES. Again, I recall it all because I was rather convinced we were going to see some form of a EURUSD turnaround.

I sometimes spend ~10 min doctoring up a chart with arrows, boxes, etc ... these things do take time & if I post after the fact, I really don't care as I'm not out to prove or challenge anyone ... take it or leave it and move on.

As...
  • #6,654
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:11am Nov 12, 2010 3:11am



Best,
Tom



Quoting theGuru
Personally I think this statement was a little rude and uncalled for, but hay, it's your thread.

I for one would actually like to thank Malcolm for showing us a great (and simple) system which has been working well of late. Here are the rules ...

1. When Malcolm says Buy ... Sell.
2. When Malcolm says Sell ... Buy.

Check the charts against post times ... works a treat
  • #6,655
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:18am Nov 12, 2010 3:18am
Quoting tfflyer
Beljevina, You tell me why mal is refering to me old post that EU has hitted supply after he posted that he went long.

Simple question

Best,
T
OK, last time for me, I swear ... so I go long, everything looks good for a few minutes, supply comes along, thus sellers have arrived, the plan falls apart - as it often does & an astute trader catches it - and you exit your long, potentially going short. Makes sense to me, & I think that was the flow in this case. Regardless, over & out.

P.S. - looks like the initial Malcolm projection of buyers is working out - and boy am I thankful to be long. I am sure a retest will ensue, and I will prolly go BE on that one, but I've bagged 40 pips so far anyways. Sh*t happens, and we're all wrong.
  • #6,656
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:24am Nov 12, 2010 3:24am
Nice so far - 85 pips off the low ... did get in not too shabily @ above 1.36. Waiting for 1.367, and will shoot for a short, and see how the expected retest goes. Still seeing sellers, but presumably not as many given the direction.
Attached Image (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: 2010-11-12_042159.png Size: 27 KB
  • #6,657
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:27am Nov 12, 2010 3:27am
Quoting Beljevina
OK, last time for me, I swear ... so I go long, everything looks good for a few minutes, supply comes along, thus sellers have arrived, the plan falls apart - as it often does & an astute trader catches it - and you exit your long, potentially going short. Makes sense to me, & I think that was the flow in this case. Regardless, over & out.

P.S. - looks like the initial Malcolm projection of buyers is working out - and boy am I thankful to be long. I am sure a retest will ensue, and I will prolly go BE on that one, but I've bagged 40 pips so far...
Placed both tom and that other guy on the iggy list .. trying to keep this kind of stuff out of the thread.

I hate putting people on the iggy list but sometimes it has to be done

If i seemed rude to Tom I am sorry. He has been chirping on at me for weeks now.
Blogging daily now at www.volume.zone
  • #6,658
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:29am Nov 12, 2010 3:29am
Quoting Beljevina
Nice so far - 85 pips off the low ... did get in not too shabily @ above 1.36. Waiting for 1.367, and will shoot for a short, and see how the expected retest goes. Still seeing sellers, but presumably not as many given the direction.
I think DR G maybe right on the ES moving up tomorrow.

This should take eu and gu with it

1200 is key.
Blogging daily now at www.volume.zone
  • #6,659
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:31am Nov 12, 2010 3:31am
Quoting theGuru
Personally I think this statement was a little rude and uncalled for, but hay, it's your thread.

I for one would actually like to thank Malcolm for showing us a great (and simple) system which has been working well of late. Here are the rules ...

1. When Malcolm says Buy ... Sell.
2. When Malcolm says Sell ... Buy.

Check the charts against post times ... works a treat
lol.
do as u wish.

mal has always been a top contender for most posts here in FF.
what's my point? he has shared a significant chunk of his time (away from trading) posting here.
(im sure a LOT of newer traders want the more experienced guys to post in real-time --- some are even cocky enough to demand posting trades within seconds of entry, LOL)
anyone who cannot understand why mal & others in FF is/are posting belatedly is trading-/VSA-ignorant, insensitive, not trading a live account, &/or doesnt know how much time is involved in making a post.
i personally refrain from posting/posting charts, moreso recently, because it takes/has taken time away from my trading.



Hey Tom,
we are all VSA brothers & sisters (mal is in your buddy list for a good reason right), so at least let's respect each other.
if u dislike mal's posts, then it's best to stay away, for the sake of peace.
  • #6,660
  • Nov 12, 2010 3:36am Nov 12, 2010 3:36am
I must post one good example how i took 100 pips and also i think we can see lower EURJPY,i didnt have time to post on both forums setup i posted on EURJPY thread but i will post here also before and after becouse maybe will help to someone....


Here it is :
Cheers

Petar
Attached Image(s) (click to enlarge)
Click to Enlarge Name: hss.gif Size: 32 KB
Click to Enlarge Name: tp1hitjen.gif Size: 32 KB
"Buy on fear, sell on greed !!!
88 traders viewing now