Need an EA to help with J16 trades 1 reply
J16 thread. 2 replies
J16 pinbar discussion 7 replies
J16 Type Trades 60 replies
Dislikedwell i see your trading and i saw you got 2 win, 5 lost and around 4 break even , the only way your account gain is because in your 2 wining trade you are lucky to bet more money than your losing trade.
The old said: you could gain thousands of percent but you only lose 100 percent
although you are gaining but trade like you i doubt you could survive in a long runIgnored
Dislikedthe only way your account gain is because in your 2 wining trade you are lucky to bet more money than your losing trade.Ignored
DislikedShort Eur, risking 1% stop 3425, Daily IB, Divergence.
Target 1.3000 but will adjust depending on situations that arise.Ignored
DislikedHow do you even know he is gaining, with the way he has decided to post the trades, you can't know what he is doing. Example, last trade he got stopped, but he didn't even post his entry point. I had hopes when he opened the thread that he would be beneficial to james, but to tell you the truth, this thread harms more than helps as it is too convoluted, and in the end, nobody will know if he made money or not. Very dissappointed.Ignored
Dislikedwell i see your trading and i saw you got 2 win, 5 lost and around 4 break even , the only way your account gain is because in your 2 wining trade you are lucky to bet more money than your losing trade.
The old said: you could gain thousands of percent but you only lose 100 percent
although you are gaining but trade like you i doubt you could survive in a long runIgnored
DislikedHow do you even know he is gaining, with the way he has decided to post the trades, you can't know what he is doing. Example, last trade he got stopped, but he didn't even post his entry point. I had hopes when he opened the thread that he would be beneficial to james, but to tell you the truth, this thread harms more than helps as it is too convoluted, and in the end, nobody will know if he made money or not. Very dissappointed.Ignored
DislikedI doubt this was luck. Probably his loosing trades were based on a style that has a lower expected win rate % but Higher potential Risk/Reward ratio. So it makes sense to use a smaller position size with these type of trades.
Keep it up Mr SmithIgnored
DislikedHere's something I don't really understand, how can a trade be taken based only on some bar pattern ?, in this case some IB bar, divergence, etc, without taking notice with what's going on with the market sentiment/fundamentals, we just had the FOMC and the dollar bearish sign alias QE, then on top of that we got some good German Ifo numbers this morning.
And for the usd/jpy trade, at least is in the same direction as the BOJ but imo it got nothing to do with a pin bar, mickey mouse bar, jumping the fence bar, whatever bar. Now this trade will...Ignored
DislikedShort Eur, risking 1% stop 3425, Daily IB, Divergence.
Target 1.3000 but will adjust depending on situations that arise.Ignored
DislikedNo i see it's very clear man , he lost 100 pips on euro short and probably lost 200 pips on UJ long.
he posted real time trading . No bull shit or trick here but i just doubt about his first winning , that's all. He is the number one fan of James16 group, no doubt... James himself could not prove he is profitable , maybe Smith make the change?
we will need at least 200 trades before confirming anything.Ignored
Dislikedsomething is amiss here, going short when j16 himself goes long
http://www.forexfactory.com/showthre...27#post4047527
again, it's differences is perception which everyone is arguing about, and this trade goes to prove it - selling a subjective methodology is so advantageous, regardless if the intentions were good or bad
read, from the thread itself where the idea for this was born:
http://www.forexfactory.com/showpost...&postcount=113Ignored
DislikedSo what, bottom line is, I learnt from j16 thread how to make money,Ignored
QuoteDislikedand I do make money now cause of his thread.
QuoteDislikedIt's not a hidden fact that his teachings are not a hard set of rules.
DislikedHow do you even know he is gaining, with the way he has decided to post the trades, you can't know what he is doing. Example, last trade he got stopped, but he didn't even post his entry point. I had hopes when he opened the thread that he would be beneficial to james, but to tell you the truth, this thread harms more than helps as it is too convoluted, and in the end, nobody will know if he made money or not. Very dissappointed.Ignored
Disliked+1
You gonna display skill at least just take the trades you view of similar quality, i.e. fixed risk% or lot size at least per trade
Why confuse matters, I wonderIgnored